Votes v Dees

[George27]

4. Carlisle
4. Roberton

These two guys read the play very well - excellent intercept marking

3. Steele
2. Dunstan

Very good inside mids.

1. Sinclair. Great user again. Would like to see him get it more, but still worth a vote
1. Longer . More than held his own against strong opponent.

No votes from me for Billings. Got a lot of it, but his missed goals are so deflating.

[WellardSaint]

one vote to each of Dunstan and Steele.
2 votes to Jakey and Robbo.

The rest are hopeless, including Seb who gets the ball but gives it to a demon.

[Proph3t of egan]

5. Longer - more than held the best ruck in the game
4. Carlisle - absolute rock in defence especially in the 3rd term
3. Roberton - should be a shoe in for All-Australian, but will be robbed
2. Dunstan worked hard and carried both his and Stevens load, but faded later in the game
1. Membery - only forward that looked likely

Honourable mentions
White - one of the few who could be proud of their 1st halves, looks super composed
Bruce's mark - a ripper

[kosifantutti]

Roberton
Carlisle
Dunstan
Savage
Sinclair

[Sainter_Dad]

What the hell did Billings do wrong today that no-one has considered him in the votes - 14 kicks, 16 handballs, 9 marks - all with one eye - strength and courage personified.

[borderbarry]

And why all the love for Dunstan. He was shocking early. Could only find Melbourne players. He was not Robinson Crusoe, but had shocking turn overs early. Pleased that he got into the game later, but no votes from me.

[The Fireman]

-10 goal kicking coach

[borderbarry]

5. Roberton.
4. Carlisle
3. Billings
2. Longer
1. Sinclair

[avid]

4 Billings
3 Roberton
2 Carlisle
2 Sinclair
2 Longer
1 Gresham
1 Dunstan

[dals_da_bomb]

5 Steele
4 Billings
3 Roberton
2 Dunstan
1 Longer

.5 Billings eye - had a lot of impact this game

[carn_sainter]

Billings was poor. At least three contests near where i was watching where he went at half pace and Melbourne got the ball instead. He was flat as a tac. Dished the ball of instead of take responsibility and he was wasteful, especially in front of goal.

Carlisle
Roberton
Longer
Dunstan
Sinclair

Individuals are a moot point this week. We were thoroughly, comprehensively dismantled and smashed in the first half.

[George27]

What the hell did Billings do wrong today that no-one has considered him in the votes - 14 kicks, 16 handballs, 9 marks - all with one eye - strength and courage personified.

SainterDad. I am very appreciative of your work in tabulating the votes each week. I really enjoy trying to work out who are our best players . I scribble notes at the end of each quarter.

As to Billings, I refer you to my original post on this thread. Early on I had Billings as our best. However he had 5 shots for one goal. Yes he got the ball, but his kicking for goal is so wasteful. It really is deflating . So that is my answer to your question- an answer which I preempted in my initial votes.

You have a different opinion - no worries.

[desertsaint]

Roberton
Carlisle
Dunstan
Longer
Billings

[The OtherThommo]

Billings was poor. At least three contests near where i was watching where he went at half pace and Melbourne got the ball instead. He was flat as a tac. Dished the ball of instead of take responsibility and he was wasteful, especially in front of goal.

Carlisle
Roberton
Longer
Dunstan
Sinclair

Individuals are a moot point this week. We were thoroughly, comprehensively dismantled and smashed in the first half.

That's tripe.

[terry smith rules]

5 Billings
4 Gilbert
3 Longer
2 Roberton
1 Dunstan

re Gilbert I thought that he insitgated our turnaround at the end of the second quarter. He attacked, tried to break lines and got to so many contests. He continued that through the second half

[saintbob]

5 Steele
4 Billings
3 Carlisle
2 Roberton
1 Sinclair

[stonecold]

6: Longer
4: Steele
2: Robbo
2: Jake
1: Billings

[SemperFidelis]

4. Jake
3. Robbo
3. Billy
2. Gilbo
2. Sincs
1. JB

[Bernard Shakey]

Carlisle
Billings
Robertson
Sinclair
Longer

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Billings
4 - Longer
3 - Roberton
2 - Dunstan
1 - Savage
1 - Sinclair

0 - Melb crowd

[mr six o'clock]

5 smashed avocado
4 smoked salmon
3 cheese
2 sourdough brioche
1 cheese board

[thejiggingsaint]

5 smashed avocado
4 smoked salmon
3 cheese
2 sourdough brioche
1 cheese board

WHAT? No votes for sushi?

Discuss

[mr six o'clock]

5 smashed avocado
4 smoked salmon
3 cheese
2 sourdough brioche
1 cheese board

WHAT? No votes for sushi?

Discuss

Sushi started well but fell apart by the 3rd quarter
Cheese board whilst just laying there the whole game ,did keep the condiments apart , so deserved the 1 vote.

[Sainter_Dad]

49 Roberton
43 Carlisle
33 Longer
31 Billings
19 Dunstan
18 Steele
12 Sinclair
6 Gilbert
3 Savage
1 Gresham
1 Membrey

Therefore:
5 Roberton
4 Carlisle
3 Longer
2 Billings
1 Dunstan

[thejiggingsaint]

5 smashed avocado
4 smoked salmon
3 cheese
2 sourdough brioche
1 cheese board

WHAT? No votes for sushi?

Discuss

Sushi started well but fell apart by the 3rd quarter
Cheese board whilst just laying there the whole game ,did keep the condiments apart , so deserved the 1 vote.

Fair assessment.... BUT why did the sausage roll? AND the apple turnover?

Discuss