Carlisle

[ROLS-LEE]

Why don't we use him more coming out of defence or in genergy play. He is one of our few that can take a contested mark.

[Pwoit]

Why don't we use him more coming out of defence or in genergy play. He is one of our few that can take a contested mark.

And with foot skills

[Milne]

Carlisle is playing the role he needs to play perfectly. Anything more would just be a bonus.

[Premium89]

Bet I'm not the only one who said a hallelujah when he took that grab in the last quarter! All our forwards have been making that kind of stuff look damn hard (which it probably is)!!

[Joe Bloggs]

Probably our best player at the mo.

[saintbob]

Going beautifully at the minute

[Johnny Member]

Dude is a beast.

[philtee]

Very good today. Reads play superbly. Puts body on the line. Good decision maker.
Just sometimes takes a while to get to a contest.

[stkfc1]

If he stays injury free and gets a full pre season into him next year, I'll go as far to say will be in the top 5 big men in the league next year. If not Top 3.

[Proph3t of egan]

Probably our best player at the mo.

Billings and Ross are the other ones that come to mind

[The Fireman]

Roberton, Ross, Carlisle , Billings....keepers.

[mullet]

Why don't we use him more coming out of defence or in genergy play. He is one of our few that can take a contested mark.

And with foot skills

and a football brain

[Sainternist]

Loving the work of Cutthroat Jake. The guy is killing it week in, week out.

[ROLS-LEE]

Loving the work of Cutthroat Jake. The guy is killing it week in, week out.

I agree with all the statements above but he is capable of more and we don't use his strongest assets. Marking.

[Sainternist]

Loving the work of Cutthroat Jake. The guy is killing it week in, week out.

I agree with all the statements above but he is capable of more and we don't use his strongest assets. Marking.

Sure. Would be more than happy for him to add an extra string to his bow. How good was his goal today? I enjoyed that.

[mr six o'clock]

Hopefully he will be the match winner for us when we play the druggies in a couple of weeks

[Sainternist]

Hopefully he will be the match winner for us when we play the druggies in a couple of weeks

Their fans will be carrying on like pork chops every time he goes near the ball. I hope that'll only spur him on to want to stick it right up 'em!

[SemperFidelis]

Absolutely rapt with his "slow burn". After so many years with an undersized backline he and Browny are an absolute revelation.

I just feel a tad wistful that neither Chips nor Shinner got to play out a season or two with at least one of them.

[BigMart]

He's been ok

Not a great deal better than that

A lot of 5/10 to 7/10 games

[Jacks Back]

I know he's tall but he looks very slow. I think Chips or Dempster could be doing a better job if they were a few years younger.

[stonecold]

He's been ok

Not a great deal better than that

A lot of 5/10 to 7/10 games

Rubbish post Marto, you have no idea in regards to Bigmen, full stop!!!!!

Stick to what you know or have experienced, don't punch above your weight, or in this case height!!!!!

[Proph3t of egan]

I know he's tall but he looks very slow. I think Chips or Dempster could be doing a better job if they were a few years younger.

I tend to disagree. His running motion looks a bit lumbering, but he can cover the ground fairly quickly and is a pretty good athlete

[stonecold]

I know he's tall but he looks very slow. I think Chips or Dempster could be doing a better job if they were a few years younger.

Neither Chips or Shimmer were anywhere near as Tall as Jake!!!!!

[BigMart]

I'd like to know which games he's dominated?

He's been OK, good some games.

You must have been some ruckman/KPP Stoney... where was it again?

BTW... I'm not that small, nor that big, just a typical 6' mid
But it's not the size of the dog is it champ, just look at big Paddy

[stonecold]

I'd like to know which games he's dominated?

He's been OK, good some games.

You must have been some ruckman/KPP Stoney... where was it again?

BTW... I'm not that small, nor that big, just a typical 6' mid
But it's not the size of the dog is it champ, just look at big Paddy

Last time I looked champ, 183cm, NOT 178cm is 6ft!!!!!

Nothing wrong with Paddy's fight either Chief!!!!!