Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Jacks Back wrote:Out: Roo (rested), Weller (ankle) & maybe 8cres (he had a sore hamstring late in the game last week)
In: Bruce, Wright & Savage (if 8cres or Newnes is out)
I agree with the posters that are saying Bruce should not be recalled after last weekends effort, being thrashed by Liam Jones.
If Roo is rested, that leaves Paddy and Membrey. Maybe it is time to promote Marshall,although he missed last week. Now who do we have for CHB if Carlisle playies CHF?
Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
No but good pick up. Surprised the media missed it, but they are often too self absorbed with themselves
i am Melbourne Skies - sometimes Blue Skies, Grey Skies, even Partly Cloudy Skies.
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
I reckon Bailey Rice has to be close to a game. I think Brucey will be back along with Sav
In Springfield, they're eating the dogs. The people that came in, they're eating the cats. They’re eating – they are eating the pets of the people that live there.
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
For those confused,
Jill is Newnes.
Jack n Jill - so many Jack's out there.
Thanks Tony as always
A real Sainter will pledge allegiance to the ❤ and despise the Pies, the Blues, and the Injectors.
Remember one of the 10 Commandments : Thou shalt have no other team before thee
WellardSaint wrote:tony74 suggested that "maybe Bruce just needs to be managed "
Well, he's had his week off by all accounts. Will be good to have him back. As I've said, he's important for structure and also, I feel, to the chemistry of the side. Always gives a hard, physical contest.
I'd play him chf, though, with McCartin/Membrey deeper and permitted to lead.
bigcarl wrote:
I know. I said it in the context of him being managed as per tony74's post. You may have missed the irony. ie, two kicks for Sandy equals a week off.
if thats how the club is doing it nowadays then Longer (5) had a week off as well
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
No but good pick up. Surprised the media missed it, but they are often too self absorbed with themselves
I'm not sure it was even cramp. He turned the ball over and they kicked a goal. Then he reached for his hamstring. It might have just been deflection.
Macquarie Dictionary Word of the Year for 2023 "Kosi Lives"
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
No but good pick up. Surprised the media missed it, but they are often too self absorbed with themselves
I'm not sure it was even cramp. He turned the ball over and they kicked a goal. Then he reached for his hamstring. It might have just been deflection.
tony74 has since posted it was cramp.................. good enough for me to now accept t74's diagnosis.
loris wrote:Acres clutched at his hamstring and gingerly went off in the dying stages of the match against the Swans.
Haven't read anything about his hammy being a problem, maybe it was just cramp. Anyone else notice that from the game?
No but good pick up. Surprised the media missed it, but they are often too self absorbed with themselves
I'm not sure it was even cramp. He turned the ball over and they kicked a goal. Then he reached for his hamstring. It might have just been deflection.
I've been known to do that in my younger days... playing amateur footy, to save face after a turnover.
Do a big stretch and get to the next contest quickly and make amends.
Even in my last job in a call centre! an annoying customer who just wouldn't stop talking,
I would hang up on them, they'd ring back and speak to a colleague, who'd come over after and mention they'd just spoken to so-and-so
"Oh, the call dropped out, mobile phones do that sometimes!"
A real Sainter will pledge allegiance to the ❤ and despise the Pies, the Blues, and the Injectors.
Remember one of the 10 Commandments : Thou shalt have no other team before thee
The non-inclusion of Bruce is puzzling though. To me the forward line lacks leadership and a hard, experienced edge.
I don't expect that from Paddy yet. He's still struggling to find his feet. Nor Membrey. That's not his go.
I sincerely hope to be proven wrong, but it's as though we've conceded this match already. And if you look at the ladder only miniscule percentage separates the Bulldogs and us. They aren't that flash.
I reckon the Dogs barometer is Libba- he is their main man, not Bont. Worried about our forward line, no real focal point. We need the mids to really get amongst the goals and can't afford to have Jack S tagged out yet again.