Carslile incident

[borderbarry]

If he did spit on Jake, he should be rubbed out. And they should be able to pick it up on the replay if he did.

[Jacks Back]

What a gutless POS marc is…

From 28 touches today, 4 were contested and zero clearances, but he managed to sledge a player who was basically knocked unconscious…

What a skipper, perfect for the blues really.

It was his Jatz Crackers

[kosifantutti]

Just saw it on Fox.

It looks like he ran past and called him a soft bump.

[satchmo]

Just saw it on Fox.

It looks like he ran past and called him a soft bump.

Well then, he should get 50.

[saintbrat]

IF the AFL investigate- will the players 'tell' or hold to the code?

[CarlTaughtMeEnglish]

Everyone sitting around me leapt up from our seats as soon as Murphy turned to go to Jake. We were all watching as after the initial shakes of pain Jake hadn't moved. (pretty brave lying still in the middle of traffic like that) The guy next to me and I were already yelling abuse when Geary got to Murphy.

Watching the highlights and Carlisle was inset lying on the ground as the play went on. Unfortunately they removed the inset probably a second before Murphy would have come into shot. That camera would have still been rolling so hopefully Murphy gets outed on one of Fox's footy shows this week.

I will be interested in what fine Murphy gets when they are dished out. Will he get more for provoking the brawl or less for being the one who is attacked? With the Saints record the MRP will find a way to rub Geary out and do nothing to Murphy.

[Griggsy]

Everyone sitting around me leapt up from our seats as soon as Murphy turned to go to Jake. We were all watching as after the initial shakes of pain Jake hadn't moved. (pretty brave lying still in the middle of traffic like that) The guy next to me and I were already yelling abuse when Geary got to Murphy.

Watching the highlights and Carlisle was inset lying on the ground as the play went on. Unfortunately they removed the inset probably a second before Murphy would have come into shot. That camera would have still been rolling so hopefully Murphy gets outed on one of Fox's footy shows this week.

I will be interested in what fine Murphy gets when they are dished out. Will he get more for provoking the brawl or less for being the one who is attacked? With the Saints record the MRP will find a way to rub Geary out and do nothing to Murphy.

There was already footage shown from behind the goals level 2 maybe? the kind they use for mrp etc.

Murphey soft as they come, shame we won't see them again till 2018

[twirlyhair]

Saw it all unfold. Right in front of us. Really worked in our favour I think. Totally fired us all up where we were sitting. Great response from our lads, particularly our captain. Stupid from Murphy to say the least.

[ace]

Just saw it on Fox.

It looks like he ran past and called him a soft bump.

Well then, he should get 50.

50
Rubbed out until well into 2019 should finish his career.

[saintspremiers]

The MRP will just issue a fine or probably do nothing. You can't rub out a Carlton captain. Gilligan will have none of that.

[thejiggingsaint]

It was a dog act but ( imho ) the MRP will take a look at it, then move on. In some respects, I'm sometimes puzzled at how some AFL fans yearn for the " good old days " before footy became (quote) "sanitised", an era when this sort of behaviour was commonplace, but then get outraged about Murphy's conduct yesterday. Interesting.

[jonesy]

It was a dog act but ( imho ) the MRP will take a look at it, then move on. In some respects, I'm sometimes puzzled at how some AFL fans yearn for the " good old days " before footy became (quote) "sanitised", an era when this sort of behaviour was commonplace, but then get outraged about Murphy's conduct yesterday. Interesting.

We want to be outraged jiggster,it's all part of the theatre and gives heckling and venting ammunition. The AFL need to bring in a rule that allows one thug (or weak dog like Murphy acts) per week per team.

[CQ SAINT]

He got what he deserved. We won. Issue a few fines and move on. I love this game. He probably told Carlisle that he had no nuts and then had his handed to him via the scoreboard.

Move on. Nothing to see here.

[thejiggingsaint]

As I say, interesting. I've seen footage from days past, " bumps and biffs" or some such title, narrated by Rex Hunt. It contained some of the dirtiest, cheap shots and king hits imaginable, and to my way of thinking, glorified the cheap shot.

[whiskers3614]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

[citywest]

The MRP will give him 2 weeks.

[Fidelis]

Purple has claimed on the footy show this morning that Murphy was so upset at the verballing he was receiving that re reacted uncharacteristically. Carlton PR department has swung into action.

[WellardSaint]

Purple has claimed on the footy show this morning that Murphy was so upset at the verballing he was receiving that re reacted uncharacteristically. Carlton PR department has swung into action.

what verballing?
I don't care. You don't attack a bloke when he can't defend himself.
Bluescum typical reaction, it's in their DNA to cover up and justify criminal or immoral actions.

What's with the "damsel and the King"?

[The Fireman]

In the nuts?

Yep, hard knee in the plums.

in the Jatz crackers ?

[The_President]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Very strong rumours around this as well hahaha

[dragit]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Very strong rumours around this as well hahaha

What is this about anyway?

[WellardSaint]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Very strong rumours around this as well hahaha

On field, racist or homophobic sledgeing is out and punishable.
Harry O'Brien/Heritier Lumumba who was a Filth/Demons/Wimmera Reserves player
called some guy "gay" or "faggot" or something got in trouble.

But bagging someone about a rumour is perfectly fine, it's getting under their skin and putting them off the game.
Have to be assertive and aggressive. It's not bloody netball, FFS.
You shake hands after the game.

Murphy still married her in Oct last year, I think

[silverhalo]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Please explain?

[silverhalo]

Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Please explain?

Ah got it..... Carey and the Mrs

[shrodes]

Here's Barrett going on about it


Regardless of the sledge the unacceptable part is remonstrating with a player who looks seriously injured.