Ziebell Is a Dirty Dog

[silverhalo]

That hit was far from tough
Hitting an open bloke as he is kicking is gutless
Does it all the time

+1

[Griggsy]

That hit was far from tough
Hitting an open bloke as he is kicking is gutless
Does it all the time

Still completely within the rules. Gees, it was some heavy work though. Cloke is a huge man.

Was unnecessary, the kick was long gone and while he couldn't prevent contact he still could have slowed up, instead he leant more into it to maximize damage.
Confirmed that it's going to mrp and Cloke has broken ribs, set to miss 4-6 weeks

[prwilkinson]

That hit was far from tough
Hitting an open bloke as he is kicking is gutless
Does it all the time

Still completely within the rules. Gees, it was some heavy work though. Cloke is a huge man.

Was unnecessary, the kick was long gone and while he couldn't prevent contact he still could have slowed up, instead he leant more into it to maximize damage.
Confirmed that it's going to mrp and Cloke has broken ribs, set to miss 4-6 weeks

Funny game these days. You can be backing back into a pack like Aaron Sandilands with no way of protecting yourself, get completely split open by Nic Nat coming the other way... break 6 ribs and puncture a lung.... Out for the season. Even played today with padding still underneath his jumper. Didn't even get looked at.... BUT if you bumppppp.... even if it's right down the chest without hitting them in the head... apparently something you're still allowed to do... HOW DARE YOU!!!

[sunsaint]

Thought he was half a second within the rules
Half second earlier he would have knocked cloke off his kick
Normal speed replay it looks ok - now over to MRP to judge

[stonecold]

The bump is part of the sport and he laid a ripping one.

+1, you have to expect and brace for that sort of contact in footy, wasn't high!!!!!

Rod Keogh, anyone remember him?????

Good old Rod... Those bone rattling bumps... He was seriously tough.

Yeap, very tough Rocket Rod, nearly got me once, at training mind you, very quite man Rod, those quite ones are normally the toughest once they cross the white line!!!!!

[prwilkinson]

The bump is part of the sport and he laid a ripping one.

+1, you have to expect and brace for that sort of contact in footy, wasn't high!!!!!

Rod Keogh, anyone remember him?????

Good old Rod... Those bone rattling bumps... He was seriously tough.

Yeap, very tough Rocket Rod, nearly got me once, at training mind you, very quite man Rod, those quite ones are normally the toughest once they cross the white line!!!!!

Haha all this talk has me thinking about a time I got split open from someone coming straight at me... one of those ones that you know you're going to get hit but you get the kick on anyway... swear to god I still have a rib near my sternum that still slightly sticks out because of that hit. Just healed that way.

Rod had that ability to quickly pick up pace over a short distance, shoulder tucked in and BAM! Cop that!

[RodKeoghsLoveChild]

The bump is part of the sport and he laid a ripping one.

+1, you have to expect and brace for that sort of contact in footy, wasn't high!!!!!

Rod Keogh, anyone remember him?????

Yes, he was my father.

[stonecold]

The bump is part of the sport and he laid a ripping one.

+1, you have to expect and brace for that sort of contact in footy, wasn't high!!!!!

Rod Keogh, anyone remember him?????

Yes, he was my father.

Thought mentioning his name would attract.your attention!!!!!

Your not a bonefied footballer until you've both dished out and received one of those hits!!!!!

[Greg T]

Dogs act was unnessecary but he's always sniping
Hope he gets knocked out

[BigMart]

What

A late hit after someone kicked it... very tough indeed!

Being a superstar yourself, you'd know, taking a guy out in the act of kicking is the easiest thing to do in the game.

It's legal, it happens, it requires no toughness.

[stonecold]

As I said before Ted, happy to come and play in your game or at least be privileged enough to come and watch a legend like you go round, but, to this point you refused my offer!!!!!

[BigMart]

Because I want absolutely nothing to do with you or have nothing to prove to you

I am not 12 years old or after your respect/approval/validation...

Fact is I don't care about anything you want or think... told you, you are completely irrelevant to me...

[realdeal]

I thought there must've been another incident between these two players because the one I saw was a North player running as fast as he could over open space to put pressure on a player setting up a goal in the final minutes of a close game.

He was given a free kick down the ground and that's sufficient in my opinion.

If Cloke got up and was fine then no one would be talking about this.

[maverick]

Still think it was a cheap shot irrespective of the injury
If he tried to smother the ball it might have saved the game
He has a history of being gutless

[magnifisaint]

He's not a dirty dog, he's a dirty roo.

[satchmo]

Ziebell Is a Dirty Dog. dooh dah, doo dah...

[stonecold]

Free to play next week, no Suprise there, it's still a big boys game!!!!!

[saynta]

No case to answer. Told you.

[stonecold]

No case to answer. Told you.

Agree, I never had a problem with it in the first place!!!!!

[maverick]

Big boys please, he is a soft c**k
Riewoldt plays a mans game

[Enrico_Misso]

Do we really want to see players taken out for 6 weeks at a time when another player targets their ribs in a "legal" bump?
Are we happy with that?

[stonecold]

Do we really want to see players taken out for 6 weeks at a time when another player targets their ribs in a "legal" bump?
Are we happy with that?

Yeap, have no problem with it, same today with Gibson on Ruggles, it's footy, AFL, not AFLW!!!!!