Best Trades from other Clubs

[8856brother]

Essendon - Tony Antrobus
Richmond - Terry Smith
Hawthorn - Mark Scott
Fitzroy - Timmy Pekin
North - Matty Capuano


Sent from my SM-T210 using Tapatalk

[bobmurray]

WOW Jones Carlton

[supersaints]

Adelaide Mathew Clarke
Brisbane Gram/ Voss
Carlton Hamill/ Jezza/Peter McConville/Wow Jones/Vinnie catoggio/Marcou
Collingwood McGough/ Freeman /Kink
Essendon Max Crowe/ Carlisle ?
Fremantle Roberton\Black\ Craig Callaghan
Geelong Fetcher/ King/Rex Hunt/Neal
Gold Coast Hickey
GWS Bruce
Hawthorn Savage/ Morris/Mark Scott/Anderson
Melbourne Wilson/Newport/ Rod Keogh /Beveridge
North Melb P and J Krakour
Port Adelaide Guerra
Richmond Barrott/ Fiora
Sydney Swans Dempster/ Membrey/Schnider/ Silvio Foschini
West Coast Gehrig/ Gardiner/Paul Harding/Jason Heatley
Bulldogs Ray

I Would put Luke Penny in front of Farren Ray from the Bulldogs

[Sainternist]

Carlton - Peter McConville, Spiro Kourkoumelis, Kenny Sheldon, Alex Marcou.
Essendon - Craig O'Brien
Collingwood - Rene Kink
Melbourne - Brian Wilson, Rod Keogh
Hawthorn - Peter Russo, Paul Harding, Dean Anderson, Matty Young
North Melbourne - Lazar Vidovic
Port Adelaide - Brent Guerra
Fitzroy - Brad Gotch, Grant Lawrie
Bulldogs - Luke Beveridge
Sydney - Robert Neill, Paul Morwood

[robsaint]

You are right he played for Melbourne not us. One I did miss from Carlton was Sheldon.

[loris]

Can we and do we want to claim Mark Jackson - Melbourne??? Maybe he was traded to us as 'best fool'.

[Life Long Saint]

Carlton - Ken Sheldon

[OldGeorgeYoung]

[quote="Sainternist"]
North Melbourne - Lazar Vidovic

Lazar would have been a shoe in, but played with Carlton, and was recruited from Castlemaine so no trade.

I like someone's suggestion of Luke Penny & I agree that he might just edge out Farren as the better pick up from the Dogs.

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Looking at our trade history over the last 40 years, whilst we've pick up some good player I'd suggest that only the G-Train and maybe Aaron Hamill would be considered game changing champions with hopefully Hickey showing future potential.

We spend a lot of energy searching for the Messiah (which we should) but history suggests that that person is very hard to attract and by themselves isn't going to make us a real contender. Still fun to dream.

[saintbob]

Richmond Barrott/ Fiora

Don't forget that fantastic trade where we snared Adam Pattinson

[Sainternist]

Lazar would have been a shoe in, but played with Carlton, and was recruited from Castlemaine so no trade.

I like someone's suggestion of Luke Penny & I agree that he might just edge out Farren as the better pick up from the Dogs.

I'm pretty sure Lazar was originally recruited by North Melbourne. Nevertheless, he did play all of his senior career with St.Kilda.