Our greatest Trade?

[SaintWodonga]

What do you think our best trade has ever been? (not draft)

In recent years Schnides & Dempster was pretty good.
Also, St Kilda-West Coast, 2000 St Kilda received Fraser Gehrig; West Coast received pick No.18 (Daniel Kerr) and David Sierakowski.
Worked out well for both clubs!c

[LTN16]

Pick 12 for Tom Lee..

[Toy Saint]

....not Ian Stewart for Bill Barrot, and not Tony Locket for ...

In recent times we've done OK with Dempster & Schneider from Sydney for...

[cwrcyn]

Pick 24 (or thereabouts) for Dempster and Schneider.

Barry Hall to Sydney for pick 13, which we then used to draft Nick Dal Santo

But the best of all was Craig Davenport to Carlton for pick 21, which we then used to draft Barry Hall. Pissed myself laughing for years over that one

[saintspremiers]

Pick 12 for Tom Lee..

Didn't we get back pick 26 and drafted Spenna White with it?

[LTN16]

Pick 12 for Tom Lee..

Didn't we get back pick 26 and drafted Spenna White with it?

Nope. According to anyone in the media and it was a straight swap of pick 12 for Lee..

[Legendary]

Pick 24 for Dempster & Schneider is hard to beat.... we got an AA defender, classy half-forward, both played 100 games and member of our grand final sides...

[Goose is king]

[quote="cwrcyn"]Pick 24 (or thereabouts) for Dempster and Schneider.

Barry Hall to Sydney for pick 13, which we then used to draft Nick Dal Santo

But the best of all was Craig Davenport to Carlton for pick 21, which we then used to draft Barry Hall. Pissed myself laughing for years over that one[/quote]


So Davenport turned into Hall then in to Dal and what did we get for Dal?

[Beno88]

If the last 26 Rounds of footy we've played are anything to go by, Josh Bruce for Pick 48 (pass) could well be our best ever trade.

[remboy]

So Davenport turned into Hall then in to Dal and what did we get for Dal?

Pick 25, which we bundled up with 41 to get Longer and 48, which we used to get Bruce. So in effect Dal Santo and 41 got us Bruce and Longer.

[bigmicka]

Fraser G-Train Gehrig

Traded from West Coast for pick 18. Played 145 games, 390 goals. 2 coleman medals and 2nd in the BF 2001.

micka

[BigMart]

West Coast got Daniel Kerr with that pick.

[BigMart]

Though both Gardiner and King were good pick ups for not too much

But yeah
Schnieder and Dempster for a second rounder Was hard to believe

[RODOS]

if freeman's hammies hold together he'll take this thread

[Linton Lodger]

Mc Evoy for 2 picks (Dunstan & Acres) and Savage was truly inspired. Indirectly this lead to us bending over Brisbane for Longer.

We also got Michael Gardiner for just about nothing.

As already mentioned the Dempster/Schneider deal was good, as was the Bruce deal.

[borderbarry]

Fraser Gehrig was good, but I will go with Schneids and Dempster as our best.

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Perry, Gram & Voss were handy pick ups, but I'd agree with G-Train.
But in 5 years it will be Bruce Almighty

[Goose is king]

[quote="remboy"][quote="Goose is king"]
So Davenport turned into Hall then in to Dal and what did we get for Dal?[/quote]

Pick 25, which we bundled up with 41 to get Longer and 48, which we used to get Bruce. So in effect Dal Santo and 41 got us Bruce and Longer.[/quote]


Ha. God Davenport was good for us

[cwrcyn]

Craig Davenport is the gift that keeps giving

[Rosco]

So Davenport turned into Hall then in to Dal and what did we get for Dal?

Pick 25, which we bundled up with 41 to get Longer and 48, which we used to get Bruce. So in effect Dal Santo and 41 got us Bruce and Longer.

Hall got us 250 games from Dal plus bruce and longer.

[Rosco]

Fraser G-Train Gehrig

Traded from West Coast for pick 18. Played 145 games, 390 goals. 2 coleman medals and 2nd in the BF 2001.

micka

Right now I'd take a 25yo g-train over Dempster + Schneider at the age we got them (about 24).

[footynut]

Aaron Hamilton for Sam Cranage

[bigred]

24 or whatever it was for Schnads and Dempster is pretty hard to turn up. Especially Dempster. He has been ridiculous value.

But for mine it is Gehrig. Absolute beast.

[Legendary]

So Davenport turned into Hall then in to Dal and what did we get for Dal?

Pick 25, which we bundled up with 41 to get Longer and 48, which we used to get Bruce. So in effect Dal Santo and 41 got us Bruce and Longer.

Hall got us 250 games from Dal plus bruce and longer.

So we traded Craig Davenport for Barry Hall, who we traded for Nick Dal Santo, who we traded for Billy Longer and Josh Bruce.

Pretty hard to beat that one...

[SaintPav]

Tony King and Mark Scott for Russell Greene