2015 - Draft & Trade Thread

[magnifisaint]

bombers have made a counter offer, it seems...

5 for Carlilse + 3rd rounder (44)

I would certainly settle for carlisle +23+44 for 5+63
i.e let 25 from our original offer slide to 44

I doubt we expected them to take our original offer.. so we must have had some target in mind.. maybe it is it bit closer toward essendon....

No way we only get back pick 44, yuk.

Today is the day that Essendons arse gets reamed. They have nothing to stand on. How smug will the Essendon supporting journos be then??

[longtimesaint]

bombers have made a counter offer, it seems...

5 for Carlilse + 3rd rounder (44)

I would certainly settle for carlisle +23+44 for 5+63
i.e let 25 from our original offer slide to 44

I doubt we expected them to take our original offer.. so we must have had some target in mind.. maybe it is it bit closer toward essendon....

No way we only get back pick 44, yuk.

We won't accept that deal particularly if Carlisle states he is prepared to go toPSD.
We should hold firm on our offer of two second round picks back.

[bigred]

Port Adelaide situation is getting reported all over.

So yeah, Essendon may have a few issues sitting down....

[magnifisaint]

I'd rather Carlisle goes to the draft and get picked up by Carltoon than deal with Dildoro. Surely he wouldn't last in his job if that happened. A poker player he's not!

[longtimesaint]

I'd rather Carlisle goes to the draft and get picked up by Carltoon than deal with Dildoro. Surely he wouldn't last in his job if that happened. A poker player he's not!

This is where the bluff comes in -if Essendon believe he will go in the PSD then Essendon will have to deal on our terms.
If he went in the PSD it is a gamble but a great result if we could get Carlisle and still keep pick 5

[magnifisaint]

I'd rather Carlisle goes to the draft and get picked up by Carltoon than deal with Dildoro. Surely he wouldn't last in his job if that happened. A poker player he's not!

This is where the bluff comes in -if Essendon believe he will go in the PSD then Essendon will have to deal on our terms.
If he went in the PSD it is a gamble but a great result if we could get Carlisle and still keep pick 5

I think a group of Saints fan should line up at AFL house, wait until he comes out and then clap him off into oblivion.

[Playon]

Port Adelaide situation is getting reported all over.

So yeah, Essendon may have a few issues sitting down....

I actually like that deal better, gives us 2 first rounders next year, 10 for Calisle and perhaps a second or 3rd rounder back.
We could shop for whoever we want or 2 good picks for next years draft

Worst would be a straight swap for 10 and theres no way they could refuse it if mediation came into play

[Eastern]

Port Adelaide situation is getting reported all over.

So yeah, Essendon may have a few issues sitting down....

I actually like that deal better, gives us 2 first rounders next year, 10 for Calisle and perhaps a second or 3rd rounder back.
We could shop for whoever we want or 2 good picks for next years draft

Worst would be a straight swap for 10 and theres no way they could refuse it if mediation came into play

Does the Port deal also help us with the points thingy for Bailey Rice? I don't understand how that works !!

[Playon]

Port Adelaide situation is getting reported all over.

So yeah, Essendon may have a few issues sitting down....

I actually like that deal better, gives us 2 first rounders next year, 10 for Calisle and perhaps a second or 3rd rounder back.
We could shop for whoever we want or 2 good picks for next years draft

Worst would be a straight swap for 10 and theres no way they could refuse it if mediation came into play

Does the Port deal also help us with the points thingy for Bailey Rice? I don't understand how that works !!

Yeah. It means we swap 5 for 10 and Ports next year first and may have to include a second or 3rd rounder

So basically it could be
5 for 10
next years second for ports first
This years second for Freeman
this years 3rd for Rice

Hope to get more out of the Bombers 10 for Carlisle and 3rd rounder

Above could be tweaked or improved and finer details to be sorted etc. But basically thats how it works

And of course it may not happen

[saintjake]

Does anyone out there have some rock solid information on the Carlisle trades that isn't taken from some anonymous poster on Big Footy.
Will it get done any time soon?
Will it just be between us and the Bombers or will Port and Gold Coast get involved?
If it's the rumoured port deal, will we use those picks on JOM?

Anything half FACT would be great. Getting so tired of all armchair experts on Bigfooty. Just want some actual news

[Bunk_Moreland]

Does anyone out there have some rock solid information on the Carlisle trades that isn't taken from some anonymous poster on Big Footy.
Will it get done any time soon?
Will it just be between us and the Bombers or will Port and Gold Coast get involved?
If it's the rumoured port deal, will we use those picks on JOM?

Anything half FACT would be great. Getting so tired of all armchair experts on Bigfooty. Just want some actual news

Do go there then.

Asking anonymous posters on one forum if they have better information from anomonous posters on another forum seems to be a bit of a waste of time

[saintjake]

Does anyone out there have some rock solid information on the Carlisle trades that isn't taken from some anonymous poster on Big Footy.
Will it get done any time soon?
Will it just be between us and the Bombers or will Port and Gold Coast get involved?
If it's the rumoured port deal, will we use those picks on JOM?

Anything half FACT would be great. Getting so tired of all armchair experts on Bigfooty. Just want some actual news

Do go there then.

Asking anonymous posters on one forum if they have better information from anomonous posters on another forum seems to be a bit of a waste of time

The day < mod edit - poster warned for abuse > ........ the day Santa and Jesus are confirmed as real.

[Playon]

Well those things were tweeted by the Journos and the Port thing was in the Age.
There is no rock solid info yet and wont be until someone signs

[longtimesaint]

Does anyone out there have some rock solid information on the Carlisle trades that isn't taken from some anonymous poster on Big Footy.
Will it get done any time soon?
Will it just be between us and the Bombers or will Port and Gold Coast get involved?
If it's the rumoured port deal, will we use those picks on JOM?

Anything half FACT would be great. Getting so tired of all armchair experts on Bigfooty. Just want some actual news

Do go there then.

Asking anonymous posters on one forum if they have better information from anomonous posters on another forum seems to be a bit of a waste of time

We are all just hanging on waiting for news and hoping it's a good deal for us.
It would be good if we could at least secure Freeman.

[jaxons]

jaxons, can you verify or deny any of this?

garbage

[saintjake]

jaxons, can you verify or deny any of this?

garbage

What parts?

[Linton Street Saint]

jaxons, can you verify or deny any of this?

garbage

What parts?

Pretty sure it was in reference to the tweet from BS a few pages back.

[saintsRrising]

jaxons, can you verify or deny any of this?

garbage

What parts?

Playon wrote:
Brian Speaking
‏@Brian_Speaking

Essendon looking like accepting Saints offer, Saints trading up to 8,Lachy Weller a gen chance. Jaeger O'Meara for pick 8 and 1st rounder 16

Is it all, or just the JOM?

[MC Gusto]

The Trade Whisperer ‏@AFLTradeWhisper 2m2 minutes ago
I understand Carlton and Gold Coast are officially out of Carlisle deal. Neither are interested, sighting salary cap issues #AFLTrades


Pass the vasso to dorodo

[saintjake]

The Trade Whisperer ‏@AFLTradeWhisper 2m2 minutes ago
I understand Carlton and Gold Coast are officially out of Carlisle deal. Neither are interested, sighting salary cap issues #AFLTrades


Pass the vasso to dorodo

He's also tweeted today that a deal was basically imminent.
So much bulls*** flying around it isn't funny.

If you go through the tweets from Journos like Mark Robinson and Jay Clark you'll see how much they change their opinion on what is fair/what they report as fact. It's ridiculous.

[saintjake]

Honestly not sure if Robbo, Jay Clark or Trade Week Radio is more credible.

[longtimesaint]

The Trade Whisperer ‏@AFLTradeWhisper 2m2 minutes ago
I understand Carlton and Gold Coast are officially out of Carlisle deal. Neither are interested, sighting salary cap issues #AFLTrades


Pass the vasso to dorodo

If this is true we would be almost certain to get him in the PSD for nothing and keep pick 5.
You would think that Essendon would be mad not to accept our offer to trade rather than get nothing ( as we did re Luke Ball).
This is all as long as Carlisle stays firm and states that he is prepared to go in the PSD.

[The Recruit]

If JC walks to us through PSD, Dildo will be applying for Centrelink by Christmas. If Blues and Suns are not ken on him we will def get two second rounders.....great news considering it could be traded for pick 8.

JC and 5 for pick 8....elite trading

on the other hand if we stick it to Essendon and walk him through PSD, keep pick 5....well, thats tough trading. So realy could be do better than two second rounders?

[saynta]

I'd be putting a pic of Bains above my bed.

I've already got one there. Added Elshaug and Finnis as well. Rumours of my change of sexual preference probably originated from my son, although BS tweeted

If they pull this off, I'd consider <edited by mod> for all of them.

Didn't he used to play for Carlton back in the 70s...?

You might be confused with Milan Faletic.

Close, but no cigar...unlike Bill Clinton...

I think Bill only had the cigar case.

[saynta]

Does anyone out there have some rock solid information on the Carlisle trades that isn't taken from some anonymous poster on Big Footy.
Will it get done any time soon?
Will it just be between us and the Bombers or will Port and Gold Coast get involved?
If it's the rumoured port deal, will we use those picks on JOM?

Anything half FACT would be great. Getting so tired of all armchair experts on Bigfooty. Just want some actual news

Do go there then.

Asking anonymous posters on one forum if they have better information from anomonous posters on another forum seems to be a bit of a waste of time

The day you provide anything useful will be the day Santa and Jesus are confirmed as real.

Think one out of two has already been confirmed.