Jake Carlisle

[SAAD]

Damnit...I want Treloar...Maybe wait next year for Jaeger or Prestia...

[saynta]

hmm
i could go here and get a job with this much pay
or
i could go here which is closer and i like that area better and its a shorter commute and is closer to friends and my outside of football hobbies for roughly the same pay



no
when deciding to go to a melb club in a job thats prob only going to last till you are around 30, location would have nothing to do with it...for a JOB


it would be a BIG factor

Without having a clue where Rice lives im pretty sure he lives much closer to Seaford than Princes park. That is why for especially I think it is rubbish about Seaford. So if its a big factor we must be getting Rice.

Maybe an 18 year old doesn't feel the urge to live with or near his parents

Be good if my kids felt like that.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Reported tonight that Treloar to Collingwood is pretty much a done deal. I'm a bit miffed that we didn't even get mentioned in the reports as a team chasing him. I hope we are being aggressive enough in our trading and not just hoping for the odd Membrey to fall off the back of the truck.

because we are a small team, Ameet has decided not to do anything and just collect his pay cheque.

Cant compete so we are doing nothing

are you seriously having a go at Baines recruiting work ? seriously????

[saynta]

Reported tonight that Treloar to Collingwood is pretty much a done deal. I'm a bit miffed that we didn't even get mentioned in the reports as a team chasing him. I hope we are being aggressive enough in our trading and not just hoping for the odd Membrey to fall off the back of the truck.

because we are a small team, Ameet has decided not to do anything and just collect his pay cheque.

Cant compete so we are doing nothing

are you seriously having a go at Baines recruiting work ? seriously????

We need to wait a few years before the jury's in on that.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

not really .... its pretty clear to see the recruiting is on the improve (that said it was so bad in previously any improvement is going to be massive)
sure it will take time to see how good those picks have been but the fact that our second rounders are getting regular games compared to the likes of previous years where none were getting up to standard ... that said we are a significantly different team now from then

[Bunk_Moreland]

Reported tonight that Treloar to Collingwood is pretty much a done deal. I'm a bit miffed that we didn't even get mentioned in the reports as a team chasing him. I hope we are being aggressive enough in our trading and not just hoping for the odd Membrey to fall off the back of the truck.

because we are a small team, Ameet has decided not to do anything and just collect his pay cheque.

Cant compete so we are doing nothing

are you seriously having a go at Baines recruiting work ? seriously????

[Bunk_Moreland]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

[Saints94]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

Moorabbin Ghost?

[Con Gorozidis]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

Moorabbin Ghost?

Good news. Not sure we need another tall defender with a high pick. Will Schofield is a gun player and was a pick 50. Lets just focus on our midfield.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

Moorabbin Ghost?

Good news. Not sure we need another tall defender with a high pick. Will Schofield is a gun player and was a pick 50. Lets just focus on our midfield.

I agree if you are going to give up an early pick you do it for a game breaker not a foot soldier ... Carlisle is a good player but I would rather a mid

[Bunk_Moreland]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

Moorabbin Ghost?

BS

[SENsei]

I hear this now wont be happening......if it ever was

Moorabbin Ghost?

BS

Brian Sierakowski still has his finger on the pulse? Not even a shark can keep him down!!

[Eastern]

Those thinking that Jake Carlisle would be a good investment should research the name Jonathon Hay. Hawthorn laughed all the way to the Draft table at Nth Melbourne's expence !!

[St Chris]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

[FQF]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

[Eastern]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

I doubt we'll look too closely at either !!

[St Chris]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

Henderson has more ticker than Carlisle. He's not a d*ckhead either....

[bergholt]

Those thinking that Jake Carlisle would be a good investment should research the name Jonathon Hay. Hawthorn laughed all the way to the Draft table at Nth Melbourne's expence !!

Sorry mate, I don't understand what the comparison is. They're both quite tall? What are the other similarities in the situations?

[saynta]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

Henderson has more ticker than Carlisle. He's not a d*ckhead either....

Oh, I thought Henderson just proved that he was a dick head and that's why he is now sitting out the last three games.

Couldn't keep his mouth shut until the end of the season. How dumb is that?

[St Chris]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

Henderson has more ticker than Carlisle. He's not a d*ckhead either....

Oh, I thought Henderson just proved that he was a dick head and that's why he is now sitting out the last three games.

Couldn't keep his mouth shut until the end of the season. How dumb is that?

I think it's pretty mature actually, and the reaction from Carlton shows the AFL industry isn't truly ready for free agency....

Would you prefer the BS line "we're putting off contract talks until after the season, but i'm confident i'll stay" that supporters got from Ablett, and Goddard, and Tom Scully, and Chip Frawley, and Buddy, and are getting from Carlisle, Dangerfield and Luenberger???

[plugger66]

Those thinking that Jake Carlisle would be a good investment should research the name Jonathon Hay. Hawthorn laughed all the way to the Draft table at Nth Melbourne's expence !!

What do you mean Eastern? Do the Bombers know Carlisle has depression?

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

Henderson has more ticker than Carlisle. He's not a d*ckhead either....

Oh, I thought Henderson just proved that he was a dick head and that's why he is now sitting out the last three games.

Couldn't keep his mouth shut until the end of the season. How dumb is that?

reading between the lines I reckon Carlton knew he was heading out the door anyway and were always going to drop him for the last three games - Henderson just came out on the front foot saying he wanted to be traded and that's why he was being dropped to keep his value up... a player dropped for the last three games without explanation reflects poorly on the player

[plugger66]

Lachie Henderson has officially requested a trade from the Blues, he'd be a better option than Carlisle??

Why better? Who is a better player? Also Hendserson will be 26.

Henderson has more ticker than Carlisle. He's not a d*ckhead either....

Oh, I thought Henderson just proved that he was a dick head and that's why he is now sitting out the last three games.

Couldn't keep his mouth shut until the end of the season. How dumb is that?

reading between the lines I reckon Carlton knew he was heading out the door anyway and were always going to drop him for the last three games - Henderson just came out on the front foot saying he wanted to be traded and that's why he was being dropped to keep his value up... a player dropped for the last three games without explanation reflects poorly on the player

I would like to congratulate you. Very good.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

not sure if that's sarcasm or not plugs.......

[plugger66]

not sure if that's sarcasm or not plugs.......

No its hard to spot but its very good. Your comments are fine also.