Jake Carlisle

[MadSaintFan]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

[BackFromUSA]

The only problem being we may not see him play with us until 2018.

[plugger66]

The only problem being we may not see him play with us until 2018.

Not an issue. Even if they are found guilty I think 6 months will see it out afterall this has gone on for 3 years and the players have been effected enough I think. Still a bit to high a price to pay. Love to have a player we could swap plus our second rounder.

[saynta]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

He probably won't be playing in 2016/7, so no thanks.

[Rosco]

Good to have him but hate to give them anything.

[magnifisaint]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

Where does this come from?

[Rosco]

I'm guessing the same place most of this comes from.

[Con Gorozidis]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

3 picks would be completely insane. Utter lunacy. The Bombers will demand the world for this guy.
Pick 6 maybe - but no way to 20 and 40.

[SuperDuper]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

3 picks would be completely insane. Utter lunacy. The Bombers will demand the world for this guy.
Pick 6 maybe - but no way to 20 and 40.

read it again Con
he is saying 20 odd comes back our way

So we end up with Carlisle and go to the draft with 2 early 20's picks

[Con Gorozidis]

Jake Carlisle to StK is becoming a very strong possibility - the player is keen to come to the Saints with the offer of good $$ and playing without interruption in his preferred position at full back. The Dogs are out of the race and Carlton are looking to rebuild through the Draft, not through Trades.
Pick #5-6 in this years Draft is worth about 10-12 in previous years - our preferred target Parish will most likely be gone by this stage, making our first pick less desirable to keep.
At this stage pick 5-6 + pick 40(odd) for Carlisle + pick 20(odd) would be on the cards.

From a personal perspective, I think this is very exciting. The guy is a gun Full-Back and would almost complete our spine for the next 10 years: FB - Carlisle , CHB - Goddard, C - Armitage/Steven, CHF - Bruce, FF - McCartin.

3 picks would be completely insane. Utter lunacy. The Bombers will demand the world for this guy.
Pick 6 maybe - but no way to 20 and 40.

read it again Con
he is saying 20 odd comes back our way

So we end up with Carlisle and go to the draft with 2 early 20's picks

Gotcha Sweet Ok. thats more like it.

Carlisle + picks 23 + 24 seems certainly something I wouldn't mind at all. Seems reasonable.
Would give Bummers 5 & 6 which they desperately need and if he is an unhappy chappy there then it is a win-win really for both sides.
Perfect age for us really.

Maybe we can jag another top 40 pick some other way.
Carlisle + 3 top x 40 picks would be ok in my books.

[IanRush]

Ess should be happy if anyone takes him, Ess is not in a position to bargain at the moment.

[matrix]

looks youd consider it depending on the essendope saga
but id try to give them F*** all to get him
i mean if he is no good to play for over a year is that what we really want?

who is the sauce of this trade rumor ?

[quidnunc]

They need a ruckman - we need a FB/CHB.

[Old Mate]

looks youd consider it depending on the essendope saga
but id try to give them F*** all to get him
i mean if he is no good to play for over a year is that what we really want?

who is the sauce of this trade rumor ?

Finey

[plugger66]

They need a ruckman - we need a FB/CHB.

I think they are getting Luenberger unfortunately otherwise we have plenty.

[SuperDuper]

They need a ruckman - we need a FB/CHB.

I think they are getting Luenberger unfortunately otherwise we have plenty.

got a sauce on Luenberger Pluggs?

Also... serious question.. is Finey a reliable sauce re carlisle? based in history?

I am sure it is all pretty fluid at this stage, especially any Essendndon dealings... cant see anyone going there if half their team is outed for a year or so

[plugger66]

They need a ruckman - we need a FB/CHB.

I think they are getting Luenberger unfortunately otherwise we have plenty.

got a sauce on Luenberger Pluggs?

Also... serious question.. is Finey a reliable sauce re carlisle? based in history?

I am sure it is all pretty fluid at this stage, especially any Essendndon dealings... cant see anyone going there if half their team is outed for a year or so

Mentioned on channel 7 the other night. As for Finey well im unsure he gets much more than anyone else unless a player is managed by a guys who appear on his program. I will ask him Saturday if he umpires our footy.

[lewdogs]

I heard this rumour from a Essendon mate. Would do it for the 1st rounder if we got their second rounder back.

[Bunk_Moreland]

I heard this rumour from a Essendon mate. Would do it for the 1st rounder if we got their second rounder back.

The only first rounder we have is pick #6.

You seriously want to give up our #6 for Carlilse.

lol - really

[saynta]

Pick 5 or 6 for a GOP who might not play for years. No thanks. No more Lovett like deals with the cheaters.

[Eastern]

How loudly should I say NO?

Sheedy & Hird are probably busy right now writing references for him !!

[Eastern]

Pick 5 or 6 for a GOP who might not play for years. No thanks. No more Lovett like deals with the cheaters.

By GOP you mean 'Genuinely Ordinary Player', don't you? !!

[matrix]

yeah

nahhh


the more i think about it for pick 5 or 6 the more i think they can bash it up their ass tbh

[saynta]

Pick 5 or 6 for a GOP who might not play for years. No thanks. No more Lovett like deals with the cheaters.

By GOP you mean 'Genuinely Ordinary Player', don't you? !!

Well. I think Jack did, but who really knows.

[SaintWodonga]

surely after WADA, all his worth would be a packet of chips and a dim sim?