Let's call it what it is......cheating.

[CURLY]

Just blatant cheating and they don't try and hide it. Arm chops ignored while non marks getting paid as marks resulting in goals the other way. It was 15-6 GWS way during the 3rd. We get to 16 down and Lonie and Bruce both get clearly infringed 20 out no free. It's just cheating and we keep copping it.

[whiskers3614]

Can mod's sticky this and save Curly the trouble of starting it every week?

[CURLY]

Just treat us equally that's all I ask.

[Con Gorozidis]

I love Curly.

[plugger66]

Good stuff curls.

[CURLY]

I love Curly.

Has to be said it's just pathetic.

[plugger66]

I love Curly.

Has to be said it's just pathetic.

Yep they cheated but why do they only do it against us?

[saint6709]

I love Curly.

Has to be said it's just pathetic.

Yep they cheated but why do they only do it against us?

That is the question

[plugger66]

I love Curly.

Has to be said it's just pathetic.

Yep they cheated but why do they only do it against us?

That is the question

I think its called watching a game through one eye or we all lack logic. Im going with the one eye.

[CURLY]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

[plugger66]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

Makes completely no sense. I have no idea why you bother with the AFL if you really think that. I certainly wouldn't. Warburton still getting a bad deal? You really are unlucky.

[whiskers3614]

Bioody Grant Thomas!
All his fault.

[CURLY]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

Makes completely no sense. I have no idea why you bother with the AFL if you really think that. I certainly wouldn't. Warburton still getting a bad deal? You really are unlucky.

Warby get a good deal the umpire that told our football manager he gives our full forward nothing because the umpires don't like him has been let go. All good.

[plugger66]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

Makes completely no sense. I have no idea why you bother with the AFL if you really think that. I certainly wouldn't. Warburton still getting a bad deal? You really are unlucky.

Warby get a good deal the umpire that told our football manager he gives our full forward nothing because the umpires don't like him has been let go. All good.

Of course he did. Even when you hear things, you hear it with one ear.

[CURLY]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

Makes completely no sense. I have no idea why you bother with the AFL if you really think that. I certainly wouldn't. Warburton still getting a bad deal? You really are unlucky.

Warby get a good deal the umpire that told our football manager he gives our full forward nothing because the umpires don't like him has been let go. All good.

Of course he did. Even when you hear things, you hear it with one ear.

Question was asked and the umpire replied. Guess he believed that umpires are above the law.

[plugger66]

Question was asked and the umpire replied. Guess he believed that umpires are above the law.

Rather hilarious.

[8856brother]

Different rules for different clubs it's that simple. Watched Pies v Hawks frees to White and Blair when the Pies needed them were as soft as you'll get. Both resulted in goals. Now Bruce and Lonie were clearly infringed and both in clear view and both ignored. Fair enough they ignore the first but not two in five minutes.

Makes completely no sense. I have no idea why you bother with the AFL if you really think that. I certainly wouldn't. Warburton still getting a bad deal? You really are unlucky.

Warby get a good deal the umpire that told our football manager he gives our full forward nothing because the umpires don't like him has been let go. All good.

Of course he did. Even when you hear things, you hear it with one ear.

Difficult to wear glasses with only one ear.

[gringo]

We keep making excuses for them they ruined the last game we played in Melbourne. Bugg anyone.

[plugger66]

We keep making excuses for them they ruined the last game we played in Melbourne. Bugg anyone.

And I just thought it was our skills. I didn't think they ruined the last game we played but each to their own. I was pretty happy with 110 point win.

[gringo]

We keep making excuses for them they ruined the last game we played in Melbourne. Bugg anyone.

And I just thought it was our skills. I didn't think they ruined the last game we played but each to their own. I was pretty happy with 110 point win.

You know what I was talking about. The in the back that wasn't there when Riewoldt left the field with whiplash which was given to them as a free kick that lost us a game by a couple of points. It was an outrageously s*** piece of umpiring. They actually dragged Leigh Fisher before the game today...I reckon we complained about last time so they got stuck into us or something.

[FQF]

Rumour has it that the reason Leigh Fisher was pulled out of the umpiring team at the last minute was because he refused on principle to accept the firm AFL directive to subtly assist a GWS victory.

But seriously, it is indeed a long shot to claim that there is some hidden agenda, but there were a number of calls today that were both inconsistent and not in our favour. Very frustrating and could plausibly have have affected the result.

[Freebird]

I love Curly.

Has to be said it's just pathetic.

Yep they cheated but why do they only do it against us?

That is the question

Not just us..depends on combination of umpires. Did you watch hawks today, umps were on for them today. Even got one for blocking when a player stood his ground in a marking contest.

We all know that historically umps all over the world cheat. St Kilda is not a popular side when it comes to AFL supporters I would think that would spill over to umps.

If you can't see us being pushed blocked and arms pulled/chopped and getting nothing then the other end sft c**k frees everywhere then you are either blind or just want to be politically correct. It does not happen in all games but we certainly don'y have a good run with the little pricks.

[Toy Saint]

Rumour has it that the reason Leigh Fisher was pulled out of the umpiring team at the last minute was because he refused on principle to accept the firm AFL directive to subtly assist a GWS victory.

But seriously, it is indeed a long shot to claim that there is some hidden agenda, but there were a number of calls today that were both inconsistent and not in our favour. Very frustrating and could plausibly have have affected the result.

But seriously, the AFL is highly motivated to ensure AFL is successfull in the western suburbs of Sydney. They'll do about whatever it takes. Why is anybody surprised?

[plugger66]

Rumour has it that the reason Leigh Fisher was pulled out of the umpiring team at the last minute was because he refused on principle to accept the firm AFL directive to subtly assist a GWS victory.

But seriously, it is indeed a long shot to claim that there is some hidden agenda, but there were a number of calls today that were both inconsistent and not in our favour. Very frustrating and could plausibly have have affected the result.

But seriously, the AFL is highly motivated to ensure AFL is successfull in the western suburbs of Sydney. They'll do about whatever it takes. Why is anybody surprised?

How come they don't get favoured against all sides. How come we haven't had a game this year where we have been favoured. It lacks logic.

[Con Gorozidis]

Personally I would like to see Curly get a 5 minute webcast on the Saints webpage where s/he analyses the frees like the 'Engine Room'.'
I am more than happy to collaborate.This would be quite funny. Get the big screen, pause it 'roll it'. 'The Adjudicator' or 'Curly's Corner'.