Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

Out

Hickey
Schneider
Sinclair

in
Lee
Weller
Dunstan

[bergholt]

OUT: Schneider, Sinclair
IN: Dunstan, Weller

[Old Mate]

Out
Sinclair
Schneider
Hickey

In
Weller
Dunstan
Membrey

[St Loxton]

Out. Hickey
Schnieder
Shenton
Sinclair

In. Membery
Weller
Dunstan
Goddard

[Saint wagga]

INs: Weller, Minch, Goddard

OUts: Schneider, Sinclair, Shenton

Dunstan would still be very very sore i reckon!

[Teflon]

Ins: Strategic, Planning

Outs: Tenacity, Delusion, Self gratification

I think tenacity pulled up sore after last week so will be interesting to see if he is a late change...

[St Chris]

Today:
Out: Schneider, Sinclair

In: Weller, Dunstan, Goddard, Membury, McKenzie

Final
Out: Schneider, Sinclair, Shenton

In: Weller, Dunstan, Goddard
Emerg: Shenton, Menbury, McKenzie

[saintspremiers]

Out

Hickey
Schneider
Sinclair

in
Lee
Weller
Dunstan

Almost correct.

It will be Goddard instead of Lee, but I'd prefer Lee to Goddard!

[FQF]

Out
Hickey
Schneider
Sinclair
Shenton

In
Mav
Dunstan
Goddard
Gilbert

[FQF]

Would like to see DMac back in the side but can't see who else goes out

[bigballs]

In: Minchington, Weller, Gilbert

Out: Schneider, Sinclair, Shenton

[plugger66]

Ins: Strategic, Planning

Outs: Tenacity, Delusion, Self gratification

I think tenacity pulled up sore after last week so will be interesting to see if he is a late change...

That leave us with 21. Surely the AFL will know we are tanking.

[stkfc1]

Garland and Vandenberg out for them. Good outs for us!

[stkfc1]

Garland and Vandenberg out for them. Good outs for us!

[Sainternist]

Word has it Gilbert will be getting the call up.

Will be happy to see the Maverick back.

[#gosaintas]

Ins : Membrey, Goddard, Lee, Gilbert and Weller

Outs : Schneider, Shenton, Sinclair, Longer and Newnes

[Saint wagga]

If Gilbert comes in off two VFL games, solid without being sensational, makes the 'VFL form counts for a lot' line even more of a Furphey!! Surely after the best part of 2 years out, he should spend longer in the 2's...were not talking about a Judd, or a Cyril Rioli! Hasn't done enough IMO to walk straight back in, nothing against Gilbo personally, agree with Richo, he will make us a better team when he's got a solid 4-6 games under his belt without interuption...but for him to get a magic carpet ride back into the 1's...there'd be some dissapointed other i reckon...anyway, he's not been named yet so might amount to nothing.

[magnifisaint]

Looks like Gilbert will play!

[FQF]

Looks like Gilbert will play!

Massive in IMO. If Oxley could do what he did against the Dees last week, imagine how many intercepts Gilbert and Dempster could share.

[Milne]

I think a lot of us forget how important Gilbert is to the team (even with his poor disposal at times). Massive in!

[gringo]

If Gilbert comes in off two VFL games, solid without being sensational, makes the 'VFL form counts for a lot' line even more of a Furphey!! Surely after the best part of 2 years out, he should spend longer in the 2's...were not talking about a Judd, or a Cyril Rioli! Hasn't done enough IMO to walk straight back in, nothing against Gilbo personally, agree with Richo, he will make us a better team when he's got a solid 4-6 games under his belt without interuption...but for him to get a magic carpet ride back into the 1's...there'd be some dissapointed other i reckon...anyway, he's not been named yet so might amount to nothing.

He is a very good player though. We wouldn't have had Lenny Hayes, Fisher, Joey etc wait too long and he is probably in that group as far as his ability to improve the team.

[Saint wagga]

I think a lot of us forget how important Gilbert is to the team (even with his poor disposal at times). Massive in!

Which team though. He basically hasn't played any footy with the 'rebuilding team'. He was an important cog in those challenging years and no doubt is a good player who when fully fit and with plenty of footy under his belt, should be in our current best 22...but hes hardly played any footy in 2 years!! thats a long time, and a couple of mediocre games in the 2's...not enough IMO to warrant coming straighht in.

[Saint wagga]

If Gilbert comes in off two VFL games, solid without being sensational, makes the 'VFL form counts for a lot' line even more of a Furphey!! Surely after the best part of 2 years out, he should spend longer in the 2's...were not talking about a Judd, or a Cyril Rioli! Hasn't done enough IMO to walk straight back in, nothing against Gilbo personally, agree with Richo, he will make us a better team when he's got a solid 4-6 games under his belt without interuption...but for him to get a magic carpet ride back into the 1's...there'd be some dissapointed other i reckon...anyway, he's not been named yet so might amount to nothing.

He is a very good player though. We wouldn't have had Lenny Hayes, Fisher, Joey etc wait too long and he is probably in that group as far as his ability to improve the team.

I actually agree with you Gringo, that when he's fully fit and firing, even though i wouldn't put him in A grade category like a Hayes or a Fisher or even just below that a Monti...given he's in his 'prime age category', he can actually have a very big influence on our team balance, therefore as big an impact on the team even though he's not an elite player...my beaf is with his lack of match conditioning after the best part of 2 years out of top shelf footy...I just think from a total body conditioning and match conditioning perspective, it's hugely underdone and would hate for him to breakdown again...he did his groin in his first match back for peats sake!

[1966]

Out
Schneider
Sinclair
Hickey
Shenton

In
Weller
Dunstan
McKenzie
Gilbert/Goddard

[sax]

Out: Schneider (r), Sinclair (r), Shenton (omit)

In: Dunstan, Weller, Gilbert