Sinclair back to rookie list

[mad saint guy]

Yes its such a huge issue. Im sure the mainstream media will care. Not. I like it. Its up to clubs to work out whats best for them. They actually have to think into the fuyure.

Gold

[plugger66]

Yes its such a huge issue. Im sure the mainstream media will care. Not. I like it. Its up to clubs to work out whats best for them. They actually have to think into the fuyure.

Gold

Did the mainstream media care? I don't think so but I love people who try to find others who are wrong. It usually comes from those who are wrong quite a lot. You fit in perfectly. Anyway my side is the following.

[KingSaint]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

You are a disgrace and a whining sniveling internet hero, why is it your posts triple when we lose, hardly heard from you last week. Weak individuals like you wouldn't last 10 seconds on a footy field yet you choose to degrade a bloke who has played over 200 games at the highest level including a premiership. Get a clue idiot

Mate I played for 25 years and represented my state and coached for another 10.

BBMD you are the internet hero making it personal. I posted last week perhaps you were so wound up in your own misery you missed them!

I think I know what a soft footballer looks like and Schneider is exactly that and always has been. He has played 200 games most as a forward pocket sea gulling around getting cheap goals. Even Fiora played over 100 games you dont have to be hard to play some roles.

It is an opinion BBMD just as you have yours please respect others without becoming personal.

Ahh yes, it's my opinion, the preferred alibi of the Internet sniper. Well let me tell you my opinion, you are entitled to have what ever opinion you like, that is your right. However, if you choose to share your "opinion" on a public forum, be prepared cop critiquing of your "opinion" good, bad or indifferent. Also, Slagging off at a Saints player in an insulting and derogatory manner is thepoorestofpoorform.

[ace]

What's the matter guys.

The AFL has reviewed the situation and agreed that St Kilda can demote Saad back to the rookie list and retain Sincliar on the senior list.

You see what happens when you get rid of Dimwit.


Demetriou would have said NO to St Kilda - he hated us so much.
Then he would have initiated a review of the rule interpretation and finally allowed others clubs to select which player was demoted.

[plugger66]

If injury list is right today we will have to drop Sinclair and Schneider the next game. Then the following game one of them can go back on the senior list.

[gringo]

If injury list is right today we will have to drop Sinclair and Schneider the next game. Then the following game one of them can go back on the senior list.

I guess that's life, at least we get to see someone who might not have gotten a game. It might actually be a positive if someone grabs the opportunity with both hands.

[saynta]

Chips is the only listed injured player and he will be back after the bye.

I don't ever remember having a full list to choose from in the past

[SMS]

Sinclair is a gun.

Eill be elevated next uear. Well done Sinclair!

Schnieders leadership has been fantastic and much needed.

Sipposs wont make it imo. Not serious enough or big or fast enough.

[Con Gorozidis]

Maybe this was a plan? Ram games into Sinclair while we can. Ram some into the Minch after the bye. Sinclair is a certainty for elevation next year.

Re Eli. Where is he at? Jury still well out imo.

[FQF]

Maybe this was a plan? Ram games into Sinclair while we can. Ram some into the Minch after the bye. Sinclair is a certainty for elevation next year.

Re Eli. Where is he at? Jury still well out imo.

Eli probably deserves his own thread. Serious injury and a young and raw frame but many (all?) expected him to be a lock in the senior team this year. Getting good numbers at Sandy but certainly not banging the door down.

[saintbrat]

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2015-06-0 ... ist-update

JACK Sinclair and Adam Schneider are almost certain to return to the rookie list this week following the news that Arryn Siposs and Daniel Markworth have been cleared to play.

Sinclair and Schneider were promoted to the senior list prior to round one and have played nine and ten games respectively since.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
However all is not lost for these three, or fellow rookies Brenton Payne and Jason Holmes, with the club almost certain to promote a rookie after the mid-season break – in line with the AFL’s rules.

“Over the next week or so we will decide which of the rookies we want to promote onto the senior list,” Cox said.

“It will be a really tough choice for our list management group as to who gets the nod.”

[saintsRrising]

Well at least it will be very interesting to see how Markworth goes. He has all the tools, but so far has had little opportunity.

Looks like from those arms that he has been hitting the gym hard.

[kosifantutti]

Official now

@AFL_PKeane: St Kilda has reinstated Daniel Markworth to the senior list from the long-term injury list and returned Jack Sinclair to the Rookie List.

@AFL_PKeane: St Kilda has reinstated Arryn Siposs to the senior list from the long-term injury list and returned Adam Schneider to the Rookie List.

[Goose is king]

By all reports Sinclair had a ripper.
Out of interest how long is required for a long term injury?

[mordi]

One of the main benefits of Sinclair back to rookie is he will play more minutes on the ball. In today's game against the VFL Bulldogs he was key player in the middle in last qtr. if he stayed in afl side may have only spent time as small forward and also sub.

[Con Gorozidis]

By all reports Sinclair had a ripper.
Out of interest how long is required for a long term injury?

8 weeks

Out of interest if you put someone on the LTI list in say Rd 19, does that carry through the next season?

[8856brother]

Welcome back Jack. No pressure, but reckon there's a lot of Sam Mitchell about him. How did 18 clubs overlook him?

[dragit]

Out of interest if you put someone on the LTI list in say Rd 19, does that carry through the next season?

i don't think so, but round 18 is the latest someone can be promoted.