Good news re Jack Sinclair

[Richter]

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/afl/afl ... h6m2b.html

A change of heart from the AFL has allowed St Kilda to reverse their decision to demote emerging youngster Jack Sinclair back to the rookie list....

[stjay]

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/afl/afl ... h6m2b.html

A change of heart from the AFL has allowed St Kilda to reverse their decision to demote emerging youngster Jack Sinclair back to the rookie list....

Excellent news although I can't work out what it means. Is it that he can remain until Ross is selected in the seniors? Or..that he can remain and another elevated rookie be dropped?

[Armoooo]

Looks like it will be Saad that is demoted instead.

[longtimesaint]

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/afl/afl ... h6m2b.html

A change of heart from the AFL has allowed St Kilda to reverse their decision to demote emerging youngster Jack Sinclair back to the rookie list....

Excellent news although I can't work out what it means. Is it that he can remain until Ross is selected in the seniors? Or..that he can remain and another elevated rookie be dropped?

I think it means he has been swapped with Saad and therefore his return to rookie will relate to the long term injury of Siposs.
By the time Siposs returns he can be elevated under the round 11 rule.

[plugger66]

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/afl/afl ... h6m2b.html

A change of heart from the AFL has allowed St Kilda to reverse their decision to demote emerging youngster Jack Sinclair back to the rookie list....

Excellent news although I can't work out what it means. Is it that he can remain until Ross is selected in the seniors? Or..that he can remain and another elevated rookie be dropped?

I think it means he has been swapped with Saad and therefore his return to rookie will relate to the long term injury of Siposs.
By the time Siposs returns he can be elevated under the round 11 rule.

If Schneider isn't. It will be very close based on form and age.

[Saint wagga]

just can't see Saad giving us anything at AFL level, i wasn't a fan of keeping schneider on the list, based purely on his age and injury risk profile, not on afl level ability, thats never been in question IMO...but given schneider is match fit, playing well and with some senior boys in and out due to injury, i think schneider should at least be kept elevated (weather he plays each week depends on balance of team) as long as possible...