Sinclair back to rookie list

[Goose is king]

So says article on afl app with Ross' return
Disappointing but glad we have him

[saintbrat]

http://afl.com.au/news/2015-05-16/riewo ... ning-clash

[saintspremiers]

So for Seb to play VFL do we have to demote Sinclair?

[saintbrat]

So for Seb to play VFL do we have to demote Sinclair?

Yes

[WinnersOnly]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

[desertsaint]

Prefer Sinclair personally - bit of a bugger for the lad. Took his opportunity with both hands, now has to wait for a seaon for another.

[StGoddard18]

Why not Saad?
I've been very impressed with Sinclair.

[Scollop]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

Obviously Sinclair doesn't know how to use a microphone and do interviews that are humurous

[saintspremiers]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

Con may agree with you (I don't). He should be back tomorrow

[Jacks Back]

I think Sinclair could use a bot of a break. He has been good but today was pretty poor. He may get re-elevated in Round 11 when teams are allowed to elevate a rookie for the rest of the season.

Having said that we have a lot of players who are small and slight and therefore not AFL ready to play week in week out.

[elizabethr]

Who ?

[longtimesaint]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

I don't think we have a choice as a rookie is elevated for a specific player who is put on the long term injury list.
Therefore the rookie goes back when that player returns.

[St Ick]

Elevated rookie in round 1, means he gets a three game rest - he has probably exceeded even his own expectations anyway so far so a run in the twos won't kill the kid. Well done on a great start to a hopefully successful career though

[plugger66]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

You really are a terrible supporter. Disgusted.

[BringBackMadDog]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

You are a disgrace and a whining sniveling internet hero, why is it your posts triple when we lose, hardly heard from you last week. Weak individuals like you wouldn't last 10 seconds on a footy field yet you choose to degrade a bloke who has played over 200 games at the highest level including a premiership. Get a clue idiot

<warning for abuse>

[SMS]

He will be elevated round 11 if not before. If you guys cant see what a gun he is you need help.
The kid can play and fits in perfectly.
He have a down day did he? He put himself in position to kick a few. He has things you cant teach. Like lonie and mckenzie. All gems.

[magnifisaint]

This kid can play. We've unearthed a gem. He'll be back in no time.

[FQF]

Sinclair was upgraded in Ross' place, we can't just decide to switch it around and demote Saad or Schneider instead.

Anyway, as I've posted elsewhere, a 4 game stretch in the VFL midfield will only do good things for Sinclair's development before a permanent upgrade in round 11. In the meantime, we really need to see Acres, Ross and co get a run in the seniors, so the opening of a spot is necessary.

[thequarry]

This article from pre-Round 1 has the rookie promotions and who they were for:
http://www.saints.com.au/news/2015-04-0 ... ookie-trio

Sinclair for Ross
Saad for Markworth
Schneider for Siposs

[Linton Lodger]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

Why the antipathy towards the Schneiderman? He has played well, and his experience and leadership are important.

[Linton Lodger]

Why not Saad?
I've been very impressed with Sinclair.

Understand your point, I think the reason is that Saad is playing for his career, whereas Sinclair will without question be promoted from the Rookie list for next year.

[Goose is king]

Sadly I think Saad has already played for his career and it's over

[WinnersOnly]

Why not snivling Scheider. He is my most disliked Saints player ever always 'sea gulling' and looking for the cheap shots. Lazy cant tackle cant run, has been getting reasonable stats but does nothing with them. The guy hasnt won a hard ball get in his entire career exactly why Sydney got rid of him!

Yet we choose to move Sinclair back?

You are a disgrace and a whining sniveling internet hero, why is it your posts triple when we lose, hardly heard from you last week. Weak individuals like you wouldn't last 10 seconds on a footy field yet you choose to degrade a bloke who has played over 200 games at the highest level including a premiership. Get a clue idiot

Mate I played for 25 years and represented my state and coached for another 10.

BBMD you are the internet hero making it personal. I posted last week perhaps you were so wound up in your own misery you missed them!

I think I know what a soft footballer looks like and Schneider is exactly that and always has been. He has played 200 games most as a forward pocket sea gulling around getting cheap goals. Even Fiora played over 100 games you dont have to be hard to play some roles.

It is an opinion BBMD just as you have yours please respect others without becoming personal.

[Austinnn]

Still a dumb post, and pretty low.

[WinnersOnly]

Still a dumb post, and pretty low.

Why its the truth! He hasnt been hurting opposition with goals, hence for me he is cheating the club and a young player getting games.