Votes v Carl

[avid]

Can anyone start this up?
Here goes:

5 Longer
4 Armitage
3 Steven
2 Lonie
1 Schneider


Now, someone disagree ...

[borderbarry]

5. Armo
4. Longer.
3. Fisher
2. Lonie
1. Steven

[gringo]

5 Armo
4 Longer
3 Schnieder
2 Lonie/ Billings
1 Shenton

Think Bruce is doing a good job generally and was a great focal point with another couple of goals too.

[Bluthy]

5 Lonie - almost got us back in the game
4 Armo - always works hard
3 Steven - great early before being shut down s
2 Billings - a howler or too but makes stuff happen when he's got the footy
1 Longer - worked tirelessly in the ruck

[whiskers3614]

No love for nick Maxwell, er sorry Geary?

[cwrcyn]

Longer
Armitage
Fisher
Dempster
Schneider

[Old Mate]

Longer
Lonie
Armo
Billings
Honestly cannot think of a 5th, the rest were extremely poor

[elizabethr]

5 Armo
4 Dempster
3 Longer
2 Lonnie
1 Fisher

[Hallalj#3]

5 Armo
4 Steven
3 Longer
2 Lonie
1 Billings..

Worst on ground Geary very frustrating player.

[elizabethr]

Steven had 14 disposals

[8856brother]

Steven had 14 disposals

And 11 tackles.

5 Armo
4 Longer
3 Lonie
2 Dempster
1 Fisher

[saintbob]

5 Armitage
4 Schneider
3 Longer
2 Lonie
1 Bruce

[gambler]

5 Longer
4 Lonie
3 Curren
2 Armo
1 Sinclair

[Griggsy]

Too busy swearing to notice who our best were.

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Longer
3 - Armitage
3 - Steven
2 - Schneider
1 - Geary
1 - Billings

0 - Umpires

[mad saint guy]

5 Longer
4 Armitage
3 Lonie
2 Steven
1 Billings

[plugger66]

5 Longer
4 Armo
3 Lonie
2 Geary
1 Steven

[whiskers3614]

5 Longer
4 Armo
3 Lonie
2 Geary
1 Steven

are you trolling Plugger or were the rest so bad?
(I didn't see or hear the game ,just going on comments on other threads)

[plugger66]

5 Longer
4 Armo
3 Lonie
2 Geary
1 Steven

are you trolling Plugger or were the rest so bad?
(I didn't see or hear the game ,just going on comments on other threads)

It was hard to watch the hole game because one I was drinking and 2 I was also watching Ormond play. I thought he did ok but I could certainly be wrong. All I know is Longer was our best. And Geary did nearly have our most possessions.

[gringo]

5 Longer
4 Armo
3 Lonie
2 Geary
1 Steven

are you trolling Plugger or were the rest so bad?
(I didn't see or hear the game ,just going on comments on other threads)

It was hard to watch the hole game because one I was drinking and 2 I was also watching Ormond play. I thought he did ok but I could certainly be wrong. All I know is Longer was our best. And Geary did nearly have our most possessions.

He made a few mistakes but he was far from the problem. He was pretty solid I thought. Shenton too, people bagged him out again but he was good IMO. We lost it from the midfield again.

[Toy Saint]

P66 votes are fair enough, it interesting that he thought Longer was our best, given he's been pushing to replace him with Hickey. Perhaps it demonstrates that he can actually be honest and objective.

[matrix]

5 armo
4 longer
3 steven
2 schneides
1 lonie

[milney044]

Surprised no one has mentioned Roberton..in a backline that struggled for creativity I really liked his ability to back himself and take the game on, great to see him back in form.

5. Armitage
4.Steven
3.Longer
2.Roberton
1.Lonie

[Scollop]

5 Armo
4 Chips
3 Steven
2 Longer
1 Lonie

Sinclair/Dunstan/JB/Gears/Shents/Schneids/Dempster/Bruce and Roberton also worthy efforts

[Bernard Shakey]

Chips
Lonie
Roberton
Bruce
Billings