Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

No change


What I want is no change.

[dragit]

I also fear change.

[#gosaintas]

Out - Shenton, Membrey, Curren
In - Webster, Paddy, Joey

I wish

[FQF]

If Saad doesn't get up:
Minch in, Saad out

Otherwise:
No change

[saintbob]

Schneider in for Saad

[Saint wagga]

NO Chnage for mine after a great win.

But i do want to see changes when the performance drops off. I'm looking for cut throat selection and pressure for spots, especially for youngsters without runs on the board. ie if Lonie's form dips, bang, dropped, and bring Minchington in if his form stays very good in the two's

[coopergrech]

In : Schneids
Out: Saad or Curren

[Bunk_Moreland]

Depends on how they have pulled up after consecutive six day breaks.

Saad maybe after his whack.

Don't know why someone would think Shenton would need to be replaced after last weeks effort.

I thought he should have been dropped after GWS however he redeemed himself well against GC.

Don't think it sends a good message to the players if you drop a player after he has busted a gut to improve his performance

So for me

Out: Saad (only if not recovered)

In: Templeton, playing up forward.

Collingwoods defence is stretched and Eli with space could create major issues up forward.

[Beno88]

Out : Saad

In : Templeton

[The Redeemer]

Depends on how they have pulled up after consecutive six day breaks.

Saad maybe after his whack.

Don't know why someone would think Shenton would need to be replaced after last weeks effort.

I thought he should have been dropped after GWS however he redeemed himself well against GC.

Don't think it sends a good message to the players if you drop a player after he has busted a gut to improve his performance

So for me

Out: Saad (only if not recovered)

In: Templeton, playing up forward.

Collingwoods defence is stretched and Eli with space could create major issues up forward.

I do not see the value in Eli just yet. He has played 7 games with 1.5 pre-seasons coupled with a small frame. Whilst he is classy and seemingly composed, not just yet.

I think both sides' defences are going to be stretched as both sides are not too flash. It should be a good game!

[Kernal75]

No change unless required by injury.

If Saad doesnt come up then;

Out : Saad
In: McKenzie

[Moods]

What's happening with Joey? Surely if he's available he comes straight back in. Has to.

[spert]

What's happening with Joey? Surely if he's available he comes straight back in. Has to.

Depends on how we go against the Pies- if the midfield do well, then he might have to wait his turn.

[dragit]

What's happening with Joey? Surely if he's available he comes straight back in. Has to.

Still has an issue with his knee I think.

[bigballs]

What's happening with Joey? Surely if he's available he comes straight back in. Has to.

Still has an issue with his knee I think.

Apparently they are going to give Joey another week to get over his knee injury according to the Injury report from the club physio.

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2015-04-1 ... ey-to-miss

[Bunk_Moreland]

Depends on how they have pulled up after consecutive six day breaks.

Saad maybe after his whack.

Don't know why someone would think Shenton would need to be replaced after last weeks effort.

I thought he should have been dropped after GWS however he redeemed himself well against GC.

Don't think it sends a good message to the players if you drop a player after he has busted a gut to improve his performance

So for me

Out: Saad (only if not recovered)

In: Templeton, playing up forward.

Collingwoods defence is stretched and Eli with space could create major issues up forward.

I do not see the value in Eli just yet. He has played 7 games with 1.5 pre-seasons coupled with a small frame. Whilst he is classy and seemingly composed, not just yet.

I think both sides' defences are going to be stretched as both sides are not too flash. It should be a good game!

probably correct, it is just a speculative pick. I reckon they probably go for Schneider if Saad is out

[PJ]

On Sandy form and amount of pre-season games the only 2 you'd think would be Minch and Eli.

I'll go Minch for Saad

[Stephen Theodore]

Also hope no change.

Schnieder, if Saad is ruled out

[Spinner]

Out saad

In Acres

[saintsRrising]

No Change....except perhaps Sub of Wright for Schneider

If there is a change you would imagine it woould revolve around our Sub Wright as they may not want him playing two Sub games in a row.
> Sinclair played very well and so cannot imagine that they would demote him to Sub.
> Saad was BOG prior to kis KO. So would start unless ruled out
> Forecast is for rain, and as game is at night swapping Schneider for Wright could be prudent.

[bergholt]

IN: Schneider
OUT: Curren

Schneids had his best game in a while in round one, seems an automatic inclusion for mine. Curren out not because he did much wrong but on like-for-like and last-in-first-out principles.

[4ever_saint]

Probably not going to factor into the ins and outs but interesting to note that Jen Phelan from the AFL is at the Saints' final training run this afternoon and is reporting on Twitter that Riewoldt has his calf heavily strapped. Take that for what it's worth.

Riewoldt in heavy consultation with Richo and Wallis (head physio) about the left calf.

Source:

[SaintPav]

Do we still have to wait until the cheesy Seven News for Timmy to read the teams out?

[Junction Oval]

Out - Saad (concussion).
Out - Rooey (calf).

In - Schneider
In - McCartin

[Old Mate]

Out: Saad & Membrey (both inj)
In: Schneider & McCartin