Lockett 73% Hudghton 27%

[kosifantutti]

Who is your favourite Saint out of:

Max Hudghton


Or

Tony Lockett

[st.byron]

Love Max....

but Plugger then daylight

[ROLS-LEE]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

[Sam23]

This s*** is pointless mate.

Give it a rest.

[james rose]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

Or those who appreciate a one club player

[kosifantutti]

This s*** is pointless mate.

Give it a rest.

Thanks for the feedback.

I'll take it on board.

[Muir_32]

Plugger for me... Greatest I have seen.

[Mr Magic]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

Or those who appreciate a one club player

As distinct from a Club Champion who scurried off to the opposition and taught them how to best our most potent weapon?

Loved Max when he played for us but was very disappointed with the way he 'ran' to Collinwood after not being selected in 2009 GF.

[plugger66]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

Or those who appreciate a one club player

As distinct from a Club Champion who scurried off to the opposition and taught them how to best our most potent weapon?

Loved Max when he played for us but was very disappointed with the way he 'ran' to Collinwood after not being selected in 2009 GF.

Cant believe both of you. Surely its a job and like any job if you go to in the same industry they try and find out what you know about the opposition. The other choice for Max was to give up maybe 100k. I don't know about you but I wouldn't be doing that. Anyway its Plugger for me because he was the best Saint I have ever seen and by a clear margin.

[stinger]

This s*** is pointless mate.

Give it a rest.

Thanks for the feedback.

I'll take it on board.

well...you have been warned

[plugger66]

This s*** is pointless mate.

Give it a rest.

Thanks for the feedback.

I'll take it on board.

well...you have been warned

You just don't get how best of 32 and best of 16's work Stinger. You don't have even match ups at that stage even though this is a set formula. If you had even match ups early they would be uneven later. It isn't hard to work out.

[Playon]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

There's quite a few players I'd vote for over Plugger, but then aren't we voting for favorites, not who you think is best?

[plugger66]

Exactly Plugger will win the whole contest. The only people that won't vote for him would be the kids that never saw him play.

There's quite a few players I'd vote for over Plugger, but then aren't we voting for favorites, not who you think is best?

I think you can vote anyway you like. I have decided to vote on the best I have seen and he was certainly the most favourite player I wanted to watch .

[St Chris]

Happy to vote for Maxy.

Plugger was a better player, but Max was no slouch. And because this is a vote for "favorite" rather than best, I'll always vote for the guy that stuck around with the Saints rather than chase cash up north.

[skeptic]

Plugger would kick 7 on him

on the topic raised in this thread... I know at least one if not 2 players that will get my vote ahead of plugger

[PADDLEPOP1001]

Plugger!

[kosifantutti]

Final results
Lockett 36 Hudghton 13