Milne 84% Fisher 16%

[kosifantutti]

Who is your favourite saint out of:

Stephen Milne
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/ ... Milne.html

or

Sam Fisher
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/ ... isher.html

[FQF]

Very tough, both integral parts to our dominant era.

[tweedaletomanning]

Very tough, both integral parts to our dominant era.

True, But Milney made it fun!!

[Life Long Saint]

That night Milne kicked 11 against Brisbane in the final round of 2005 remains one of my favourite nights at the footy.

[MCG-Unit]

Voted Sam Fisher.....

Thought it was favourite, not necessarily best

[Munga]

Tough. Can't split, won't vote.

[skeptic]

It's not tough...

One is a good player for his time, the other arguably the best small forward of all time

No brainer

[plugger66]

It's not tough...

One is a good player for his time, the other arguably the best small forward of all time

No brainer

Reckon you are really harsh on Fisher. 2 B&F make him better than a good player and he has also been AA.

[stinger]

That night Milne kicked 11 against Brisbane in the final round of 2005 remains one of my favourite nights at the footy.

i can relate to that....and someone...forget who....cleaned up that white headed brissie prick...i went with a commonwealth government prosecutor.....a brissie fan...he sat there glumly all night...

[desertsaint]

Milne - legendary character and possibly the greatest small forward of all time.
Endured more flack than likely any other player in history, but good enough to play through it.
All time Saints great!
Chips unlucky to meet an irrepressible force in round one.

[stinger]

Milne - legendary character and possibly the greatest small forward of all time.
Endured more flack than likely any other player in history, but good enough to play through it.
All time Saints great!
Chips unlucky to meet an irrepressible force in round one.

+1

[skeptic]

It's not tough...

One is a good player for his time, the other arguably the best small forward of all time

No brainer

Reckon you are really harsh on Fisher. 2 B&F make him better than a good player and he has also been AA.

I don't think I am

if you made a team of the last 10 years... Sam Fisher would be worthy of consideration but he wouldn't make it. Milne would

I don't mean to diss the guy but like Lenny Vs Plugger, there's a clear winner here

[plugger66]

It's not tough...

One is a good player for his time, the other arguably the best small forward of all time

No brainer

Reckon you are really harsh on Fisher. 2 B&F make him better than a good player and he has also been AA.

I don't think I am

if you made a team of the last 10 years... Sam Fisher would be worthy of consideration but he wouldn't make it. Milne would

I don't mean to diss the guy but like Lenny Vs Plugger, there's a clear winner here

Im talking about the term good player not that he should beat MIlne.

[kosifantutti]

Final result
Milne 42 Fisher 8

[Scollop]

That night Milne kicked 11 against Brisbane in the final round of 2005 remains one of my favourite nights at the footy.

i can relate to that....and someone...forget who....cleaned up that white headed brissie prick...i went with a commonwealth government prosecutor.....a brissie fan...he sat there glumly all night...

I'll never forget Milnies efforts in late 2010. He single handedly got us over the line in the close ones and that helped us cement a top 4 spot. His match winning goals and inspiritional goals were undoubtedly the difference in so many games.

His efforts in h&a 2010 were enough for me to concede that he was a champ and he was very stiff not to have earned his first AA that year....Then Milne also showed that he was finally able to perform on the big stage and he was a match winner again in the finals. The AA selectors had stuffed up again (I suppose if history is going to repeat you could lock in Priddis as a certainty for AA next year)