Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Saint Stu · Tue 21 Oct 2014 12:04pm

Geelong has delisted Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown, are either worth looking at????

White Winmar · Tue 21 Oct 2014 12:13pm

The Redeemer · Tue 21 Oct 2014 2:38pm

ShanghaiSaint · Tue 21 Oct 2014 2:51pm

Saint Stu wrote:Geelong has delisted Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown, are either worth looking at????

No

plugger66 · Post: # 1512384Post **plugger66** » Tue 21 Oct 2014 3:14pm

Get both. Please.

#gosaintas · Tue 21 Oct 2014 3:38pm

If they come from geelong they must be great. They have never had a dud on their list.

SENsei · Post: # 1512397Post **SENsei** » Tue 21 Oct 2014 3:41pm

I'd take Mitch Brown.

What?

Sorry?

Huh?

What do you mean there are two Mitch Browns?

Well colour me purple. I want the other one then!

plugger66 · Post: # 1512398Post **plugger66** » Tue 21 Oct 2014 3:47pm

SENsaintsational wrote:I'd take Mitch Brown.

What?

Sorry?

Huh?

What do you mean there are two Mitch Browns?

Well colour me purple. I want the other one then!

Didn't we get 2 years ago?

WinnersOnly · Tue 21 Oct 2014 5:42pm

If Ross Lyon was here they would be on there way to Seaford - thankfully our talent scouting has improved!

plugger66 · Post: # 1512456Post **plugger66** » Tue 21 Oct 2014 5:51pm

WinnersOnly wrote:If Ross Lyon was here they would be on there way to Seaford - thankfully our talent scouting has improved!

Like Schneider, Dempster, Ray, King and MG. Remember we had no money in the cap and also a pathetic recruiting department. Not sure there were many choices.

remboy · Post: # 1512458Post **remboy** » Tue 21 Oct 2014 5:55pm

Is Taylor Hunt that bad? Thought he looked half decent when I've seen him. Not that we've got a spot on the list for him anyway.

saint6709 · Post: # 1513045Post **saint6709** » Fri 24 Oct 2014 2:03pm

I actually think if a few things fall his way Mitch Brown might be a good pick up for us.

Cheltenham/Sandy lad originally seen as a high draft pick (went at 15)- from what I've seen he looks OK - and has battled for a spot against some very good tall defenders.

But I think he needs 2 things to fall his way for this to be on the cards -

1 we draft a key back ie Mcdonald - who will need a few years to develop into the position.
2 Josh Bruce plays mainly forward

Delany will be our sizable defender and will surely need someone who is 'ready to go' - ie a mature aged player, to help out while we develop another class backman. If anything if Bruce is to play forward surely someone like Brown will be required if we haven't drafted a Mcdonald type player

Given that he is delisted can we just sign him ? Can we sign him as a rookie ?

stinger · Post: # 1513057Post **stinger** » Fri 24 Oct 2014 2:57pm

the question is.....will either of them win you a premiership???....girlong obviously doesn't think so....why should we??????

saint6709 · Post: # 1513071Post **saint6709** » Fri 24 Oct 2014 4:01pm

stinger wrote:the question is.....will either of them win you a premiership???....girlong obviously doesn't think so....why should we??????

As per my above post I don't think that's the question at all - the question is who will be our second key back in the next few years while we develop a key back of premiership winning ability ?

Joffa Burns · Fri 24 Oct 2014 4:18pm

Given they have been delisted it is probably safe to assume they were offered as steak knives in the Rhys Stanley deal and rejected, so I would be thinking the club has little interest in them.
Taylor Hunt is a reasonable run with player with very average disposal, I don't think we need another one of these on our list.

Mitch brown is KP size but doesn't play with KP aggression or presence.

No to both from me.

Dis Believer · Wed 29 Oct 2014 9:43am

Taylor Hunt was on SEN this morning and unless I mis-heard him, has been invited to do pre-season training with the Saints.......

dragit · Post: # 1513787Post **dragit** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 9:52am

True Believer wrote:Taylor Hunt was on SEN this morning and unless I mis-heard him, has been invited to do pre-season training with the Saints.......

Sweet, now that we have got rid of Pelchen we can finally fast track this rebuild: Taylor Hunt, Mitch Brown, Shaun McKernan, Patrenko, Robinson, Lucas…

For the love of god, no more average recycled players that can't get games at struggling clubs please.

magnifisaint · Wed 29 Oct 2014 10:12am

True Believer wrote:Taylor Hunt was on SEN this morning and unless I mis-heard him, has been invited to do pre-season training with the Saints.......

He wants to go to Richmond or that's what the papers say.

Armagizmo · Wed 29 Oct 2014 10:25am

dragit wrote:
True Believer wrote:Taylor Hunt was on SEN this morning and unless I mis-heard him, has been invited to do pre-season training with the Saints.......
Sweet, now that we have got rid of Pelchen we can finally fast track this rebuild: Taylor Hunt, Mitch Brown, Shaun McKernan, Patrenko, Robinson, Lucas…

For the love of god, no more average recycled players that can't get games at struggling clubs please.

Petrenko's shown a bit hasn't he? I've always thought him a pretty handy player when fit. Plus, his wikipedia page (lol) says he grew up a Saints fan.

gringo · Post: # 1513795Post **gringo** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 10:29am

If the club looks at a few recycled players and chooses one to be a rookie it's probably because they want to fill in holes in the age profile. We are fast becoming the youngest list in the comp so possibly not the worst move just hope we don't loose spots that a got junior rookie might get.

dragit · Post: # 1513796Post **dragit** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 10:30am

Armagizmo wrote:
dragit wrote:
True Believer wrote:Taylor Hunt was on SEN this morning and unless I mis-heard him, has been invited to do pre-season training with the Saints.......
Sweet, now that we have got rid of Pelchen we can finally fast track this rebuild: Taylor Hunt, Mitch Brown, Shaun McKernan, Patrenko, Robinson, Lucas…

For the love of god, no more average recycled players that can't get games at struggling clubs please.
Petrenko's shown a bit hasn't he? I've always thought him a pretty handy player when fit. Plus, his wikipedia page (lol) says he grew up a Saints fan.

dennis-lane showed a bit too.

Petrenko doesn't get the ball, doesn't kick many goals, doesn't make many tackles… so I think we can safely give him a miss.

dragit · Post: # 1513797Post **dragit** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 10:32am

gringo wrote:If the club looks at a few recycled players and chooses one to be a rookie it's probably because they want to fill in holes in the age profile. We are fast becoming the youngest list in the comp so possibly not the worst move just hope we don't loose spots that a got junior rookie might get.

Yes it would be a terrible move.

A few recycled players means a few young guys don't come to the club.

stinger · Post: # 1513801Post **stinger** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 11:19am

dragit wrote:
gringo wrote:If the club looks at a few recycled players and chooses one to be a rookie it's probably because they want to fill in holes in the age profile. We are fast becoming the youngest list in the comp so possibly not the worst move just hope we don't loose spots that a got junior rookie might get.
Yes it would be a terrible move.

A few recycled players means a few young guys don't come to the club.

hasn't worked for us in the past...

fingers · Post: # 1513804Post **fingers** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 11:57am

#gosaintas wrote:If they come from geelong they must be great. They have never had a dud on their list.

Charlie Gardner

stinger · Post: # 1513838Post **stinger** » Wed 29 Oct 2014 2:33pm

fingers wrote:
#gosaintas wrote:If they come from geelong they must be great. They have never had a dud on their list.

Charlie Gardner

well said...and in only two words....

Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???

Re: Taylor Hunt & Mitch Brown worth a look???