Pick 1 & 21 for Melbournes picks 2 & 3??

[Faulky63]

This was one of the brief subjects that Pelchin mentioned last night when on Twitter, has anyone heard this previously and what would people think?

[saintsRrising]

Why would the Dees be that stupid?

Pretracca+?? is less than Brashaw + McCartin

[plugger66]

This was one of the brief subjects that Pelchin mentioned last night when on Twitter, has anyone heard this previously and what would people think?

Would be sensational but Melbourne have said they want to use one of their pick on a young promising player so I don't see how it happens.

[Verdun66]

Pick 1, 21, and a player for Picks 2 and 3 maybe. They get Petracca, and ? And ?. We get Brayshaw and McCartin.

Depends on who our player was I suppose if this was if this was on the cards.

[St Chris]

I reckon something like 1 and 10 for 2 and 3 might be possible. 1 and 21 wouldn't cut it IMO.

There was talk the Dogs were trying to move up to get McCartin, so Melbourne might trade with them first, and offer 2 and 6 for Pick 1???

[plugger66]

Pick 1, 21, and a player for Picks 2 and 3 maybe. They get Petracca, and ? And ?. We get Brayshaw and McCartin.

Depend on who our player was I suppose if this was if this was on the cards.

No mention of a player in the deal.

[Verdun66]

No kidding? What I'm saying is that would probably be the only way it would work.

[Austinnn]

Still would say no to that.

[avid]

We should say Yes to that!

Petracca is not superhuman.
He's (apparently) the best, but McCartin/Wright and Brayshaw must surely add up to more.

[Con Gorozidis]

2+ 3 > 1 + 21 imo.

[magnifisaint]

We should say Yes to that!

Petracca is not superhuman.
He's (apparently) the best, but McCartin/Wright and Brayshaw must surely add up to more.

I agree with Austinn.

[Bunk_Moreland]

Posted by a Hawk supporter on bigfooty

Please god don't give away pick 1 to anyone (except us of course). You're going to be competing with the giants and saints in a few years time, and he's the one kid for years now that could genuinely win a finals series off his own boot. He and Dunstan will be a disgusting midfield pairing. You're sort of as close to being guaranteed a Fyfe/Dangerfield as anyone ever has been.

certainly gives you pause to think

Petracca/Dunstan close to a Fyfe/Dangerfield combination - OMG that gets me excited

[Dave McNamara]

There was talk the Dogs were trying to move up to get McCartin, so Melbourne might trade with them first, and offer 2 and 6 for Pick 1???

I really hope that happens!

Would guarantee we do not end up with McOneTrickCartin... and with flooding... it ain't much of a trick.

We must get Petracca unless someone makes us a ridiculous offer.

[kosifantutti]

Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

[Dave McNamara]

1/ Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
2/ Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
3/ Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
4/ Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

Very interesting approach Kosi.

My attempt...

1/ With Goose's broken leg... line ball. Without Ball's O Pubis... I'd take 2&3.

2/ No deal. BJ better than all the other three combined. Easily!
(Brennan more talent maybe than all the other three combined, but wasted all of that talent.
Wells... mentally soft... and yep, that's an euphemism.)

3/ No deal. See 2/, but substitute the names Cooney for Goddard, Sylvia for Brennan, and 'plain overrated' for Walker.

4/ Easiest choice of all. Picks 2&3 please. Where do I sign?
(However, Petrucca will be no Deledio... which is reason why I want Petracca!
For Deledio... see Wells.)

[Razzledazzle]

No brained! The Club should believe in the riches of the draft.If on offer I say take 2&3 for 1 &21. Go Sainters!!

[kosifantutti]

1/ Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
2/ Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
3/ Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
4/ Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

Very interesting approach Kosi.

My attempt...

1/ With Goose's broken leg... line ball. Without Ball's O Pubis... I'd take 2&3.

2/ No deal. BJ better than all the other three combined. Easily!
(Brennan more talent maybe than all the other three combined, but wasted all of that talent.
Wells... mentally soft... and yep, that's an euphemism.)

3/ No deal. See 2/, but substitute the names Cooney for Goddard, Sylvia for Brennan, and 'plain overrated' for Walker.

4/ Easiest choice of all. Picks 2&3 please. Where do I sign?
(However, Petrucca will be no Deledio... which is reason why I want Petracca!
For Deledio... see Wells.)

Should have gone back one more year.
Kosi and Didak for Nick Riewoldt and Nick Ries.

[FQF]

Happy to take Petracca - quality over quantity every time.

[Dave McNamara]

1/ Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
2/ Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
3/ Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
4/ Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

Very interesting approach Kosi.

My attempt...

1/ With Goose's broken leg... line ball. Without Ball's O Pubis... I'd take 2&3.

2/ No deal. BJ better than all the other three combined. Easily!
(Brennan more talent maybe than all the other three combined, but wasted all of that talent.
Wells... mentally soft... and yep, that's an euphemism.)

3/ No deal. See 2/, but substitute the names Cooney for Goddard, Sylvia for Brennan, and 'plain overrated' for Walker.

4/ Easiest choice of all. Picks 2&3 please. Where do I sign?
(However, Petrucca will be no Deledio... which is reason why I want Petracca!
For Deledio... see Wells.)

Should have gone back one more year.
Kosi and Didak for Nick Riewoldt and Nick Ries.

1 & 21 please! But not a fair example Kosi. Having 'pistols' Didak in any comparative duo immediately rules-out said duo.

[Con Gorozidis]

Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

You won me on BO Nixon

[Rosco]

Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

You won me on BO Nixon

shouldn't it be judd + ball vs hodge + maguire? judd wasn't pick 1

[plugger66]

Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

You won me on BO Nixon

shouldn't it be judd + ball vs hodge + maguire? judd wasn't pick 1

Ball was pick 2 though. No idea what goose has to do with it.

[Rosco]

Comparing examples of where a trade of picks 2 & 3 versus 1 & 21 would get you. Even though we now have 1 & 22.

I realise ball was pick 2, judd 3.

[kosifantutti]

Ball and Hodge for Judd and Maguire?
Wells and Brennan for Goddard and BO Nixon?
Walker and Sylvia for Cooney and Alex Gilmour.
Roughead and Griffen for Deledio and Tom Murphy

You won me on BO Nixon

shouldn't it be judd + ball vs hodge + maguire? judd wasn't pick 1

Ball was pick 2 though. No idea what goose has to do with it.

Maguire was pick 21. And yes, I had hodge and Judd the wrong way around.