Tim membrey

[MC Gusto]

Can't crack the swans forward line, kicked 104 goals in the NEAFL, cracking kick.

Thoughts?

Bit of talk we are chasing him

[plugger66]

I wouldn't but id rather him than the likes of 3 to 5 year players who have struggled to become permanents at their club. His problem is he is a third tall at best because he is just a little small.

[Old Mate]

His problem is trying to get a go in a forward line which includes Tippet, Buddy, Goodes and Reid.

He's kicked 50 goals in both 2013 and 2014. Not bad for a 20 year old.

[defacto]

anything from the 3rd round onwards would be a worthwhile price for membrey. he is extremely strong for his size and extremely accurate on goal. the knock on him was his tank and agility, but it looks like he has worked hard on his tank and is starting to come through

would be a very good get at the right price

[plugger66]

His problem is trying to get a go in a forward line which includes Tippet, Buddy, Goodes and Reid.

He's kicked 50 goals in both 2013 and 2014. Not bad for a 20 year old.

Probably only playing A grade amateur standard though.

[Old Mate]

anything from the 3rd round onwards would be a worthwhile price for membrey. he is extremely strong for his size and extremely accurate on goal. the knock on him was his tank and agility, but it looks like he has worked hard on his tank and is starting to come through

would be a very good get at the right price

What I like about him is the simple fact he's a footy player first and an athlete second. He's like the opposite to Stanley.

[plugger66]

anything from the 3rd round onwards would be a worthwhile price for membrey. he is extremely strong for his size and extremely accurate on goal. the knock on him was his tank and agility, but it looks like he has worked hard on his tank and is starting to come through

would be a very good get at the right price

What I like about him is the simple fact he's a footy player first and an athlete second. He's like the opposite to Stanley.

The problem with using a third round on him and a rumoured second round on jakach is we don't get hardly any unproven players and yes I know one could be an LJ but it could also be a Steven. Don't want to many with unproven AFL experience IMO. That would leave pick one and only probably pick 4 as new AFL players.

[MC Gusto]

anything from the 3rd round onwards would be a worthwhile price for membrey. he is extremely strong for his size and extremely accurate on goal. the knock on him was his tank and agility, but it looks like he has worked hard on his tank and is starting to come through

would be a very good get at the right price

What I like about him is the simple fact he's a footy player first and an athlete second. He's like the opposite to Stanley.

This

[Old Mate]

I wouldn't use a third on Membry. Pick 47 two years ago and played one senior game. 4/5 rounder at best.

Jaksch I'm not overly keen on. I'd prefer to use our 2nd on O'Rourke but seems he's off to Hawthorn.

[defacto]

I wouldn't use a third on Membry. Pick 47 two years ago and played one senior game. 4/5 rounder at best.

Jaksch I'm not overly keen on. I'd prefer to use our 2nd on O'Rourke but seems he's off to Hawthorn.

i said third round as the likes of the doggies, essendon, carlton might force our hand

[Old Mate]

I wouldn't use a third on Membry. Pick 47 two years ago and played one senior game. 4/5 rounder at best.

Jaksch I'm not overly keen on. I'd prefer to use our 2nd on O'Rourke but seems he's off to Hawthorn.

i said third round as the likes of the doggies, essendon, carlton might force our hand

Our 3rd is too high a pick IMO even if a bidding war begins. Hopefully we come to terms with Membry - nice contract and worry about dealing with Syd later. We can get him in the PSD if needed.

[defacto]

I wouldn't use a third on Membry. Pick 47 two years ago and played one senior game. 4/5 rounder at best.

Jaksch I'm not overly keen on. I'd prefer to use our 2nd on O'Rourke but seems he's off to Hawthorn.

i said third round as the likes of the doggies, essendon, carlton might force our hand

Our 3rd is too high a pick IMO even if a bidding war begins. Hopefully we come to terms with Membry - nice contract and worry about dealing with Syd later. We can get him in the PSD if needed.

we might not even be using a third rounder in the draft

[Old Mate]

I wouldn't use a third on Membry. Pick 47 two years ago and played one senior game. 4/5 rounder at best.

Jaksch I'm not overly keen on. I'd prefer to use our 2nd on O'Rourke but seems he's off to Hawthorn.

i said third round as the likes of the doggies, essendon, carlton might force our hand

Our 3rd is too high a pick IMO even if a bidding war begins. Hopefully we come to terms with Membry - nice contract and worry about dealing with Syd later. We can get him in the PSD if needed.

we might not even be using a third rounder in the draft

Good point. That would be to Syd's benefit.

[howlinwolf]

We may be looking at him with thought of playing him in the midfield. He's a goal kicker and would be a good height.

[Munga]

Could he be a Stevie J type?

[dragit]

Dennis-Lane straight swap since they duped us from the beginning.

[jonesy]

How many project forwards can we fit into the one side?

Stanley,Bruce,Lee,White

Rewoildt there for next two years,and now we are linked to Jaksch and Membrey?

Get a good one,otherwise stick to loading up on the midfield

[gringo]

Could he be a Stevie J type?

He looks more a Hammill type undersized KPF. Jack Darling is a comparison I have heard.

[saintsRrising]

How many project forwards can we fit into the one side?

Stanley,Bruce,Lee,White

Add Siposs...

Rewoildt there for next two years,and now we are linked to Jaksch and Membrey?

Get a good one,otherwise stick to loading up on the midfield

This.

Plus what we need is more cream. We already have a pretty big supporting cast...including guys with potential such as Hickey, Longer, Bruce....

Has only played 1 game!!! If he is very cheap maybe...but are we going to delist.

Our first 3 picks need to be on quality players.

[saintsRrising]

Could he be a Stevie J type?

He looks more a Hammill type undersized KPF. Jack Darling is a comparison I have heard.

Except Tim is 188cm, and Jack is 191cm.

[Scoop]

We may be looking at him with thought of playing him in the midfield. He's a goal kicker and would be a good height.

His tank would need to have improved from a couple of years ago...but agreed this could be an option....especially if we trade #1.....big bodied former forward, turned midfielder that can kick goals (similar to Petracca)...

[Scoop]

We may be looking at him with thought of playing him in the midfield. He's a goal kicker and would be a good height.

His tank would need to have improved from a couple of years ago...but agreed this could be an option....especially if we trade #1.....big bodied former forward, turned midfielder that can kick goals (similar to Petracca)...

[evertonfc]

A battle between him and Sipposs if we took him on. Hmmmm.

[The Redeemer]

Could he be a Stevie J type?

No.

[LTN16]

Could he be a Stevie J type?

He looks more a Hammill type undersized KPF. Jack Darling is a comparison I have heard.

Good comparison. The NEAFL is a pretty weak comp so 100 goals for an AFL player in that comp is no mean feat..