Cam O’Shea to St Kilda ? Gwilt to Crows?

[SaintWodonga]

HS reporting we are inline for the young defender and Gwilt to the Crows:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/t ... 7041355579

Read more about Oshea:
http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/player ... eron-oshea

Anyone rate Cam?

What would the Crows give up (for Gwilt)?

[WinnersOnly]

Obviously Richo rates him (OShea) but he listed at 193cm defender so another tall down back is great! Be interested how they work Gwilt/Milera to Crows getting in return a player from Port?

[St Chris]

Another undersized key defender - just what we need....

[Bluthy]

He's got some real dash which we need. Can't really tell about his kicking though https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4mXPUJxzRM

[Bunk_Moreland]

What ever we get for Gwilt (R3 at best) give to Port, O'shea was only #52 and hasn't done much at Port

Seems like just a younger version of Gwilt

[BringBackMadDog]

Another undersized key defender - just what we need....

He is not a key defender, he is a tall mid/utility. He has elite endurance was in the top 3 or 4 in 3km time trial at draft combine and that was after suffering a few injuries just before. He also has a 14.7 beep test. He is a great kick and hard as nails. If we could get him it would certainly be a good get

[bergholt]

Another undersized key defender - just what we need....

He is not a key defender, he is a tall mid/utility. He has elite endurance was in the top 3 or 4 in 3km time trial at draft combine and that was after suffering a few injuries just before. He also has a 14.7 beep test. He is a great kick and hard as nails.

That makes more sense then. Certainly agree with St Chris that we don't need another undersized key back - may as well keep Simpkin!

[oldie60]

Good get,has been unable to string too many games due to niggling injuries and Port do have an abundance of similar players which has made it hard being in and out of the side.

[luc1966]

He is listed at 1.97

[luc1966]

Ok afl listed is 1.93

[Con Gorozidis]

Gwilt is 187?

I dont think the Crows would give up much for him

[The Redeemer]

What ever we get for Gwilt (R3 at best) give to Port, O'shea was only #52 and hasn't done much at Port

Seems like just a younger version of Gwilt

I would take my chances with O'Shea considering how terrible Gwilt has been for a few years now.

[borderbarry]

He is listed on Port Adelaides website as 193cm. That doesnt mean much. Stanley is still listed at 200cm on ours.

[gringo]

Gwilt is 187?

I dont think the Crows would give up much for him

Free agent so exactly nothing would be our compensation.

[Toy Saint]

Plenty here reckon we should delist Gwilt anyway, so a trade for a young defender with skills would be a good deal for us

[gringo]

Gwilt is 187?

I dont think the Crows would give up much for him

Free agent so exactly nothing would be our compensation.

That would be they would give us nothing for him. We would get round 3 compo though probs.

[Munga]

Gwilt to the Crows for Talia, straight swap.

[Sobraz]

Gwilt to the Crows for Talia, straight swap.

Reckon they'll need to throw in thier first rounder to get that done.
Talia+8/9 for Jimmy, done deal!!

[saint6709]

Another undersized key defender - just what we need....

He is not a key defender, he is a tall mid/utility. He has elite endurance was in the top 3 or 4 in 3km time trial at draft combine and that was after suffering a few injuries just before. He also has a 14.7 beep test. He is a great kick and hard as nails.

That makes more sense then. Certainly agree with St Chris that we don't need another undersized key back - may as well keep Simpkin!

++1

[Munga]

Gwilt to the Crows for Talia, straight swap.

Reckon they'll need to throw in thier first rounder to get that done.
Talia+8/9 for Jimmy, done deal!!

Packaged with Sloane for a third rounder

[Bunk_Moreland]

And so our season begins.

[SainterK]

All the best to Jimmy.

Hope he lands a gig somewhere.

Would suit a side where he gets the third best forward.

[matrix]

He ain't gone yet

[Stephen Theodore]

All the best to Jimmy.

Hope he lands a gig somewhere.

Would suit a side where he gets the third best forward.

Just like he used to get with us

[The Redeemer]

He ain't gone yet

I hope he is though.