Round 13 Team Changes

[stkildathunda]

IN: Armitage, Gwilt, Webster

No outs at moment due to extended bench

[cwrcyn]

Well, after watching Sandy last week, they brought the right guys in.

It'll be out of Ross, Simpkin, Jones, Murdoch, and Billings.

[kosifantutti]

ST KILDA

B Sean Dempster, (Three to be omitted) Luke Delaney, (Three to be omitted) Cameron Shenton (Three to be omitted)
HB Brodie Murdoch, (Three to be omitted) Josh Bruce, (Three to be omitted) Jimmy Webster (Three to be omitted)
C Leigh Montagna, (Three to be omitted) Maverick Weller, (Three to be omitted) Jack Newnes (Three to be omitted)
HF Lenny Hayes, (Three to be omitted) Nick Riewoldt, (Three to be omitted) Terry Milera (Three to be omitted)
F Jack Billings, (Three to be omitted) Tom Lee, (Three to be omitted) Tom Simpkin (Three to be omitted)
FOL Billy Longer, (Three to be omitted) Jack Steven, (Three to be omitted) Luke Dunstan (Three to be omitted)
I/C Clinton Jones, (Three to be omitted) Sebastian Ross, (Three to be omitted) David Armitage, (Three to be omitted) Farren Ray, (Three to be omitted) James Gwilt, (Three to be omitted) Josh Saunders, (Three to be omitted) Sam Dunell (Three to be omitted)
IN
Jimmy Webster, David Armitage, James Gwilt

I think there's three to be omitted.

[plugger66]

I will go with Jimmy, Dunell and CJ not playing.

[saintspremiers]

I will go with Jimmy, Dunell and CJ not playing.

dunny and CJ must not play. I hope Webster plays though.

[bergsone]

Each week plenty keep calling for CJ to be dropped,yet it doesn't happen

[plugger66]

I will go with Jimmy, Dunell and CJ not playing.

dunny and CJ must not play. I hope Webster plays though.

Thats Gwilt not Webster.

[borderbarry]

Fornme it would be Jones, Ray, and Dunnell to miss.

[borderbarry]

For me it would be Jones, Ray, and Dunnell to miss.

[saint6709]

For me it would be Jones, Ray, and Dunnell to miss.

I would be happy with that - or rest Billings - let Ray play - I would trade Ray if possible end of season - he can play just can't kick to a target

[plugger66]

For me it would be Jones, Ray, and Dunnell to miss.

I would be happy with that - or rest Billings - let Ray play - I would trade Ray if possible end of season - he can play just can't kick to a target

Ray is worth nothing at all so he is delisted or stays.

[The Redeemer]

For me it would be Jones, Ray, and Dunnell to miss.

I would be happy with that - or rest Billings - let Ray play - I would trade Ray if possible end of season - he can play just can't kick to a target

Ray is worth nothing at all so he is delisted or stays.

So he stays.

Out go CJ and Dunnell, in come Webster and Armitage

[BigMart]

I'm sure Ray is happy with that comment

If I have to wander down to Seaford to tell a 25 game Ruckman ... I don't rate him

Perhaps you should do the same with a 150+ veteran who has been a mainstay in teams best 18 for the best part of a decade? Who is apparantly worthless. Farren on the trade table. Pick 45-55. Only because he's only got 4 or so years left. But with that pick... You've guaranteed youself a 50+ gamer.

[plugger66]

I'm sure Ray is happy with that comment

If I have to wander down to Seaford to tell a 25 game Ruckman ... I don't rate him

Perhaps you should do the same with a 150+ veteran who has been a mainstay in teams best 18 for the best part of a decade? Who is apparantly worthless. Farren on the trade table. Pick 45-55. Only because he's only got 4 or so years left. But with that pick... You've guaranteed youself a 50+ gamer.

I know you will never answer questions but is CJ or Lenny worth anything on the trade table. If I told Ray he wouldnt get traded I reckon he would go no s***. He is a keeper or he will be delisted. i would keep him based on current form. He is 29 next season so he cant be traded. You called Hickey a gumby I called Ray nothing at all. You really dont understand a lot of the time but hey keep trying.

[saintbob]

Only the two changes for me;

Billings and Jones out

Webster and Armitage in

[Con Gorozidis]

Only the two changes for me;

Billings and Jones out

Webster and Armitage in

Sounds fair.
For Gwilty to come in one of the defenders would have to go out.

[spert]

I think Dunell should get another game..a good player and a bit unfair to drop him after the team got clobbered by the in- form team. I was more disappointed with the efforts of experienced players in Ray and Jones who should go to the VFL and probably time to send Billings back to the VFL- he is a work in progress. Armo, Gwilt and Webster in.

[St Chris]

Only the two changes for me;

Billings and Jones out

Webster and Armitage in

Agree.

Stick a fork in Billings, cause he's done....give him a week off, then a few lower-intensity hitouts in the VFL before coming back for another stint in the Seniors later in the year.

Saunders was good last week, I'm happy for him to play that defensive forward role and keep Jones out. However, if Jones hasnt been dropped thus far, i'm not sure it will ever happen??

I'm not impressed with Dunell, for all his form in the VFL over the previous years, he's shown a whole lot of nothing at senior level. But he needs a stint of a month or so to see if there is any hope of a future at that level.

[dragit]

Why is billings done?

In just over a quarter he had 7 touches and 2 goal assists.

He keeps playing for mine unless sore.

[3rd generation saint]

I still would have bought Stanley back, simply because we need a back up ruckman and he is a better option than Lee.
Just hope he makes a good showing this weekend at Sandy, because we have Cox and Natenui (sorry if I spelt that wrong) next week.

[spert]

I think Stanley just has to do a whole lot more before he will get back in the seniors- needs to find that extra gear.

[plugger66]

Only the two changes for me;

Billings and Jones out

Webster and Armitage in

Agree.

Stick a fork in Billings, cause he's done....give him a week off, then a few lower-intensity hitouts in the VFL before coming back for another stint in the Seniors later in the year.

Saunders was good last week, I'm happy for him to play that defensive forward role and keep Jones out. However, if Jones hasnt been dropped thus far, i'm not sure it will ever happen??

I'm not impressed with Dunell, for all his form in the VFL over the previous years, he's shown a whole lot of nothing at senior level. But he needs a stint of a month or so to see if there is any hope of a future at that level.

I think Billings has played 5 quarters in 3 weeks.

[Con Gorozidis]

I think Stanley just has to do a whole lot more before he will get back in the seniors- needs to find that extra gear.

Waiting for Stanley's extra gear is like Waiting for Godot

[Bluthy]

I still would have bought Stanley back, simply because we need a back up ruckman and he is a better option than Lee.
Just hope he makes a good showing this weekend at Sandy, because we have Cox and Natenui (sorry if I spelt that wrong) next week.

Yeah it was a heavy load for Longer last week. Was he getting a chop out from Lee or Rooey I didn't really notice? Longer does strike me as one of those players who thrives on hard work. He needs to build up a big tank to start to be a able to make an impact away from hitouts. He got outmarked a couple of times when he was in front that was criminal. But he does work hard around the clearances when it hits the deck.

[Bunk_Moreland]

Billings is the only player in the teamthat can hit a target and people want him dropped?

Are we aiming at a new record in disposal inefficiency this weekend?