OK experts. Nearest the pin for the draft.

[White Winmar]

You've read the profiles. You've watched the highlight clips. You've studied the phantom drafts. Time to put your expertise to the test. Let's see who can get nearest the pin with their predictions. We oly have another 24 hours to wait for confirmation. I'll go first.
Pick 3 - Billings
Pick 18 - Hartung
Pick 19 - Garlett

[kimberly saint]

You've read the profiles. You've watched the highlight clips. You've studied the phantom drafts. Time to put your expertise to the test. Let's see who can get nearest the pin with their predictions. We oly have another 24 hours to wait for confirmation. I'll go first.
Pick 3 - Billings
Pick 18 - Hartung
Pick 19 - Garlett

is garlett a guess or have you herd we are interested in him ??

[White Winmar]

I'm tipping him as a pelican special. A mixture of what I've heard and the Pelican's MO. Plus Bruce Eva reckons we've lost interest. A very unconvincing attempt at deflection.

[cwrcyn]

Billings
Crouch
Dumont

[HitTheBoundary]

3 - Jack Billings
18 - Luke Dunstan
19 - George Hewett
83 - Tom Curren

Guaranteed to get one right

[plugger66]

Billings will be 3 and Curren will be 83. No idea about the others.

[sasaint]

Billings
Dunstan
Dumont
Curren

But wouldn't mind seeing Taylor or Gardiner slide in for Dumont.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Billings
Hartung
Dunstan

Curren

Garlett will get to Hawthorn ... its almost a sure thing ...

[bobmurray]

Billings
Sheed
Cripps
Curren

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Billings
Sheed
Cripps
Curren

cannot see the WCE not picking Sheed ... so i highly doubt he will come our way ... as for Cripps i dunno if the club would have enough faith to pick another Cripps after the last one ran home as soon as he could ...

[St Ick]

Billings
Acres
Dunstan
TC

I really want to fit Dumont into there, I am so keen on two of Acres, Dunstan or Dumont, actually like Dumont the best but think Dunstan is more likely which is far from a bad outcome. I've also warmed to Billings from Aish, but Scharenberg could now be in the box seat. Not one of the names in my post would actually disappoint me.

Hopefully the initials of Billings, Acres and Dunstan isn't a sign of the quality of our drafting this year

[st_Trav_ofWA]

its funny how a kid like Barass has slipped out of talk ... at the start of the year he was in the top 15 or so now most phantoms dont have him in the top 30

[evo]

Pick 3 - Scharenberg
Pick 18 - Dunstan
Pick 19 - Garlett

[Verdun66]

3. Scharenberg
18. Dunstan
19. Hewett
Then Tommy C....

[MCG-Unit]

3 - Scharenberg
18 - Dunstan
19 - Hartung

[bobmurray]

Billings
Sheed
Cripps
Curren

cannot see the WCE not picking Sheed ... so i highly doubt he will come our way ... as for Cripps i dunno if the club would have enough faith to pick another Cripps after the last one ran home as soon as he could ...

2 out of 4 was about as many as i thought i would get right...

Trouble is, i'm only certain about Curren

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Pick 3 - Scharenberg
Pick 18 - Dunstan
Pick 19 - Garlett

Personally I would be pissed off if we blow 19 on Garlett ... The kid can play but we could of taken him with pick 99 last year .... He has improved this year no mistake but not enough to warrant pick 19 ... If we had a live pick in the 30's sure but we don't ...

[MC Gusto]

Boyd
Acres
Dumont

[Zed]

Billings
Crouch
Dunstan

So hard to know who will still be there by pick 18. I would love to get Dumont but I'm predicting he will be gone by the time we get to 18.

[Devilhead]

Billings
Dumont
Jones
Curren

[noob]

Billings
Crouch
Dunstan

So hard to know who will still be there by pick 18. I would love to get Dumont but I'm predicting he will be gone by the time we get to 18.

Ditto. 100%
Billings at pick 3 and either Crouch/Dunstan/Dumount

Billings
Crouch
Dunston

[Heidelberg_Saint]

Billings
Dumont
Merrett
Curren

[dragit]

Billings
Dunstan
Acres

[MCG-Unit]

Edit

3 - Scharenberg
18 - Crouch
19 - Hartung

[vacuous space]

3. Marcus Bontempelli
18. Tom Cutler
19. Jonathon Marsh