Dermott loves our club now

[SteveStevens66]

Dermott also said that the three friends he has that are the smartest football minds he knows of are Rodney Eade, Terry Wallace and Scott Watters. I think he meant it as a compliment....

Apparently Alan Jeans doesn't rate. He thinks all three of those boof heads are superior football brains. So when Brereton was prattling on about the greatness of Jeansy at the time of his passing one can only assume that he was crying crocodile tears.

[joffaboy]

Dermott also said that the three friends he has that are the smartest football minds he knows of are Rodney Eade, Terry Wallace and Scott Watters. I think he meant it as a compliment....

lol even the STKFC has won more premierships than those three coaches

[sainterinsydney]

Terry Wallace, Rodney Eade, and Scott Watters are deemed the best football brains Brereton has ever met--that statment alone is evidence enough to disregard his opinion outright hahahaha.

[saintsrus]

Dermott also said that the three friends he has that are the smartest football minds he knows of are Rodney Eade, Terry Wallace and Scott Watters. I think he meant it as a compliment....

lol even the STKFC has won more premierships than those three coaches

Was thinking the same thing

[starsign]

i asked this in the Pelchin thread annyone know if he have a role in the appointment of
Scott, and will he have one this time?

[Fraser]

Dermott also said that the three friends he has that are the smartest football minds he knows of are Rodney Eade, Terry Wallace and Scott Watters. I think he meant it as a compliment....

Dermott... Opinions are like arseholes... Everyone has one. How many of these 3 are premiership coaches. I think guys like roos, Lyon, clarkson, would have pretty good footy smarts. If Wallace was as smart as dermie reckons, how did he go at footscray and Richmond? Dermie is a wanker.

[lefty]

You have to question... IF Pelchen is so good, why did Hawthorn get rid of him?

Question it.

I am suggesting that whatever problems Hawthorn had with him, are the same problems we are having with him.
I'm going to assume to Hawthorn board told him where to go, whereas our board followed what he wanted.

I am very suspicious about Pelchen.
I'm shocked and upset Watters is gone, I thought he was very good for us to be honest, always calm in the box, always spoke clearly and played the young kids.

Something is missing from this story, and it HAS to be told, otherwise there is no TRUST among this club. No trust, and nothing will move forward. If you were a coach, why would you want to come and be a coach here? Seriously.. you wouldn't know where you stand or support you have.

Over it...

[Eastern]

Worse than Melbourne according to Dermie

He also said that Scott Watters is a mate of his and he (Dermie) has a policy of "NO D!CKHEADS" in his circle of friends. Normally, one per group is enough !!

[BringBackMadDog]

You have to question... IF Pelchen is so good, why did Hawthorn get rid of him?

Question it.

I am suggesting that whatever problems Hawthorn had with him, are the same problems we are having with him.
I'm going to assume to Hawthorn board told him where to go, whereas our board followed what he wanted.

I am very suspicious about Pelchen.
I'm shocked and upset Watters is gone, I thought he was very good for us to be honest, always calm in the box, always spoke clearly and played the young kids.

Something is missing from this story, and it HAS to be told, otherwise there is no TRUST among this club. No trust, and nothing will move forward. If you were a coach, why would you want to come and be a coach here? Seriously.. you wouldn't know where you stand or support you have.

Over it...

Hawthorn didn't get rid of him, he chose to leave. He was asked by Alan Jeans to come to St Kilda.

[plugger66]

You have to question... IF Pelchen is so good, why did Hawthorn get rid of him?

Question it.

I am suggesting that whatever problems Hawthorn had with him, are the same problems we are having with him.
I'm going to assume to Hawthorn board told him where to go, whereas our board followed what he wanted.

I am very suspicious about Pelchen.
I'm shocked and upset Watters is gone, I thought he was very good for us to be honest, always calm in the box, always spoke clearly and played the young kids.

Something is missing from this story, and it HAS to be told, otherwise there is no TRUST among this club. No trust, and nothing will move forward. If you were a coach, why would you want to come and be a coach here? Seriously.. you wouldn't know where you stand or support you have.

Over it...

Hawthorn didn't get rid of him, he chose to leave. He was asked by Alan Jeans to come to St Kilda.

He was sacked. I dont care what the papers said but he was sacked. A mate who works at the Hawks told me that as soon as we picked him up and i said it on here at the time.

[stinger]

To me Dermie is the Doyen of everything football...........pffffft...bwaahahahahahahahahahahahaha

only my second smile for the afternoon...

[gringo]

You have to question... IF Pelchen is so good, why did Hawthorn get rid of him?

Question it.

I am suggesting that whatever problems Hawthorn had with him, are the same problems we are having with him.
I'm going to assume to Hawthorn board told him where to go, whereas our board followed what he wanted.

I am very suspicious about Pelchen.
I'm shocked and upset Watters is gone, I thought he was very good for us to be honest, always calm in the box, always spoke clearly and played the young kids.

Something is missing from this story, and it HAS to be told, otherwise there is no TRUST among this club. No trust, and nothing will move forward. If you were a coach, why would you want to come and be a coach here? Seriously.. you wouldn't know where you stand or support you have.

Over it...

Hawthorn didn't get rid of him, he chose to leave. He was asked by Alan Jeans to come to St Kilda.

I'm mates with members of Jeff Kennett's family and they said that Pelchen and Kennett never got along. He's a power broker and he doesn't f#@$ around when he does his work but he's uncompromising. You don't get sentimentality or nepotism just straight line advancement.

It was interesting on SEN that the word coming out was that Scott had made some very poor decisions on match selection and had control of that area. They said he had upset guys like Siposs who was told he needed to work on fitness but was dropped in consecutive weeks and didn't even play Sandy after being named.

[stinger]

Said that Pelchen looks you in the eye and says one thing, then does otherwise behind your back. Absolutely unloaded on Pelchen.

Pretty much correct. I've had previous dealings with Pelchen. (What they are is irrelevant before anyone asks.)

Dictator of the highest order. He's got his foot in the door now. You won't be able to get him out.

Should remove himself from the next coaching selection panel (if there is one).

Won't take too long for Pelchen to plot to get rid of the next coach if he has an issue with him.

Beware.

to be fair on Pelchen he was employed to reshape the club (something he sure is doing).. he had a plan on how to build the club up and to our knowllege that plan is still in full swing ,the board have bought into his plan (rightly or wrongly time will tell) and as part ofthat those who go against the plan are going to be under pressure , obviously at some level (discounting the rumours) Scott watters became a road block to the plan in the eyes of the board (rightfuly or wrongly) and in turn has been removed ..

the problem i see is if that is the case the next coach has to buy in 100% into the plan as well or else we are going to be seeing the same again ... talk of Harvey Choco whoever is really a guess the person who gets the job is the guy who is willing to embrace the plan ...

it might not ever work the plan could be a dud but i think we need to stay firm to that plan otherwise we really have nothing to fall back too ...

you are wise.....not sure if it's beyond your years though.....

[The Fireman]

lol...someone didn't get on with Jeff Kennett....that's funny

[BigMart]

Are we bagging Dermie now.... Like Car, Finey and anyone else who has RIGHTFULLY criticised management of StK FC

Get rid of Pelchin

His power is dangerous...

[plugger66]

Are we bagging Dermie now.... Like Car, Finey and anyone else who has RIGHTFULLY criticised management of StK FC

Get rid of Pelchin

His power is dangerous...

Then you will say the club is in further disarray just as you are saying now even though I thought you didnt rate SW at all.

[gringo]

Are we bagging Dermie now.... Like Car, Finey and anyone else who has RIGHTFULLY criticised management of StK FC

Get rid of Pelchin

His power is dangerous...

Then you will say the club is in further disarray just as you are saying now even though I thought you didnt rate SW at all.

That seems pretty easily swayed for someone who isn't a sheep.

If it was dermot saying how awesome we were you might not be so accommodating to Dermies opinions. I think you might suffer from a little bit of a contrary nature BM.

[stinger]

[

It was interesting on SEN that the word coming out was that Scott had made some very poor decisions on match selection and had control of that area. They said he had upset guys like Siposs who was told he needed to work on fitness but was dropped in consecutive weeks and didn't even play Sandy after being named.

yep that happened...he was one very unhappy boy at the time.........jackson ferguson was told to work his arse off and he would be retained......been living in the gym ever since and put on 5ks of muscle......roo and scott even remarked how impressed they were ...now you know what happened to him.....he also stuffed up young ledgers career...didn't play him even when we were getting flogged......in the last two games when we played all our top ballwinners, including curren, ross and ledger......we won easily.....yeah sure we were only playing freo reserves...but hey...they played in a grandfinal ...and we thrashed them....now ledger is gone and wet toast or the shockers are going to pick him up and reap the benifits.....

...there will be no crocodile tears from me....

[fugazi]

Got to hand it to us....we are spectacular when we implode!

Just glad it happened after the trade period....that's actually an improvement for us.

Sit back and watch the show!

[plugger66]

[

It was interesting on SEN that the word coming out was that Scott had made some very poor decisions on match selection and had control of that area. They said he had upset guys like Siposs who was told he needed to work on fitness but was dropped in consecutive weeks and didn't even play Sandy after being named.

yep that happened...he was one very unhappy boy at the time.........jackson ferguson was told to work his arse off and he would be retained......been living in the gym ever since and put on 5ks of muscle......roo and scott even remarked how impressed they were ...now you know what happened to him.....he also stuffed up young ledgers career...didn't play him even when we were getting flogged......in the last two games when we played all our top ballwinners, including curren, ross and ledger......we won easily.....yeah sure we were only playing freo reserves...but hey...they played in a grandfinal ...and we thrashed them....now ledger is gone and wet toast or the shockers are going to pick him up and reap the benifits.....

...there will be no crocodile tears from me....

How quickly you can change. Not true about Ferg either.

[satchmo]

Worse than Melbourne according to Dermie

He also said that Scott Watters is a mate of his and he (Dermie) has a policy of "NO D!CKHEADS" in his circle of friends. Normally, one per group is enough !!

So dermutt isn't even in his own circle of friends?

[Mr Magic]

Worse than Melbourne according to Dermie

He also said that Scott Watters is a mate of his and he (Dermie) has a policy of "NO D!CKHEADS" in his circle of friends. Normally, one per group is enough !!

So dermutt isn't even in his own circle of friends?

I wonder how he now describes his 2 long term business partners?
I'm sure I read in the news over the past week that he has taken them to court over millions.

[The Fireman]

why does this thread exist...someone actually takes on board what that knob jockey says?????

[TJMcCarthy]

I can dismiss Brereton's sensational comments for the most part but I'm not a happy Sainter.
Where is the truth in all this?
SW comes on SEN this morning proclaiming all is well.
Did he lie? Surely not. The rug was pulled out from under him i strongly suspect.
All should eyes should fall on the man holding the knife. Dermie was right about that.

[plugger66]

I can dismiss Brereton's sensational comments for the most part but I'm not a happy Sainter.
Where is the truth in all this?
SW comes on SEN this morning proclaiming all is well.
Did he lie? Surely not. The rug was pulled out from under him i strongly suspect.
All should eyes should fall on the man holding the knife. Dermie was right about that.

Im pretty sure SW lied.