GWS now have picks 1 and 2

[Grrrrr]

Welcome to Seaford Tom Boyd

How do you draw that conclusion?

Well why not? Send pick 3 and Fisher to GWS and receive pick 1 in return, win-win.

[Kernal75]

Throw in picks 19&20 as well and they end up with the first 2 selections of Round 1 &2. We're screwed in 5 years time

[plugger66]

Welcome to Seaford Tom Boyd

How do you draw that conclusion?

Well why not? Send pick 3 and Fisher to GWS and receive pick 1 in return, win-win.

How is that a win for GWS? They could get Fisher for basically nothing if they wanted him.

[Grrrrr]

How is that a win for GWS? They could get Fisher for basically nothing if they wanted him.

Fisher still has currency...Anyway, who knows what GWS is thinking? For all we know they may pass Tom Boyd altogether and we pick him up at 3 anyway...With Patton and Cameron as tall forwards could be every chance Boyd will pass to pick 3.

[plugger66]

How is that a win for GWS? They could get Fisher for basically nothing if they wanted him.

Fisher still has currency...Anyway, who knows what GWS is thinking? For all we know they may pass Tom Boyd altogether and we pick him up at 3 anyway...With Patton and Cameron as tall forwards could be every chance Boyd will pass to pick 3.

No there is not.

[stinger]

Melbourne gets Dom Tyson from GWS plus picks 9 and 53 in exchange for picks 2, 20 and 72.

i think melbourne got done over.

they certainly did.....

[chook23]

Melbourne gets Dom Tyson from GWS plus picks 9 and 53 in exchange for picks 2, 20 and 72.

i think melbourne got done over.

they certainly did.....

think they have done quite well

Tyson............2.....about even

20 upgraded to 9...big win for Melb

73....upgraded to .....53....win for Melbourne

[Grrrrr]

How is that a win for GWS? They could get Fisher for basically nothing if they wanted him.

Fisher still has currency...Anyway, who knows what GWS is thinking? For all we know they may pass Tom Boyd altogether and we pick him up at 3 anyway...With Patton and Cameron as tall forwards could be every chance Boyd will pass to pick 3.

No there is not.

we must be talking about a different Sam Fisher then!

[Foz]

GWS....not bad for a club that tried to claim the number 1 pick was on the table and now won't trade 1 & 2.

So if we have a go at 1&2 and get no where, do they return the favour and come for pick 3?

Interesting if they have a go at our pick 3 now as I'm sure they'd love a clean sweep with a gun forward and 2 mids.

[cannavaro17]

Should we have done this deal but for pick 3? Assuming gws accept it..obviously not that it matters now...

[Fidelis]

Anyway, who knows what GWS is thinking? For all we know they may pass Tom Boyd altogether and we pick him up at 3 ...

What a shame Buddy didn't go to GWS. There would have been every chance they might have passed over Boyd then.

[chook23]

Rekon they will go bots and kelly

Do you think they will really consider overlooking BOYD

[chook23]

Rekon they will go bots and kelly

Do you think they will really consider overlooking BOYD

[St DAC]

Unlikely. He'll most likely go 1 or 2 ... either way it's GWS for him now.

[Wayne42]

Melbourne gets Dom Tyson from GWS plus picks 9 and 53 in exchange for picks 2, 20 and 72.

i think melbourne got done over.

Melbourne always get done over , even if it's their own doing.
They had a No.1 pick a few years ago and wasted it on Scully who bailed as soon as he could and he now plays like a 2nd or 3rd rounder.
They probably traded for Tyson because they have NO confidence in their drafting skills.

[plugger66]

Melbourne gets Dom Tyson from GWS plus picks 9 and 53 in exchange for picks 2, 20 and 72.

i think melbourne got done over.

Melbourne always get done over , even if it's their own doing.
They had a No.1 pick a few years ago and wasted it on Scully who bailed as soon as he could and he now plays like a 2nd or 3rd rounder.
They probably traded for Tyson because they have NO confidence in their drafting skills.

How is that trade for Scully looking. To me it looks like they won eventually and GWS lost.

[stinger]

think they have done quite well

Tyson............2.....about even

20 upgraded to 9...big win for Melb

73....upgraded to .....53....win for Melbourne

given way the chance to draft a superstar for a gop.....don;t think so....

[stinger]

GWS....not bad for a club that tried to claim the number 1 pick was on the table and now won't trade 1 & 2.

So if we have a go at 1&2 and get no where, do they return the favour and come for pick 3?

Interesting if they have a go at our pick 3 now as I'm sure they'd love a clean sweep with a gun forward and 2 mids.

they were never going to give up the no 1 ...boyd...sheedy was just stirring the sh1t buckett...worked too.....we of all clubs fell in hook line and sinker...no wonder certain players got upset....

[chook23]

think they have done quite well

Tyson............2.....about even

20 upgraded to 9...big win for Melb

73....upgraded to .....53....win for Melbourne

given way the chance to draft a superstar for a gop.....don;t think so....

Tyson is no GOP