Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
SainterK wrote:Ben was one, I want dal to stay but he'd need to fire up a bit, Armo still nowhere near consistent enough, new captain that pushes new direction and embraces kids.
I can go on....
So you don't want Riewoldt captain?
Been on this for a while...
No.
I don't get why everyone says we have no natural leaders, so the best course of action is to wait until Nick is gone?
That makes no sense.
Sydney's model much better even, we should also throw someone in while Roo is there to mentor.
Nick grew into the role.
Someone else's turn.
Give me a reason why we shouldn't throw someone in while Len and Nick are around to catch them if they fall?
He doesn't crack the sad's in the coaches box ever unlike most of them (esp the Scott cry baby brothers).
Everything he says is controlled, realistic.
He's playing the kids which is what we want.
He's playing a better brand of football rather than the boring flood of RL.
If we loose Scott, I will spit it.
Keep Dal, grab Bruce, get Delaney through the PSD.
Moorabbin Man wrote: There is nothing better than a Premiership Coach in his second stint.
Jezza and Tony Jewell living proof, eh?
Let's just repeat the mistakes of 3 decades ago to regain our title of laughing stock of the competition!
Alan Joyce, Denis Pagan!
BLOODY JEZZA, BLOODY JEWELL! The first was the reigning premiership coach, replaced by one who had just got the sack a year after winning his flag.
Both are proof that anybody (nearly) can coach of you have the cattle. Players have always made coaches, it is rarely the other way around.
Ask any player of the era to compare the coaching of Jezza to that of the man he replaced, the luckless Mike Patterson. Responses would be interesting.
I think Choco in a support/over seeing role to help a new coach in Watters would be ideal and what he's do e at Richmond. It's what Pies did with Eade and Cats some time ago via Balme
IMHO Choco has tasted success he is the ideal replacement and I would have NO hesitation moving Laidley on (everything he's touched has turned to shyte).
Teflon wrote:I think Choco in a support/over seeing role to help a new coach in Watters would be ideal and what he's do e at Richmond. It's what Pies did with Eade and Cats some time ago via Balme
IMHO Choco has tasted success he is the ideal replacement and I would have NO hesitation moving Laidley on (everything he's touched has turned to shyte).
Apparently that is the trouble Teflon! The club after the review want to move on Laidley, when Watters in an act of blind loyalty has indicated if Laidley goes then he will walk also... hence where Choco Williams comes into the equation.
SAINTS another day older another day closer to the Holy Grail!
SW must be crazy if he has really said that.
Assistants come and go all the time. Always churn.
Surely he didn't expect they were joined at the hip forever.
I think turnover of assistants can be a good thing.
Its good hes loyal to his mate but its not realistic.
Teflon wrote:I think Choco in a support/over seeing role to help a new coach in Watters would be ideal and what he's do e at Richmond. It's what Pies did with Eade and Cats some time ago via Balme
IMHO Choco has tasted success he is the ideal replacement and I would have NO hesitation moving Laidley on (everything he's touched has turned to shyte).
Apparently that is the trouble Teflon! The club after the review want to move on Laidley, when Watters in an act of blind loyalty has indicated if Laidley goes then he will walk also... hence where Choco Williams comes into the equation.
Don't get me wrong I prefer we keep Scott but I am a little disturbed about his mates rates appointments
I understand he wants security - I'd go as far as offering an extension to the end of 2015 right now on1 proviso - Laidley goes and Choco in.....
I also think the club ought to have gone hard for Tudor...
Last edited by Teflon on Thu 10 Oct 2013 11:19pm, edited 1 time in total.
starsign wrote:Who are the other rucks possibly being tested?
I think it's Jonathan Giles
being reported in H-S
Lance or James??
There comes a point in every man's life when he has to say, "Enough is enough." For me, that time is now. I have been dealing with claims that I cheated and had an unfair advantage in <redacted>. Over the past three years, I have been subjected to a <redacted>investigation followed by <redacted> witch hunt. The toll this has taken on my family, and my work for <redacted>and on me leads me to where I am today – finished with this nonsense. (Oops just got a spontaneous errection <unredacted>)
Teflon wrote:I think Choco in a support/over seeing role to help a new coach in Watters would be ideal and what he's do e at Richmond. It's what Pies did with Eade and Cats some time ago via Balme
IMHO Choco has tasted success he is the ideal replacement and I would have NO hesitation moving Laidley on (everything he's touched has turned to shyte).
