Official Trade Rumours thread (all in here please)

[maverick]

Reckon it could be something like -

Dal and a swap of 3rd round picks for Delaney and Norths 2nd round pick and then we will on trade the 2nd round pick we get from North to GWS for Bruce

So we still get to keep our 1st and 2nd round picks - get Bruce and Delaney - downgrade our 3rd round pick and lose Dal

Just a random way off the mark guess

GWS can throw in their 3rd and 4th round picks as they won't use them...

[Devilhead]

Reckon it could be something like -

Dal and a swap of 3rd round picks for Delaney and Norths 2nd round pick and then we will on trade the 2nd round pick we get from North to GWS for Bruce

So we still get to keep our 1st and 2nd round picks - get Bruce and Delaney - downgrade our 3rd round pick and lose Dal

Just a random way off the mark guess

GWS can throw in their 3rd and 4th round picks as they won't use them...

3rd round pick would be good enough

[maverick]

Reckon it could be something like -

Dal and a swap of 3rd round picks for Delaney and Norths 2nd round pick and then we will on trade the 2nd round pick we get from North to GWS for Bruce

So we still get to keep our 1st and 2nd round picks - get Bruce and Delaney - downgrade our 3rd round pick and lose Dal

Just a random way off the mark guess

GWS can throw in their 3rd and 4th round picks as they won't use them...

3rd round pick would be good enough

Probably, but if we get their 4th round maybe we delist another, what number would it be 55 ish?

[dragit]

Reckon it could be something like -

Dal and a swap of 3rd round picks for Delaney and Norths 2nd round pick and then we will on trade the 2nd round pick we get from North to GWS for Bruce

So we still get to keep our 1st and 2nd round picks - get Bruce and Delaney - downgrade our 3rd round pick and lose Dal

Just a random way off the mark guess

Hope you're wrong here...

I reckon Dal is worth around pick 20, Delaney about 50

North's 2nd round pick will be about 30 after compos....

30 & 50 for a 20 is bad enough without downgrading our 3rd round as well.

Delaney is perfect for the PSD as I doubt GWS or Melbourne will take him.

[kimberly saint]

Delaney, according to my three North Melbourne work colleagues, is not much chop, and they all had a giggle about us chasing him. That's three supporters who follow North with passion, and none of them think Delaney is any good. I choose to believe them.

And I spoke to another North supporter who coaches local footy that reckons he has had no chance to show anything at senior level and think he goes OK.
For what we will pay he is worth a go, we need a key back, putting all our eggs in Bruce could end up like the mess we went through last year...paying way overs of missing out

altogether....

no offence but i would not hold supporters opions to highly , we have sum that want trade roo sum that thought tommy walsh was the next lockett . When a player says he wants out most the time supporters turn on them, he's no good etc.
If watters and co see potential in them id back him in

[Richter]

Scuttle that--@LukeHolmesby 1m
"Nick Riewoldt will not be traded." - Chris Pelchen, St Kilda Head of Football.

Driving the price up.

[magnifisaint]

So has Riewoldt said he wants out?

[Richter]

Ox on SEN reckons Delaney is a 4th stringer and we would be mad to get him.

Oh well, let's change tack then, the great mind has spoken...
He may well be surplus at North, but to us he is not....

Correct. Dawson was less than that when he was delisted by Hawthorn. That was over 4 grand finals and 13 finals matches ago.

[Richter]

So has Riewoldt said he wants out?

'Rumours' only at present.

He himself said that anyone is tradeable. not sure I agree with that. I mean Lennt is the only one on the list I would say that about.

What if the Tigers were to offer their 1st rounder (#12) or Collingwood theirs (#10 or #11) surely we'd be mad to turn that down.

[sainter#4]

why are people talking about dal santo for a 2nd rounder or 3rd rounder plus delaney and that ilk type of player.
burgoyne cost hawthorn pick 9 and that was when his career was threatened by a knee injury. He also missed the majority of the following year with it.

Dal can play a minimum of 100 games for a club if he goes. i expect a very good first rounder. or 2nd with a good prospect ala dom tyson.

Id be disappointed if he went for less and would seriously lose faith in the pelican

[plugger66]

So has Riewoldt said he wants out?

'Rumours' only at present.

He himself said that anyone is tradeable. not sure I agree with that. I mean Lennt is the only one on the list I would say that about.

What if the Tigers were to offer their 1st rounder (#12) or Collingwood theirs (#10 or #11) surely we'd be mad to turn that down.

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

[Dis Believer]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

What are you doing trying to introduce logic into a frenzy ?? Do you know nothing of the interwebs ???

[plugger66]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

What are you doing trying to introduce logic into a frenzy ?? Do you know nothing of the interwebs ???

I was due to produce some logic after 6 years of no logic whatsoever.

[degruch]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

I don't see a lot reported on here that is the talk of a successful club. Desperate times.

[plugger66]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

I don't see a lot reported on here that is the talk of a successful club. Desperate times.

Maybe because we keep losing our stars. Dont get me wrong, I think BJ had to go because of our situation but I find it strange anyone would just burn our Captain of so many successful years, well for us, just because we might get a pick that could be a dud or obviously a good player. if Rooy wants out then its a different story as it for all our older stars but do they want out? I certainly dont know.

[dragit]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

What are you doing trying to introduce logic into a frenzy ?? Do you know nothing of the interwebs ???

I was due to produce some logic after 6 years of no logic whatsoever.

Are you done for another 6 years now too?

[plugger66]

What are you doing trying to introduce logic into a frenzy ?? Do you know nothing of the interwebs ???

I was due to produce some logic after 6 years of no logic whatsoever.

Are you done for another 6 years now too?

Yep dont read anything i post until 2019. About the year we will be hopefully in the top 2 as the finals start.

[maverick]

So would you trade all the older stars in the one year if we got picks under 20? Surely that doesnt create an environment for a successful club.

I don't see a lot reported on here that is the talk of a successful club. Desperate times.

Maybe because we keep losing our stars. Dont get me wrong, I think BJ had to go because of our situation but I find it strange anyone would just burn our Captain of so many successful years, well for us, just because we might get a pick that could be a dud or obviously a good player. if Rooy wants out then its a different story as it for all our older stars but do they want out? I certainly dont know.

Course he doesn't want out, we can't trade him for anything....

[PJ]

would hope we end up using nothing above pick 40 in the draft except for elevation to senior list.

[MCG-Unit]

Reckon they should go with Josh Bruce (more a Harry Taylor type than Mitch / Nathan Brown type) and forget about Delaney, for now - esp if it means losing Dal Santo. A North supporter on BF wanted to give up both Delaneys to anyone who wants them....
Who knows Delaney might come good, but I'm not keen and prefer Bruce.

If they're interested in Delaney - might as well look at Niall McKeever 24, 197 / 95 delisted by BL, prob be as good IMO

Really need to get more inside mids, in trades and the draft.

[falka]

Getting a goo player via pre season draft is a must. Put a price on, don't talk to gw or dees. Sadly though, I don't think there would be any a graders in that boat. A Delaney type might be our only hope. Gotta love being a saints supporter.

If rumours are true we will be an under 23 team with a multitude of 2nd rd picks. Maybe we can package em all up for a dud.

Whatever happens, it won't be dull

Go Saints. Love this club

[Devilhead]

why are people talking about dal santo for a 2nd rounder or 3rd rounder plus delaney and that ilk type of player.
burgoyne cost hawthorn pick 9 and that was when his career was threatened by a knee injury. He also missed the majority of the following year with it.

Dal can play a minimum of 100 games for a club if he goes. i expect a very good first rounder. or 2nd with a good prospect ala dom tyson.

Id be disappointed if he went for less and would seriously lose faith in the pelican

It is not what people want but what might happen

Think every poster here would want at least a 1st round draft pick if Dal was to go but the talk is that North will not be parting with their 1st rounder because they will need it for McDonald father and son.

Remembering also that Burgoyne had only just turned 27 when traded to the Hawks whereas Dal will be 30 at the start of next season - if Dal were to play another 100 games then that is at least another 5 seasons - his ouput in that time is likely to drop off from what it is now which is already questionable.

[kimberly saint]

trade talk of sydney being in race for buddy as well as gws , lets hope this is just trash talk. Tippet and franklin in two years

[SaintSimmo]

Dal to NM -> Delaney + Pick 25 to Saints

Pick 25 + Fisher to GWS -> Bruce + Pick 10 to Saints

Effectively Pick 10, Delaney and Bruce for Dal and Fisher

Hope Pelchen can get something like this done

[Teflon]

Very happy with Luke Delaney but not as happy as the Sandy coach. Get Bruce forget Delaney.

Agreed - list filler is all

But we'll probably offer pick 3 because someone saw him stop a 10 goal haul one day in the WAFL and he could be "anything"