Finey on SEN

[HitTheBoundary]

So once again Finey said that Watters has fractured relationships with both players and other members of admin/coaching staff that makes his position untenable, and unworkable.

He says it is fact, but also refuses to name any names or sources.......

[savatage]

Class act mark fine. Three days of saying nothing.

[Dr Spaceman]

These revelations are all getting very repetitive.



..........and boring.

[savatage]

.....and destructive.

He wouldn't say James hird should stand down but with no proof, no evidence just hearsay he wants Scott watters sacked

Laughable.

When the club is back winning games of football and sexy again, we will laugh when you claim you're a loyal saints man. f***wit.

[HitTheBoundary]

He did mention that his comments had been a very popular topic of discussion on fan forums....

[defacto]

So once again Finey said that Watters has fractured relationships with both players and other members of admin/coaching staff that makes his position untenable, and unworkable.

He says it is fact, but also refuses to name any names or sources.......

all thats missing is the standard "sources close to the club", that he constantly criticizes journos for

hypocrit

[plugger66]

.....and destructive.

He wouldn't say James hird should stand down but with no proof, no evidence just hearsay he wants Scott watters sacked

Laughable.

When the club is back winning games of football and sexy again, we will laugh when you claim you're a loyal saints man. f***wit.

He may not have proof but he also may have proof. Im not sure you can say hearsay for sure. Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

[savatage]

Well I have conflicting reports to many of the things he says and so do a few other more connected people.

He's getting his info from one particular person who is disgruntled and taking it for gospel.

Without stating any concrete facts you must admit that it's a bit rich and irresponsible of a broadcaster to rant and rave on the radio for three days in a row asking for a senior afl coach to get the sack.

[dragit]

He did mention that his comments had been a very popular topic of discussion on fan forums....

Did he mention that he is a complete knob coat?

[Devilhead]

Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

He sure has a funny way of showing it

[savatage]

Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

He sure has a funny way of showing it

I'm sure hitler liked Germany too.

[plugger66]

Well I have conflicting reports to many of the things he says and so do a few other more connected people.

He's getting his info from one particular person who is disgruntled and taking it for gospel.

Without stating any concrete facts you must admit that it's a bit rich and irresponsible of a broadcaster to rant and rave on the radio for three days in a row asking for a senior afl coach to get the sack.

I think its good. Creates discussion and in the end it means jack. I guessing this will have no impact on the club at all. Certainly less than burning the dwarfs clothes. matter of fact has it even got a run anywhere else but on his show and on fan forums?

Maybe he loves the club that much he is coming out with this stuff so the club dont sign SW for another 2 years at the end of this year. Im certainly on that bandwagon.

[plugger66]

Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

He sure has a funny way of showing it

Im sure perfectionist loves our club but he still says Steven is the worst player to pull on a saints jumper. I can only say what I hear and i have heard him say many great things about our club lately. SW coaching hasnt been one of them.

[savatage]

If it was such an issue and these problems did exist then the club wouldn't sign him up for more years anyway.
I don't think mark fines influence actually dictates what the guys internally do at the footy club.

[plugger66]

If it was such an issue and these problems did exist then the club wouldn't sign him up for more anyway.
I don't think mark fines influence actually dictates what the guys internally do at the footy club.

I would 100% agree with that but people in the media have huge opinions of themselves so he may not see it that way.

[gringo]

Well I have conflicting reports to many of the things he says and so do a few other more connected people.

He's getting his info from one particular person who is disgruntled and taking it for gospel.

Without stating any concrete facts you must admit that it's a bit rich and irresponsible of a broadcaster to rant and rave on the radio for three days in a row asking for a senior afl coach to get the sack.

I think its good. Creates discussion and in the end it means jack. I guessing this will have no impact on the club at all. Certainly less than burning the dwarfs clothes. matter of fact has it even got a run anywhere else but on his show and on fan forums?

Maybe he loves the club that much he is coming out with this stuff so the club dont sign SW for another 2 years at the end of this year. Im certainly on that bandwagon.

It creates a negative impression and will work against people who may have been recruited to the club. If for instance Adams wanted to return to Victoria right now a stable Melbourne would look a million times better than us and it's based on an opinionated tools gripes.

Wish he was a Richmond supporter and go and help fix them or Collingwood.

[gringo]

Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

He sure has a funny way of showing it

Im sure perfectionist loves our club but he still says Steven is the worst player to pull on a saints jumper. I can only say what I hear and i have heard him say many great things about our club lately. SW coaching hasnt been one of them.

He has always bagged us even when we were relatively successful. He has always got good rating when bagging us and just from this just about everyone will have tuned into his show in the last 3 days and his replays will have massive hits. He will be getting a great response from his superiors who will be wanting it to keep going.

[plugger66]

He sure has a funny way of showing it

Im sure perfectionist loves our club but he still says Steven is the worst player to pull on a saints jumper. I can only say what I hear and i have heard him say many great things about our club lately. SW coaching hasnt been one of them.

He has always bagged us even when we were relatively successful. He has always got good rating when bagging us and just from this just about everyone will have tuned into his show in the last 3 days and his replays will have massive hits. He will be getting a great response from his superiors who will be wanting it to keep going.

How would you know bagging us gets more rating and why would it get more rating? It makes no sense at all.

[gringo]

He has always bagged us even when we were relatively successful. He has always got good rating when bagging us and just from this just about everyone will have tuned into his show in the last 3 days and his replays will have massive hits. He will be getting a great response from his superiors who will be wanting it to keep going.

How would you know bagging us gets more rating and why would it get more rating? It makes no sense at all.

Because every one on here would have listened to the SEN link and I bet heaps had the radio on after 6 last night when Ox and co were promoting it. Negative footy stories attract heaps more hits. It's a fact. A negative big club story is even better.

[plugger66]

He has always bagged us even when we were relatively successful. He has always got good rating when bagging us and just from this just about everyone will have tuned into his show in the last 3 days and his replays will have massive hits. He will be getting a great response from his superiors who will be wanting it to keep going.

How would you know bagging us gets more rating and why would it get more rating? It makes no sense at all.

Because every one on here would have listened to the SEN link and I bet heaps had the radio on after 6 last night when Ox and co were promoting it. Negative footy stories attract heaps more hits. It's a fact. A negative big club story is even better.

Wow thats 40 people. Others may have turned off because of the crap he was talking about the saints. i certainly didnt listen for a second and im doubting many on here did as well. I do agree negative stories get more people watching or listening but being a saints story means jack.

Just a hint we are a small club by the way.

[Dr Spaceman]

1 night = Opinion

2 nights = Inflated opinion

3 nights = Massive ego




Of course that is just my uniflated, egoless opinion!

[maverick]

.....and destructive.

He wouldn't say James hird should stand down but with no proof, no evidence just hearsay he wants Scott watters sacked

Laughable.

When the club is back winning games of football and sexy again, we will laugh when you claim you're a loyal saints man. f***wit.

He may not have proof but he also may have proof. Im not sure you can say hearsay for sure. Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

Destructively none the less.

[whiskers3614]

But is this "finey" rated by footy people?

[maverick]

Can i say one thing though. Finey loves the saints.

He sure has a funny way of showing it

Im sure perfectionist loves our club but he still says Steven is the worst player to pull on a saints jumper. I can only say what I hear and i have heard him say many great things about our club lately. SW coaching hasnt been one of them.

Course the coach is to blame for Finey, he has to blame someone, he didn't like Lyon when he started either.
It can't be the players that are no good, it must be the coach, let's sack him.
Same old St Kilda way.
In a so called successful era we can't even have one coach for the decade, we had to have three.

[BackFromUSA]

word i hear on Ledger is he wont know until after trade week if he is being kept or not ... lots revolves around who we get ... same is said of Beau

Correct.

Ledger really wants to stay and prove his worth. What I wrote was HIS view on his season and time at the Saints.

Our conversation ended with me asking him if he had actually spoken to Scott or Chris directly about his desires.

I advised an urgent coffee meeting so he could express his desires.

No idea if he took my advice.