Round 20 Team v Hawthorn

[maverick]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

[saintspremiers]

Shenton is unlucky also

[lefty]

No Schneiderman, Seb Ross, Ledger or Shenton?

Shenton just needs to keep doing what he currently is and he'll get a crack. Keep applying pressure and he'll force his way in, spewing he's not in this week though.

[CURLY]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

Id play him from what I've seen but obviously Im not privy to what he's been asked to do from the club. Im hoping for his sake there building him up over a couple of seasons to a AFL mid fielder.

[plugger66]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

Id play him from what I've seen but obviously Im not privy to what he's been asked to do from the club. Im hoping for his sake there building him up over a couple of seasons to a AFL mid fielder.

Im hoping we are not keeping another guy who struggles to get games on top of Maister and Milera.

[skeptic]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

His performances have been consistently superior to the players picked ahead of him

[maverick]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

His performances have been consistently superior to the players picked ahead of him

Curren?
Hayes?
Armitage?
Montagna?
Dal?


Mid for a mid

[Newman]

Strange Schneider not in. Even if hammy a bit suss - what the heck. Nearly end of season anyway. And who rucks with Big Boy. Blake? Why isn't Tom Hickey in? And is Saad really injured? Saw game live in Brisbane and it was onvious Stanly was injured. Never any talk that Saad, Siposs and Simpkin were injured.

[ShanghaiSaint]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

His performances have been consistently superior to the players picked ahead of him

Didn't know he played that much senior footy

[bergholt]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

He played four AFL games last year and two the year before, I reckon I saw all of them live (though I may have missed one, can't remember exactly). At the time he looked like a small mid who was a bit panicky when he got the ball. Found a little bit of it though and could kick a goal.

I want him in the side because we have to make a decision on him this year. If the powers that be have already decided that he's gone then fair enough - but it seems a dangerous call to make given that he hasn't played an AFL game all year. If we give him four games and he does nothing then we're forgiven for dumping him, but if we don't play him, dump him and then someone else picks him up and becomes a reasonable player then that's just wasteful.

[skeptic]

How many calling for Ledge to come in have watched him play live?
I haven't.
From what I have seen on TV, it's a no from me.

Anyone watched him live want him in, and why?
Interested.

His performances have been consistently superior to the players picked ahead of him

Curren?
Hayes?
Armitage?
Montagna?
Dal?


Mid for a mid

Murdoch
Saunders
TDL
Minch

He could have usurped Jones or Ray for a game or 2 at various times

[WellardSaint]

Lots of comments from ppl who say they've seen the Ledge.
Gets a lot of the ball, but wasteful, misses targets, picks wrong option, kicks out of bounds, etc.
Apparently.
He's a Perth boy so SW should be lookin after him, therefore he must be below par.

[St. Luke]

If there's one team I really hate in the comp, it's bloody Hawthorn! Can't we just play dirty and send them limping off the field tonight? their smugness makes me ill! I hope we can give them a scare...but I'm expecting an absolute beating!

[saintspremiers]

If there's one team I really hate in the comp, it's bloody Hawthorn! Can't we just play dirty and send them limping off the field tonight? their smugness makes me ill! I hope we can give them a scare...but I'm expecting an absolute beating!

So you hate the Hawks more than the Swines who are gifted an extra mil in the cap and Freo with scumbag Lyon?

[maverick]

His performances have been consistently superior to the players picked ahead of him

Curren?
Hayes?
Armitage?
Montagna?
Dal?


Mid for a mid

Murdoch
Saunders
TDL
Minch

He could have usurped Jones or Ray for a game or 2 at various times

TDL and Minch are forwards.
Murdoch played as a half forward and even in defence when he came in.
Saunders hasn't had much time in the middle at all.
CJ is a tagger so definitely not
Maybe Ray.

But I do ask, which weeks when Ray or even Saunders played did Ledger play better to deserve this chance.

[spert]

I've seen Ledger play live and he should be in the seniors by now, probably in place of Saunders who is still developing- we're not talking about trying to break into a winning top four team. Also thought Dunnell should be playing the year out in the seniors- too good for VFL.

[St. Luke]

If there's one team I really hate in the comp, it's bloody Hawthorn! Can't we just play dirty and send them limping off the field tonight? their smugness makes me ill! I hope we can give them a scare...but I'm expecting an absolute beating!

So you hate the Hawks more than the Swines who are gifted an extra mil in the cap and Freo with scumbag Lyon?

Yep! I hate them so much I throw up a little every time they run out onto the field

[SainterK]

I actually like how we match up v the hawks.

With buddy out, can think of a suitable matchup for each of their forwards now.

[plugger66]

I actually like how we match up v the hawks.

With buddy out, can think of a suitable matchup for each of their forwards now.

If we get within 60 points it will be a good effort.

[SainterK]

I actually like how we match up v the hawks.

With buddy out, can think of a suitable matchup for each of their forwards now.

If we get within 60 points it will be a good effort.

Yes it will

[Kickit]

Who will Lake match up on?
We don't really have an obvious choice. Hickey?

[kosifantutti]

I actually like how we match up v the hawks.

With buddy out, can think of a suitable matchup for each of their forwards now.

If we get within 60 points it will be a good effort.

Centrebet paying 2.10 for Hawks by 60 or more. You should get on it.

[St. Luke]

i hope the pricks get hit by lightning

[Kickit]

I remember a game in 2009 when all the money went on Hawthorn. It was a good day.

[Middo]

Lots of comments from ppl who say they've seen the Ledge.
Gets a lot of the ball, but wasteful, misses targets, picks wrong option, kicks out of bounds, etc.
Apparently.
He's a Perth boy so SW should be lookin after him, therefore he must be below par.

Pffft sounds like Jones then ..?