Changes for nest week

[Con Gorozidis]

Out : TDL Murdoch Stanley
In: Simpkin Webster Ross

[SainterK]

Out Milera TDL
In Webster Wright

[Munga]

out:
milera
tdl
murdoch
saunders

IN:
dunell
simpkin
shenton
white

Structures might not be the best, but based on today's game I'd like to these guys come in next week. Although Watters mentioned Webster and Ross might come back in, they didn't light my fire today.

[howlinwolf]

Out Milera TDL
In Webster Wright

I'm with you here SainterK.
Looks pretty right to me. very low return from these two outs and some effort from the two ins.

[samuraisaint]

I think Jimmy Gwilt could do with a run at Sandy too, just quietly. I know he is doing a difficult role at the moment, but he was terrible tonight.
Curren got a bit of it from what I saw of Sandy on TV too. Could he get a go, do you think?

[saintbob]

OUT
Milera
TDL
Gwilt
NDS

IN
Webster
Dunnell
Simpkin
Ledger

[gringo]

I think Jimmy Gwilt could do with a run at Sandy too, just quietly. I know he is doing a difficult role at the moment, but he was terrible tonight.
Curren got a bit of it from what I saw of Sandy on TV too. Could he get a go, do you think?

i thought Gwilt was good despite struggling to contain a bigger opponent he did some great assertive rebounding. His only weapon is standing next to a taller opponent and using his hip to unbalance them. With out Fisher he has to do the undersized KP backman role. I'm not sure Simpkin would have been able to do more.

[Eastern]

I think Jimmy Gwilt could do with a run at Sandy too, just quietly. I know he is doing a difficult role at the moment, but he was terrible tonight.
Curren got a bit of it from what I saw of Sandy on TV too. Could he get a go, do you think?

Jimmy Gwilt hurt his foot pretty bad (rolled ankle?) very early in the Freo game and may have had a jab to get him through. I suspect it may have still been a bit tender yesterday !!

[Eastern]

We really need midfielders who can go forward and kick goals or small forwards who can take their turn in the midfield. That would suggest that Ledger & Curran should be considered to replace TDL & Milera !!

[lloyd21]

Gwilt been poor for 6 weeks would think Simpkin would get chance

Webster Dunnell in Milera TDL out

Stanley in ruck rest McEvoy play Hickey with him in ruck

[Eastern]

Gwilt been poor for 6 weeks would think Simpkin would get chance

Webster Dunnell in Milera TDL out

Stanley in ruck rest McEvoy play Hickey with him in ruck

I thought Jimmy was showing a bit for a couple of weeks before the Freo game, but then again the memory isn't as good as it used to be !!

[plugger66]

Gwilt been poor for 6 weeks would think Simpkin would get chance

Webster Dunnell in Milera TDL out

Stanley in ruck rest McEvoy play Hickey with him in ruck

So we are dropping ben because Stanley isnt playing well in other positions. I never get those thoughts.

[Eastern]

I'd suggest that Rhys Stanley's confidence is just about shot about now. Do we? 1. Persist with him. 2. Drop him to the VFL to find form & confidence. or 3. Rest him for a week !!

[gringo]

Gwilt been poor for 6 weeks would think Simpkin would get chance

Webster Dunnell in Milera TDL out

Stanley in ruck rest McEvoy play Hickey with him in ruck

So we are dropping ben because Stanley isnt playing well in other positions. I never get those thoughts.

I would think we are dropping Ben because he hasn't been very good lately and Hickey had the better game. Rhys is a better second ruck as he offers more options around the ground.

[plugger66]

Gwilt been poor for 6 weeks would think Simpkin would get chance

Webster Dunnell in Milera TDL out

Stanley in ruck rest McEvoy play Hickey with him in ruck

So we are dropping ben because Stanley isnt playing well in other positions. I never get those thoughts.

I would think we are dropping Ben because he hasn't been very good lately and Hickey had the better game. Rhys is a better second ruck as he offers more options around the ground.

Has Stanley been good lately and wasnt Ben in the best last week or the week before? You stick up for all thes average footballers but are quite keen to drop ben.

[lloyd21]

McEvoy is injured has been for 2 months (foot) only due to Hickey also being injured he has been playing with courage.

They need to rebuild Stanley's confidence in playing a role he knows at the minute.

Have to look after McEVOY

[plugger66]

McEvoy is injured has been for 2 months (foot) only due to Hickey also being injured he has been playing with courage.

They need to rebuild Stanley's confidence in playing a role he knows at the minute.

Have to look after McEVOY

I havent heard anyone say he is injured? Is it common knowledge?

[gringo]

Has Stanley been good lately and wasnt Ben in the best last week or the week before? You stick up for all thes average footballers but are quite keen to drop ben.

Ben is still a developing ruckman and I would simply reward the better of the two static rucks. Stanley can be thrown around the ground as he offers more dimensions to his game than ruck work. Stanley is incredibly mobile for his size and can play as in several positions.The others can't.

[plugger66]

Has Stanley been good lately and wasnt Ben in the best last week or the week before? You stick up for all thes average footballers but are quite keen to drop ben.

Ben is still a developing ruckman and I would simply reward the better of the two static rucks. Stanley can be thrown around the ground as he offers more dimensions to his game than ruck work. Stanley is incredibly mobile for his size and can play as in several positions.The others can't.

Well the better of the 2 is Ben or do we now make decision after only one game. Joey may be dropped this week if that is the case. And I know Stanley is mobile. he is also playing terribly at the moment.

[lloyd21]

It is to the club doctor

[gringo]

Has Stanley been good lately and wasnt Ben in the best last week or the week before? You stick up for all thes average footballers but are quite keen to drop ben.

Ben is still a developing ruckman and I would simply reward the better of the two static rucks. Stanley can be thrown around the ground as he offers more dimensions to his game than ruck work. Stanley is incredibly mobile for his size and can play as in several positions.The others can't.

Well the better of the 2 is Ben or do we now make decision after only one game. Joey may be dropped this week if that is the case. And I know Stanley is mobile. he is also playing terribly at the moment.

maybe we should send Big Mac down back and have him as a FB and see if he goes better than Stanley. I'm sure Rhys won't mind.

[plugger66]

Ben is still a developing ruckman and I would simply reward the better of the two static rucks. Stanley can be thrown around the ground as he offers more dimensions to his game than ruck work. Stanley is incredibly mobile for his size and can play as in several positions.The others can't.

Well the better of the 2 is Ben or do we now make decision after only one game. Joey may be dropped this week if that is the case. And I know Stanley is mobile. he is also playing terribly at the moment.

maybe we should send Big Mac down back and have him as a FB and see if he goes better than Stanley. I'm sure Rhys won't mind.

I reckon the sides we play wouldnt mind either. Stanley has been poor lately whether back or forward. We cant play all these talls. Anyone can see that. I think Stanley needs to go back to Sandy to get his confidence up. It looked shot last night.

[Con Gorozidis]

Has Stanley been good lately and wasnt Ben in the best last week or the week before? You stick up for all thes average footballers but are quite keen to drop ben.

Ben is still a developing ruckman and I would simply reward the better of the two static rucks. Stanley can be thrown around the ground as he offers more dimensions to his game than ruck work. Stanley is incredibly mobile for his size and can play as in several positions.The others can't.

Can Stanley really play in other positions or do we just like the idea that he can ?

[BringBackMadDog]

Out Milera, TDL, Stanley
In: Webster, Wright, Simpkin

Three outs were so weak last night it made me angry. I have never seen 2 guys drop their heads as much as Milera and TDL and Stanley has just got to work harder, his confidence is shot to pieces.
I would also like to see Curren get a run but not sure which midfielder would miss

[borderbarry]

TDL must go. He had two more handballs, one less kick, two less tackles, than Milera who only played one quarter.
Stanley I believe is our best tap ruckman. He is definitely not a defender, and still has a ,lot to learn as a forward.

My changes for next week,
OUT;- TDL, one of Saunders or Murdoch'
IN:- Dunell, Webster