Changes v Carlton

[SainterK]

Out saad Milera ray
In Milne Riewoldt Ross

Why was wright subbed?

Hopefully Armo just cramping

[plugger66]

Wright was good and also very bad as he was on the little fellow who won the game for them. Saad was never good and had to go so we at least had more midfield rotations.

[ShanghaiSaint]

SAAD out for me... TDL did i bit, a lot better then other games but still have doubts on him...

[noob]

Riewoldt for Stanley

[Sainter_Dad]

In: That interchange umpire that can't count.

[ShanghaiSaint]

Milne in!

[SainterK]

Riewoldt for Stanley

Have to persist with him...

Would rather Roo came in for Milera or Saad

[plugger66]

How bad was Stanley, Jimmy and Saad today. Everyone else did something good.

[Jacks Back]

Out: Stanley, Saad, Milera (and if possible Dal and Gwilt but no replacements)
In: Roo, Milne, Kosi (200th only reason)

[mad saint guy]

Roo in, Stanley back to defence on Kruezer/Casboult.

Milne in for Milera. Saad will get another chance, even though he probably shouldn't.

I'd love to see Simpkin in for Gwilt, but it won't happen.

Lee probably had too much impact for Kosi to replace him and Watters is in love with the wasteful McEvoy/Hickey combo so I think that will stay.

[savatage]

Leave Ross in the vfl. Having him out of the side actually helped us. He wouldn't have lasted a quarter at the intensity that game was played at.

He's had a taste. Let him build his tank and work on second and third efforts in the vfl.

[ShanghaiSaint]

Out: Stanley, Saad, Milera (and if possible Dal and Gwilt but no replacements)
In: Roo, Milne, Kosi (200th only reason)

Dal for what reason?

[plugger66]

Roo in, Stanley back to defence on Kruezer/Casboult.

Milne in for Milera. Saad will get another chance, even though he probably shouldn't.

I'd love to see Simpkin in for Gwilt, but it won't happen.

Lee probably had too much impact for Kosi to replace him and Watters is in love with the wasteful McEvoy/Hickey combo so I think that will stay.

The wasteful Hickey Ben combination was great today especially till half time. I suppose it depends if you watch the game without bias.

[CURLY]

Yep McEvoy and Hickey where fantastic.

[MCG-Unit]

Out: Stanley, Saad, Milera (and if possible Dal and Gwilt but no replacements)
In: Roo, Milne, Kosi (200th only reason)

Dal for what reason?

Give up, no real reason - every week no matter how well Dal Santo plays (with a heavy tag) the same folks want him tipped out. Unbelievable

21 disposals (12 cont, equal most for Saints) 2 marks, 6 clearances, 3 Inside 50's, 5 Rebound 50's 3 tackles 1 goal
Also one of their best last week

Same with Ray & Jones. Same names come up every week.

[desertsaint]

Good chance of a win so bring Kosi in for his two hundred. Milney and Roo no doubt champing at the bit to win for him.
Lee can have a rest backing up from Perth. TDL and Milera or Saad out.

[Cairnsman]

Out saad Milera ray
In Milne Riewoldt Ross

Why was wright subbed?

Hopefully Armo just cramping

Wright hurt himself while taking mark of the round. Back I reckon. Vertical leap on the kid is like a kangaroo.

[plugger66]

Good chance of a win so bring Kosi in for his two hundred. Milney and Roo no doubt champing at the bit to win for him.
Lee can have a rest backing up from Perth. TDL and Milera or Saad out.

You are joking dropping a young guy kicking 3 goals. Unless he is injured he will not be dropped and that is based on no fact but common knowledge.

[Griggsy]

Gwilt needs a rest. He is hard at the ball but his kicking has been bad for a while now.

[SainterK]

Gwilt needs a rest. He is hard at the ball but his kicking has been bad for a while now.

30% DE is incredibly un-jimmy like, needs a rest or carrying something.

[saintspremiers]

Good chance of a win so bring Kosi in for his two hundred. Milney and Roo no doubt champing at the bit to win for him.
Lee can have a rest backing up from Perth. TDL and Milera or Saad out.

You are joking dropping a young guy kicking 3 goals. Unless he is injured he will not be dropped and that is based on no fact but common knowledge.

Agree. Give Tommy Lee another crack, he was ok today.

Kosi should play his 200th in a home game in any case.

[dragit]

Kosi's 200th can bloody wait for an injury.

Out saad, ray, Milera, TDL

In Riewoldt, Schneider, Curren, ledger

[Stephen Theodore]

Good chance of a win so bring Kosi in for his two hundred. Milney and Roo no doubt champing at the bit to win for him.
Lee can have a rest backing up from Perth. TDL and Milera or Saad out.

I'd be pis**d off if Lee was dropped after his game today. Presented, can hold a mark, kicked well, why would you drop him. He should be rewarded by his game today.

[older saint]

In: Roo, Ross
Out: Saad, Milera

Kosi can wait as Lee, Hickey were good today and too big otherwise.

please send Stanley back he will make mistakes but needs to learn the backline gig. Use him forward as a pinch hitter or even a switch hitter but not a permanent forward . Plays footy better facing goals than turning

[borderbarry]

Saad has to go. I have never seen a St.Kilda player whose opponent had so many easy marks.