Guess this weeks ins and outs

[Munga]

Out: Saad (needs to get a touch), Wright (inj)
In: Lee, Murdoch

[Con Gorozidis]

In: Murdoch

[MCG-Unit]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

[Con Gorozidis]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Ledger isnt on the list so cant play - but agree id give him a go if he was.

So he cant kick but id rather a bloke who gets his hands on it in a clearance rather than watching the opposition win it unopposed time and time again.

and anyone but CJ!

[Bernard Shakey]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Care to narrow it down a bit further. You've named 8 ins and four outs.

[Eastern]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Ledger isnt on the list so cant play - but agree id give him a go if he was.

So he cant kick but id rather a bloke who gets his hands on it in a clearance rather than watching the opposition win it unopposed time and time again.

and anyone but CJ!

Ledger IS on the Primary List !!

[Bernard Shakey]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Ledger isnt on the list so cant play - but agree id give him a go if he was.

So he cant kick but id rather a bloke who gets his hands on it in a clearance rather than watching the opposition win it unopposed time and time again.

and anyone but CJ!

This is Ledgers third year on the list.

[Eastern]

Ledger isnt on the list so cant play - but agree id give him a go if he was.

Con, Have you been on the Essendon Juice? !!

[Con Gorozidis]

Oh yeah
He is too!
Give him a go!

[MCG-Unit]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Care to narrow it down a bit further. You've named 8 ins and four outs.

The 'Ins' is from those 8 players listed above - very hard to pick this week, they will name a squad of 25 - probably only be about 2-3 changes on Sunday

Narrowed down In: Simpkin, Jones or Ledger
Out: Saad, Siposs or Ferguson

[Saint wagga]

From what watters said through the media this week, it sounds as if he is keen to give his midfield a chance to learn from that early onslaught and bounce back. Does this mean many changes...to be honest I have absolutely no idea!! Selection has been all over the shop, I hope some of the players are getting feedback or at least some sort of clearer message than we are as to a lot of selections this year. Maister/jones/ray/TDL/milera coming in and out not always on vfl form baffles me. What I'd like to see this week...
B: wright Stanley simpkin (if deemed fit enough)
HB: dempster fergusen roberton
C: NDS Armitage montagna
HF : dunell rooey Siposs
F: Milne hickey Murdoch
Foll: mcevoy Steven Geary
Int: newnes, Ross, Webster
Sub: Sam fisher

All will be revealed shortly (well not really, is it just me or does watters flat out spin bull**** at team announcement? I'm pretty sure in every single game he has been coach, the named side has been changed! It's. real bug bear of mine, but it seems like pointless dishonesty. It's not like we're currently a gun team trying to eek out that winning edge with some edgy mind games on the opposition! As a supporter, I'd just love to knowing, barring obvious late injury who is the selected best 22 for the weekend! Too much to ask? Sorry everyone, rant over.

[MCG-Unit]

Guess Dal Santo and Ray get a break from folks wanting them tipped out this week

In: A clearance player like Ledger / Jones. Consider Maister, Simpkin, Lee, Saunders, Murdoch & TDL
Simpkin plays tall back -> Stanley forward

Out: Wright (if inj) Saad maybe Siposs / Ferguson

Webster full game

Ledger isnt on the list so cant play - but agree id give him a go if he was.

So he cant kick but id rather a bloke who gets his hands on it in a clearance rather than watching the opposition win it unopposed time and time again - and anyone but CJ!

Not sure what you're on, but Ledger is on the list, maybe you were thinking of rookie Curren?

So you don't mind Ledger, even if he has poor disposal sometimes, but not Jones who is almost the same, a good clearance player but a poor kick
One or both would be good, they need in and under types.

[spot on]

Ferg was well of the pace last week, but I Spose you have to persist. Simpkin should really be ahead of him. Hoping he will come in the second half of year. Lee seem like he had a good game in vfl, surely saad need to go back to vfl to kick a few goals. Milne should have a rest too
Soo
Ferg, saad , Milne , sippos - out
Simpkin , Tdl , lee , ledger - in

[st_Trav_ofWA]

for me i would have :

out:
Saad , Siposs , Fisher

in
TDL , Dunnell , Simpkin

[joffaboy]

Not many guessed the s.hit Watters has dished up this wekk.

F***!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Toy Saint]

Would have prefered to see Lee and anybody called "Bull" in the forward line, happy to drop a small forward, and dissapointed to lose Fisher.