Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
CURLY wrote:I did after it hit his shoulder it slid up and chinned him. Hardly intentional.
Just plain unlucky. It seems Bakes and Kosi are the unluckiest players to have played the game. And it looks like the MVP bent us over again. No wonder some reckon some peoples posts lack credibility. I take it Waite was let off as the MVP do when sides are playing us. Look at Ryder and Commer. They both got off as well. And Brogan only get 3 weeks. He should have got 8.
CURLY wrote:I did after it hit his shoulder it slid up and chinned him. Hardly intentional.
Just plain unlucky. It seems Bakes and Kosi are the unluckiest players to have played the game. And it looks like the MVP bent us over again. No wonder some reckon some peoples posts lack credibility. I take it Waite was let off as the MVP do when sides are playing us. Look at Ryder and Commer. They both got off as well. And Brogan only get 3 weeks. He should have got 8.
CURLY wrote:I did after it hit his shoulder it slid up and chinned him. Hardly intentional.
Just plain unlucky. It seems Bakes and Kosi are the unluckiest players to have played the game. And it looks like the MVP bent us over again. No wonder some reckon some peoples posts lack credibility. I take it Waite was let off as the MVP do when sides are playing us. Look at Ryder and Commer. They both got off as well. And Brogan only get 3 weeks. He should have got 8.
CURLY wrote:I did after it hit his shoulder it slid up and chinned him. Hardly intentional.
Just plain unlucky. It seems Bakes and Kosi are the unluckiest players to have played the game. And it looks like the MVP bent us over again. No wonder some reckon some peoples posts lack credibility. I take it Waite was let off as the MVP do when sides are playing us. Look at Ryder and Commer. They both got off as well. And Brogan only get 3 weeks. He should have got 8.
CURLY wrote:I did after it hit his shoulder it slid up and chinned him. Hardly intentional.
Just plain unlucky. It seems Bakes and Kosi are the unluckiest players to have played the game. And it looks like the MVP bent us over again. No wonder some reckon some peoples posts lack credibility. I take it Waite was let off as the MVP do when sides are playing us. Look at Ryder and Commer. They both got off as well. And Brogan only get 3 weeks. He should have got 8.
Sorry didnt realise. Dont they bend us over? Im sure I read that somewhere.
They do and I asked would they find a reason to. Anyway we where still recovering from being bent over by the umpires Friday night. The Geary decison I think they had the whole fist in.
Last edited by CURLY on Mon 06 May 2013 5:33pm, edited 1 time in total.
2 weeks is about right for what he did. Remember lenny getting the same for just about the same offence.
Anyway seems like the MRP getting a bit consistant, too bad the useless umpires cant.
Lance or James??
There comes a point in every man's life when he has to say, "Enough is enough." For me, that time is now. I have been dealing with claims that I cheated and had an unfair advantage in <redacted>. Over the past three years, I have been subjected to a <redacted>investigation followed by <redacted> witch hunt. The toll this has taken on my family, and my work for <redacted>and on me leads me to where I am today – finished with this nonsense. (Oops just got a spontaneous errection <unredacted>)
CURLY wrote:No his intention was to block him and his arm slipped up. If he intended to belt him I doubt the bloke would have returned to the field.
So Hall didnt intend to hit Goose. Looked like it to me and he played on. Just because you intend to hit someone doesnt mean they dont play again that game.
in my opinion Kosi went to bump legitimatly but once he realised he wasnt going to make contact he put the elbow out ... stupid act and deliberate act .. did he try to cause injury to the player ? i dont think so but the act was still stupid prob should have got 3 weeks min but very lucky to get 2 ......
as for plugger66 your reverse posting style to prove your point is just dumb ... seriously everyone knows the MRP is hit and miss and this case with kosi just proves that ... it doesnt prove the "they are against us" belief some people hold though but given the run we have had in the past its an understandable feeling some of our supporters have
"The team that wins in the most positions and makes the least amount of mistakes, usually wins the game." -- Allan Jeans
CURLY wrote:
They do and I asked would they find a reason to. Anyway we where still recovering from being bent over by the umpires Friday night. The Geary decison I think they had the whole fist in.
Seriously Curly you've got a massive chip. You must have 'em on both shoulders so you can walk without falling over. Or maybe you just go around in circles. Your posts about umpires and 'being bent over' certainly do. Must be tough too when you can only see out of one eye. Every week you trot out a few threads of your own and contribute to several others with the same victimised shyte about the umpires and AFL bending us over, deliberately cheating, being out to get us etc.......
CURLY wrote:No his intention was to block him and his arm slipped up. If he intended to belt him I doubt the bloke would have returned to the field.
So Hall didnt intend to hit Goose. Looked like it to me and he played on. Just because you intend to hit someone doesnt mean they dont play again that game.
