Would you want an All Saints commentary team?

[thefatdork]

Hi Sainters,

Saw in the Hun that Fat Eddie will have a bunch of goons with him to provide an "all Collingwood" commentary option on Fox Footy this weekend - "pres red for Ed" - here's the link: http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/teams/e ... 6622915089
I'd hate to be one of the cleaners who'd have to tidy up the studio after Eddie & co - the stench from all that colly crap would be awful

I wondered whether I would listen to an all-saints team but on balance, I don't think I would want to. I'd want to hear a balanced commentary which acknowledges the oppositions exploits as well as our own and provides a fair and frank assessment of the game being played. Must say however, at the moment a lot of the commentary is biased - especially Bogan Brian and Dwayne the Pain.
What do others think?
Go Saints!!
TFD

[saintspremiers]

They are milking it as its an exclusive fox footy game. Unbelieveable considering its Richmond Pies!

[paddy]

I wouldn't want a biased call (I do that myself)

but I would like to be able to watch saints highlights and discussion at quarter/half time

[Saints94]

Good on them for doing it, but seriously who really wants to hear Tony Shaw commentate, he really is one bloke who has NO idea about the modern game.

[plugger66]

They are milking it as its an exclusive fox footy game. Unbelieveable considering its Richmond Pies!

Well it is an exclusive fox game.

[Eastern]

So, our ALL SAINTS COMMENTARY TEAM WOULD BE?;

Bruce Eva & Darren Parkin

Danny Frawley (Special Comments)

Michael Roberts (Boundry Rider)

!!

[Saints94]

So, our ALL SAINTS COMMENTARY TEAM WOULD BE?;

Bruce Eva & Darren Parkin

Danny Frawley (Special Comments)

Michael Roberts (Boundry Rider)

!!

No room for Sandy Roberts?

[Eastern]

So, our ALL SAINTS COMMENTARY TEAM WOULD BE?;

Bruce Eva & Darren Parkin

Danny Frawley (Special Comments)

Michael Roberts (Boundry Rider)

!!

No room for Sandy Roberts?

Interchange Bench !!

[Saints94]

So, our ALL SAINTS COMMENTARY TEAM WOULD BE?;

Bruce Eva & Darren Parkin

Danny Frawley (Special Comments)

Michael Roberts (Boundry Rider)

!!

No room for Sandy Roberts?

Interchange Bench !!

Hahahaha.

[kosifantutti]

They used to do this on Channel Nine. Every time Collingwood played. No need for a red button.

[saintbrat]

oI actually like to hear what others are saying about the saints and game, not those obviously biased against us, but yhose who can look at the 'game' and not just the team/colours

[PaytonPlace]

What I'd really like is either a version of the Fanzone commentaries (one fan from each team commentates) or, best of all, the option to mute the commentary and listen to the crowd...

One sided commentaries are fantastic - the ones in New Orleans generally descended into unstable anarchy in the 80s

[satchmo]

Would you want an All Saints commentary team?

I am one.

[Richter]

If you want an all saints commentary team, just come and sit in front of me and my mates at the game.

It's the full on match day experience... you'll most likely get beer and pastry over you and your eardrums assaulted by a few verbal obscenities...

[dragit]

Tony Shaw, Nick Maxwell, Eddie...

Byo dr Nitchke.

[PaytonPlace]

Can we bring back the Animal enclosure and mic that up?

[ozrulestrace]

Le'ts not forget that other unbiased commentator on Fox, his program will be called
"Roos Views, the bias of the Swans"

I so gave it to Roos on a survey Foxtel sent out a few weeks ago, about his bias and when they sought my opinion on the ad he appears in said "Loathe Paul Roos, never watch that ad" I hope they considered my view.

[snowdelisaint]

Would you want an All Saints commentary team?

Not really, I'm not sure they know that much about footy



Hahaha

[Leo.J]

Dennis Cometti and Gerard Healey.

[saintspremiers]

Problem with the red button is that it reverts to a barely SD picture that is way worse than the HD vision on the main channel.

[Eastern]

Problem with the red button is that it reverts to a barely SD picture that is way worse than the HD vision on the main channel.

Yeah, but its got NOTHING to do with the footy. ITS ALL ABOUT EDDIE !!

[Bernard Shakey]

Can we bring back the Animal enclosure and mic that up?

Are you deaf? Can't you hear us every week?

[PaytonPlace]

Can we bring back the Animal enclosure and mic that up?

Are you deaf? Can't you hear us every week?

Well sometimes in Tasmania my TV gets poor reception and the sound is a bit muffled...

Or I might be getting old

[PaytonPlace]

Would you want an All Saints commentary team?

Not really, I'm not sure they know that much about footy



Hahaha

What's Georgie Parker doing these days, surely we could get her?

[Dr Spaceman]

C'mon people; Eric Bana has to be involved.

He's even auditioned for the role