Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

saintbrat · Post: # 1319601Post **saintbrat** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:29pm

AFL‏@AFL
Another charge has been laid after investigation by MRP. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
MRP, One further charge laid after investigation by panel. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.

kosifantutti · Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:36pm

Interesting.

Must have been well off the ball. Newnes just seemed disappear with about 3 minutes to go in the first quarter.

saintbrat · Post: # 1319608Post **saintbrat** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:39pm

I wonder if the Saints queried or whether an injury review of the round noted Jack's concussion.

saintbrat · Post: # 1319610Post **saintbrat** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:49pm

GREATER Western Sydney ruckman Dean Brogan has been referred directly to the Tribunal to face a rough conduct charge out of Saturday's clash with St Kilda at Manuka Oval.

Brogan has been charged with engaging in rough conduct against St Kilda's Jack Newnes in the first quarter of Saturday's clash.

Newnes was substituted out of the match with concussion.

The AFL completed an investigation into the matter on Monday evening, referring the matter directly to the Tribunal.

As a result, Brogan cannot accept an early plea.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-04-15/g ... t-tribunal

AFL.com.au understands the Giants are planning to fight the charge and have engaged high powered lawyer David Galbally QC to represent Brogan.

The incident is believed to have happened not far from the interchange gate, with Brogan leaving the field at the time.

On his way off the ground Brogan is alleged to have made contact with Newnes.

The Giants are expected to argue Newnes was attempting to block Brogan's departure from the arena.

Newnes suffered mild concussion and was subbed out of the game.

SainterK · Post: # 1319613Post **SainterK** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:51pm

That was foolish on his part.

Oh well, GWS will have another kid that will have to stand up to the plate now.

saintbrat · Post: # 1319616Post **saintbrat** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 8:54pm

SainterK wrote:That was foolish on his part.

Oh well, GWS will have another kid that will have to stand up to the plate now.

not that it affects us
but listening to the commentary yesterday and on replay they noted that Brogan was only playing due to limit in their ruck stocks- can't remember if it was form injury or whatever- he was only going to be a coach-and gave up his #10 hence he was wearing #50

sunsaint · Post: # 1319620Post **sunsaint** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:00pm

kosifantutti wrote:Interesting.

Must have been well off the ball. Newnes just seemed disappear with about 3 minutes to go in the first quarter.

speaking of off the ball
did anyone else notice half through the second 1/4 roo's opponent doubled over on the far flank?
is he turning feral in his old age?

sunsaint · Post: # 1319621Post **sunsaint** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:00pm

kosifantutti wrote:Interesting.

Must have been well off the ball. Newnes just seemed disappear with about 3 minutes to go in the first quarter.

speaking of off the ball
did anyone else notice half through the second 1/4 roo's opponent doubled over on the far flank?
is he turning feral in his old age?

plugger66 · Post: # 1319626Post **plugger66** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:07pm

sunsaint wrote:
kosifantutti wrote:Interesting.

Must have been well off the ball. Newnes just seemed disappear with about 3 minutes to go in the first quarter.
speaking of off the ball
did anyone else notice half through the second 1/4 roo's opponent doubled over on the far flank?
is he turning feral in his old age?

I think he was exhausted trying to run with him all day.

stevie · Post: # 1319627Post **stevie** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:09pm

SainterK wrote:That was foolish on his part.

Oh well, GWS will have another kid that will have to stand up to the plate now.

Or Shiels can run Melbourne off their feet himself

Eastern · Post: # 1319628Post **Eastern** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:13pm

saintbrat wrote:AFL‏@AFL
Another charge has been laid after investigation by MRP. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
MRP, One further charge laid after investigation by panel. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.

These are 5-6 week jobs in the modern era. Like others have said, its all a bit weird as there can't have been any footage and the Fox guys didn't even know why Jack had been sub'd off.

Rough Conduct into a concussion sounds a bit like a shoulder to the head. I wonder how far off the ball it was !!

saintbrat · Post: # 1319640Post **saintbrat** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:30pm

Gerard on 360 Said Jack has a Broken jaw.
Happened as they were running to the bench- Brogan is flying down to front the tribunal

saintspremiers · Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:38pm

GWS are a bunch of rotten dirty turds under Sheedy's watch.

Oh well, I guess it's the old farts last hurrah.

Cairnsman · Post: # 1319644Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:39pm

Gee I hope he hasn't got a broken jaw. If they were running to the bench then it doesn't sound good for Drago.

andrewg · Post: # 1319645Post **andrewg** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:41pm

Does he have a broken jaw??

noddy04 · Post: # 1319647Post **noddy04** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:45pm

Dirty scum Brogan should get done for the season. Old has been who only ever picks on young or guys smaller than himself

samuraisaint · Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:57pm

Eastern wrote:
saintbrat wrote:AFL‏@AFL
Another charge has been laid after investigation by MRP. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
MRP, One further charge laid after investigation by panel. Dean Brogan referred directly to Tribunal for rough conduct against Jack Newnes.
These are 5-6 week jobs in the modern era. Like others have said, its all a bit weird as there can't have been any footage and the Fox guys didn't even know why Jack had been sub'd off.

Rough Conduct into a concussion sounds a bit like a shoulder to the head. I wonder how far off the ball it was !!

yeah, but when one of those Fox guys is Bazza that's hardly surprising.

SainterK · Post: # 1319650Post **SainterK** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 9:58pm

More importantly, a broken jaw sits him out a couple of weeks?

That's annoying, I liked him in the side.

To miss footy for an off the ball play, frustrating.

Silly mega forehead man.

Verdun66 · Post: # 1319654Post **Verdun66** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 10:05pm

Wasn't Brogan the guy that whacked some opposition supporter at Adelaide Airport a few years ago? Anyone at the game see it? Forumites I mean. The media clearly didn't.

SainterK · Post: # 1319658Post **SainterK** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 10:11pm

Which is why I think Baz is a dud recruit by fox, just not up to it IMO

perfectionist · Mon 15 Apr 2013 10:18pm

If true - 10 weeks. Hard to imagine a more gutless effort than at the interchange, when a player is least expecting it, from a guy so much bigger. Perhaps some vision will emerge to ameliorate the charge. But if not - 10 weeks.

kosifantutti · Mon 15 Apr 2013 10:50pm

Verdun66 wrote:Wasn't Brogan the guy that whacked some opposition supporter at Adelaide Airport a few years ago? Anyone at the game see it? Forumites I mean. The media clearly didn't.

I remember the headline from that airport incident.

Brogan 1 - Bogan 0

Bernard Shakey · Mon 15 Apr 2013 10:59pm

SainterK wrote:
Silly mega forehead man.

"Silly mega forehead man"?

joffaboy · Post: # 1319686Post **joffaboy** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 11:25pm

Brogan has always been a violent neanderthal.

Attacked someone at an airport, attacked someone in a park.

If he has broken the kids jaw off the ball, the bogan bastard should be charged with assault.

Deserves to be in the big house, violent aggressive animal

SainterK · Post: # 1319691Post **SainterK** » Mon 15 Apr 2013 11:43pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:
SainterK wrote:
Silly mega forehead man.
"Silly mega forehead man"?

I stand by it

Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)

Re: Brogan to Tribunal for Newnes hit-(broken jaw?)