Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
MuzunguMitch35 wrote:Was looking at the list today, what will happen with CJ? Could we be offering him and Winmar (another WA boy) up to trade to Freo? What would we want from Freo though...
Surely your taking the pi55 Fyfe and Barlow are untouchable we would have to give dal and BJ for one of them .. Muzugu is also not going to be moved for less then a first round pick ... As for Zac Clarke I doubt Ross would trade hit to us why would he want to strengthen a team that was only two games behind his this year .. Why would he want to fix our obvious weakness if a trade were to happen he would only allow it if it was heavily in his teams favour ...Ralphy wrote:MuzunguMitch35 wrote:Was looking at the list today, what will happen with CJ? Could we be offering him and Winmar (another WA boy) up to trade to Freo? What would we want from Freo though...
Fyfe
Barlow
Maybe that ruckman they have thats failing to get games
you need to get over attachments to players especially ones that a good chance to leave...you will only get let down and hurt in the end..it's not worth it.SainterK wrote:Of all clubs, why would the Tiges want BJ?
the question was what would we want from freo im only helping outst_Trav_ofWA wrote:Surely your taking the pi55 Fyfe and Barlow are untouchable we would have to give dal and BJ for one of them .. Muzugu is also not going to be moved for less then a first round pick ... As for Zac Clarke I doubt Ross would trade hit to us why would he want to strengthen a team that was only two games behind his this year .. Why would he want to fix our obvious weakness if a trade were to happen he would only allow it if it was heavily in his teams favour ...Ralphy wrote:MuzunguMitch35 wrote:Was looking at the list today, what will happen with CJ? Could we be offering him and Winmar (another WA boy) up to trade to Freo? What would we want from Freo though...
Fyfe
Barlow
Maybe that ruckman they have thats failing to get games
Thought it was a genuine question, I don't see how they need him.SaintPav wrote:you need to get over attachments to players especially ones that a good chance to leave...you will only get let down and hurt in the end..it's not worth it.SainterK wrote:Of all clubs, why would the Tiges want BJ?
It's hard to know with CJ, we are either trying to fix his kicking (if that is possible), in hope he can become a more attacking midfielder rather than a tagger, or he will be traded/delisted.Mitch35 wrote:Was looking at the list today, what will happen with CJ? Could we be offering him and Winmar (another WA boy) up to trade to Freo? What would we want from Freo though...
Let Luke Ball go away to a team that was only a couple of games behind usst_Trav_ofWA wrote:Surely your taking the pi55 Fyfe and Barlow are untouchable we would have to give dal and BJ for one of them .. Muzugu is also not going to be moved for less then a first round pick ... As for Zac Clarke I doubt Ross would trade hit to us why would he want to strengthen a team that was only two games behind his this year .. Why would he want to fix our obvious weakness if a trade were to happen he would only allow it if it was heavily in his teams favour ...Ralphy wrote:MuzunguMitch35 wrote:Was looking at the list today, what will happen with CJ? Could we be offering him and Winmar (another WA boy) up to trade to Freo? What would we want from Freo though...
Fyfe
Barlow
Maybe that ruckman they have thats failing to get games
St Trav floated the rumour at the bottom of page one. I was just giving my two cents.SaintSimmo wrote:Did you just make this rumour up or is there something behind it?Bardon Saint wrote: Broughton rumour - there's a new one. A possession accumulating half back that gets killed under Rossy for playing a tight tag. Not his style - probably hating his footy? Relatively young and can play mid.
Because I can't see him wanting to move to Victoria as he is a local WA lad....his father is from NZ though
I did acknowledge that he's just starting his career (cutting slack). I've seen him play also, so what if my background checking doesn't include BigFooty. BigFooty is not gospel. He probably will finish in the top 5 B&F but look at the team he's in. He's ok but relative to many other first or second year players, I simply think he's a bit over-hyped.MCG-Unit wrote:Harsh on Caddy. I've only seen him play 3 or 4 times this year, and he's been outstanding. According to the BF G Coast board, he is predicted to be top 5 in their B & F.Bardon Saint wrote:
Am not sure sure about Caddy. He's promised a lot but delivered little. Granted he's only just starting his career but I feel that some think he's a lot better then his actually is. His potential, well that's speculative but he hasn't started his career like some of the gun midfielders in the competition.
His first season he only played one game I think, with groin surgery and a stress fracture in his foot.
Fine if you don't rate him, but at least check some background first, maybe cut him some slack...
Bardon Saint wrote:I did acknowledge that he's just starting his career (cutting slack). I've seen him play also, so what if my background checking doesn't include BigFooty. BigFooty is not gospel. He probably will finish in the top 5 B&F but look at the team he's in. He's ok but relative to many other first or second year players, I simply think he's a bit over-hyped.MCG-Unit wrote:Harsh on Caddy. I've only seen him play 3 or 4 times this year, and he's been outstanding. According to the BF G Coast board, he is predicted to be top 5 in their B & F.Bardon Saint wrote:
Am not sure sure about Caddy. He's promised a lot but delivered little. Granted he's only just starting his career but I feel that some think he's a lot better then his actually is. His potential, well that's speculative but he hasn't started his career like some of the gun midfielders in the competition.
His first season he only played one game I think, with groin surgery and a stress fracture in his foot.
Fine if you don't rate him, but at least check some background first, maybe cut him some slack...
He may well turn out to be a gun? Who's to know?
You obviously missed the part where I said that we can only trade BJ if we match a free agent offer that he receives.SaintWodonga wrote:I don't think we would get their pick. They give up nothing (except money) it's the AFL who gives us a pick.Animal Enclosure wrote:Personally I'd much rather see BJ in yellow & black than red & black... their pick 9 would do nicely!
Teflon wrote:Latest doing rounds on BF is saints sniffing around John Giles ruck from GWS - dont know much bout him but hes not happy with his offer apparently.
Maybe.....then again, maybe not....St Ick wrote:Agree it is very out there as far as rumours go. Probably just from a SEN listening Blues supporter who isn't a fan and knows we'd love a backup ruckman!dragit wrote:The idea of a guy who has a 3 year deal worth 400K PA at a club on the rise, agreeing to be traded to a rebuilding side for minimum wage is one of the most insane concepts I have heard, why would he agree to that?
Carlton would want at least a 3rd round pick for him too I'd imagine.
Whoever said it, Hickey is the one to watch, but would take a lot to get a promising Queensland young ruckman away from Gold Coast...
I've heard he has been enquired about from two Victorian teams one is rumoured to be St Kilda ...Bardon Saint wrote:St Trav floated the rumour at the bottom of page one. I was just giving my two cents.SaintSimmo wrote:Did you just make this rumour up or is there something behind it?Bardon Saint wrote: Broughton rumour - there's a new one. A possession accumulating half back that gets killed under Rossy for playing a tight tag. Not his style - probably hating his footy? Relatively young and can play mid.
Because I can't see him wanting to move to Victoria as he is a local WA lad....his father is from NZ though
The reason we got nothing for Ball was because Ross didn't want to strengthen collingwood .. Again I feel Ross was happy for Luke to go to Melbourne for nothing .. It blew up in our face because Luke declared he only wanted to be at Collingwood ... Unfortunatly I can't remember the last player to come out and say they wanted to come to St Kilda onlynoob wrote:st_Trav_ofWA wrote:Let Luke Ball go away to a team that was only a couple of games behind usRalphy wrote: Surely your taking the pi55 Fyfe and Barlow are untouchable we would have to give dal and BJ for one of them .. Muzugu is also not going to be moved for less then a first round pick ... As for Zac Clarke I doubt Ross would trade hit to us why would he want to strengthen a team that was only two games behind his this year .. Why would he want to fix our obvious weakness if a trade were to happen he would only allow it if it was heavily in his teams favour ...
Dave McNamara in 1913.st_Trav_ofWA wrote: ... Unfortunatly I can't remember the last player to come out and say they wanted to come to St Kilda only
If so, is that legal?plugger66 wrote:Rumour as fact. BJ signed with the dons today.
