Rumour Thread

[savatage]

Lenny Hayes is rumoured to be bionic.

[SaintSimmo]

Broughton rumour - there's a new one. A possession accumulating half back that gets killed under Rossy for playing a tight tag. Not his style - probably hating his footy? Relatively young and can play mid.

Did you just make this rumour up or is there something behind it?
Because I can't see him wanting to move to Victoria as he is a local WA lad....his father is from NZ though

[SainterK]

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/A2l92rnCMAAF847.jpg

[SaintPav]

I heard that we are talking to Jack Riewoldt and will be making a big play for him during trade week.

[Sobraz]

I heard that we are talking to Jack Riewoldt and will be making a big play for him during trade week.

Define rumour??

If this is on the money I'm all in..

[SaintPav]

I heard that we are talking to Jack Riewoldt and will be making a big play for him during trade week.

Define rumour??

If this is on the money I'm all in..

It's has about as much substance as all the other rumors I've read on this site..

[bigcarl]

Lenny Hayes is rumoured to be bionic.

That's not a rumour. It's true I tell you.

[MCG-Unit]

Am not sure sure about Caddy. He's promised a lot but delivered little. Granted he's only just starting his career but I feel that some think he's a lot better then his actually is. His potential, well that's speculative but he hasn't started his career like some of the gun midfielders in the competition.

Harsh on Caddy. I've only seen him play 3 or 4 times this year, and he's been outstanding. According to the BF G Coast board, he is predicted to be top 5 in their B & F.
His first season he only played one game I think, with groin surgery and a stress fracture in his foot.

Fine if you don't rate him, but at least check some background first, maybe cut him some slack...

[WinnersOnly]

With BJ looking gone lets hope we can pick up someone like Caddy... Plus a ruckman like Hickey and a full back like Cam Delaney... As Scotty Watters suggested our salary cap position has improved...

[dragit]

Am not sure sure about Caddy… He hasn't started his career like some of the gun midfielders in the competition

We seem to think that all the great players dominated the comp from game one…

Caddy is tracking pretty well for a 19 year old in an ordinary side.

15 disposals/ave
2.6 tackles
17 goals

Here are a couple of other players in their first 20-odd matches

C. Judd
15 disposals/ave
2.8 tackles
21 goals

G. Ablett Jnr
11 disposals/ave
2.8 tackles
20 goals

L. Hayes
16 disposals/ave
2 tackles
10 goals

[MC Gusto]

ok this has come from an elevator conversation and not by any means a reliable source but i have been told goddard has signed with the tigers

[tweedaletomanning]

ok this has come from an elevator conversation and not by any means a reliable source but i have been told goddard has signed with the tigers

And I have heard it directly from an elevator, that BJ has his ups and downs..

[Sobraz]

ok this has come from an elevator conversation and not by any means a reliable source but i have been told goddard has signed with the tigers

Hence the Jack Riewoldt connection earlier in this thread by SaintPav...

It's all making sense now... Straight swap..

[jimmy_slats]

id take Reiwoldt for Goddard any day as much as i love Goddard if he wants to go then Reiwoldt would ease the pain quite nicely!

[Dr Spaceman]

ok this has come from an elevator conversation and not by any means a reliable source but i have been told goddard has signed with the tigers

Hence the Jack Riewoldt connection earlier in this thread by SaintPav...

It's all making sense now... Straight swap..

Why would they have to give us anything? He's a Free Agent.

[Ralphy]

ok this has come from an elevator conversation and not by any means a reliable source but i have been told goddard has signed with the tigers

Hence the Jack Riewoldt connection earlier in this thread by SaintPav...

It's all making sense now... Straight swap..

Why would they have to give us anything? He's a Free Agent.

restricted free agent they still do dont they?

[mad saint guy]

If we don't match an offer from an opposition club he can walk. There's no way we'd get anything from a trade

[MC Gusto]

i havent heard anything about jack

[jimmy_slats]

could be they get goodard we get pick then in trade week (as its the only time we could approach jack as not a free agent) use or first pick for jack ?

[Ralphy]

could be they get goodard we get pick then in trade week (as its the only time we could approach jack as not a free agent) use or first pick for jack ?

i dont think its a real rumour

[Dave McNamara]

could be they get goodard we get pick then in trade week (as its the only time we could approach jack as not a free agent) use or first pick for jack ?

I know it's only an elevator rumour, but if true... in a heart beat... where do we sign?





I can't see why the paper tuggers would do that swap though to get BJ..., if he was to end up there it'd be more likely to happen under free agency... surely... their recruiters aren't still that dumb... surely???

[SaintWodonga]

"St Kilda are reportedly leading the race to lure homesick Gold Coast young gun Josh Caddy"

http://www.sen.com.au/display-afl/Suns- ... addy/49093

[jimmy_slats]

its was an obsivation as to the jack rumour and goddard going to richmond was alls

[class of 2010]

I heard a rumour saying that the heart surgery to Lenny Hayes wasn't to do with a leaky valve at all...its all part of a plan to take the stem cells from his heart (scientific reasoning may be dubious) and grow 37 exact replicas (38 players on the list?). Every player at St. Kilda will be undergoing corrective heart surgery sometime this pre-season and we will win the flag in 2013 and each of the 10 years following. Not confirmed but my sauce is better than ketchup!

[Animal Enclosure]

Just to clarify... the only way we can trade BJ is if we match the best offer he receives from another club as a restricted free agent & then decide that we'd rather trade him that keep him.

It then become a straight trade as per the past.

Personally I'd much rather see BJ in yellow & black than red & black... their pick 9 would do nicely!