Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
st_Trav_ofWA wrote:Plugger same could be said about Tarrant ... Was only ever going to be a forward ... Until suddenly he was a defender ... Not saying it will happen but it can happen
Yep the 2 mentioned went back. Much easier. Anyway I doubt Raph will be playing AFL footy next year but if he does i reckon it will be as HBF.
andrewg wrote:One big rumor is if BJ goes Salopek is def coming to the saints
oh god, please no. 27 year old who can't get a game at port.
I think he would be a good pick up he is a very good kick, strong body. Give us much more than Peak ever did. We all know Pelchiloves players that can kick
andrewg wrote:One big rumor is if BJ goes Salopek is def coming to the saints
oh god, please no. 27 year old who can't get a game at port.
I think he would be a good pick up he is a very good kick, strong body. Give us much more than Peak ever did. We all know Pelchiloves players that can kick
So?? P66 I always read your posts closely and I have deducted that you strike me as a reasoned person.......therefore, I am sure you would have grasped the essence of my post.........Clarke being successful in a forward position in another club, while we may say it is improbable we can never assert that it is impossible....
So?? P66 I always read your posts closely and I have deducted that you strike me as a reasoned person.......therefore, I am sure you would have grasped the essence of my post.........Clarke being successful in a forward position in another club, while we may say it is improbable we can never assert that it is impossible....[/quote]
Clarke has had 3 coaches who all have only played him back in the easiest position on the ground and he still cant make it. HFF is one of the hardest positions on the ground. Good luck to him. Seems like a really nice person and he is or was a sainter. I want him to make it at any club but I am pretty sure it will be as a HBF if he does.
So?? P66 I always read your posts closely and I have deducted that you strike me as a reasoned person.......therefore, I am sure you would have grasped the essence of my post.........Clarke being successful in a forward position in another club, while we may say it is improbable we can never assert that it is impossible....
Clarke has had 3 coaches who all have only played him back in the easiest position on the ground and he still cant make it. HFF is one of the hardest positions on the ground. Good luck to him. Seems like a really nice person and he is or was a sainter. I want him to make it at any club but I am pretty sure it will be as a HBF if he does.[/quote]
How many games did he play under GT and Watters exactly. 3 coaches is mischievous as he would have been lucky to play 22 games under GT and so infrequently that I can't remember him having a position. Watters gave him about 3 games.
So?? P66 I always read your posts closely and I have deducted that you strike me as a reasoned person.......therefore, I am sure you would have grasped the essence of my post.........Clarke being successful in a forward position in another club, while we may say it is improbable we can never assert that it is impossible....
Clarke has had 3 coaches who all have only played him back in the easiest position on the ground and he still cant make it. HFF is one of the hardest positions on the ground. Good luck to him. Seems like a really nice person and he is or was a sainter. I want him to make it at any club but I am pretty sure it will be as a HBF if he does.
How many games did he play under GT and Watters exactly. 3 coaches is mischievous as he would have been lucky to play 22 games under GT and so infrequently that I can't remember him having a position. Watters gave him about 3 games.[/quote]
We don't needs hacks we just need to develop our own properly. Good young talented kids will improve us not players that can't get games from other clubs.
I thought the news on Gumbleton is that he's been offered one year from Essendon but is not making any decisions until he returns from holiday.
Am not sure sure about Caddy. He's promised a lot but delivered little. Granted he's only just starting his career but I feel that some think he's a lot better then his actually is. His potential, well that's speculative but he hasn't started his career like some of the gun midfielders in the competition.
Cloke is simply offering too much for a good season and some glimpses of form here and there. A move to Carlton under Malthouse may see better form.
Salopek is linked with the Saints every year. Just because he followed the Saints as a youngster. The same way that BJ is linked to Carlscum.
Danyle Pearce - glimpses but appears a bit soft. Has talent but I think we have youngsters to replace him.
Rivers - talented but who would he replace on our list? Do we need another of his type?
Maloney: How old is this guy? Hard at it, i like him but with our current direction, probs a bit too old to consider
Broughton rumour - there's a new one. A possession accumulating half back that gets killed under Rossy for playing a tight tag. Not his style - probably hating his footy? Relatively young and can play mid.
