Patrick Smith's view on the umpiring

[chook23]

Umpires Dept. have reported that the free kick to O'Brien was INCORRECT. So up roars Fatprick Smith.
No mention on all the other mistakes in favour of the Filth is noted - might be embarrasing to the AFL and Dimwit.

Is there a link to comment by the umpire department?

[joffaboy]

Umpires Dept. have reported that the free kick to O'Brien was INCORRECT. So up roars Fatprick Smith.
No mention on all the other mistakes in favour of the Filth is noted - might be embarrasing to the AFL and Dimwit.

Goodness me, will wonders ever cease?

The incidental contact by Milne to the arm was a Bridge too Far to defend even for the KGB oops I mean the AFL.

[magnifisaint]

What does Fatprick Smith know about footy?

[Thinline]

What does Fatprick Smith know about footy?

Knows more about AFL than cricket. And that's saying something. He was pinged for chucking I believe.

[mr six o'clock]

We didn't lose the game because of the obrien free , we lost it cos as usual the same players made the same poor skill errors when under pressure !
however in regard to milne taking his eye off the ball . Any player who doesn't take their eye off the ball when running with the flight of it is reckless , jono brown does it and all the media carry on how courageous he is , but he's also almost killed himself countless times .
Milney being a little runt would surely kill himself if he copped any of the hits that brown has !

[chook23]

Apparently ump department have admitted error in milne/obrien decision late in game........

is there a link to audio/article anywhere??

[Thinline]

We didn't lose the game because of the obrien free , we lost it cos as usual the same players made the same poor skill errors when under pressure !
however in regard to milne taking his eye off the ball . Any player who doesn't take their eye off the ball when running with the flight of it is reckless , jono brown does it and all the media carry on how courageous he is , but he's also almost killed himself countless times .
Milney being a little runt would surely kill himself if he copped any of the hits that brown has !

Beg to differ.

All that was done before then had added up to that specific moment.

The decision was made at a time when a goal would have all but soaked up the rest of the time available for there to be any alternative result.

So the incorrect decision had a direct bearing on it being a Collingwood win rather than a draw.

[gringo]

Don't worry about P Smith he's a clown who says controversial stuff to elicit a response. Big dumb oaf.

[Fazer]

We didn't lose the game because of the obrien free , we lost it cos as usual the same players made the same poor skill errors when under pressure !
however in regard to milne taking his eye off the ball . Any player who doesn't take their eye off the ball when running with the flight of it is reckless , jono brown does it and all the media carry on how courageous he is , but he's also almost killed himself countless times .
Milney being a little runt would surely kill himself if he copped any of the hits that brown has !

Beg to differ.

All that was done before then had added up to that specific moment.

The decision was made at a time when a goal would have all but soaked up the rest of the time available for there to be any alternative result.

So the incorrect decision had a direct bearing on it being a Collingwood win rather than a draw.

Wrong. Armo kicks the goal, Yapper gets in O'Brine's face. Salty O'Brine slaps Yapper in the face. Incompetent umpire awards Milne a free kick. We win by a goal. Simple really.

[TJMcCarthy]

We didn't lose the game because of the obrien free , we lost it cos as usual the same players made the same poor skill errors when under pressure !
however in regard to milne taking his eye off the ball . Any player who doesn't take their eye off the ball when running with the flight of it is reckless , jono brown does it and all the media carry on how courageous he is , but he's also almost killed himself countless times .
Milney being a little runt would surely kill himself if he copped any of the hits that brown has !

Beg to differ.

All that was done before then had added up to that specific moment.

The decision was made at a time when a goal would have all but soaked up the rest of the time available for there to be any alternative result.

So the incorrect decision had a direct bearing on it being a Collingwood win rather than a draw.

Wrong. Armo kicks the goal, Yapper gets in O'Brine's face. Salty O'Brine slaps Yapper in the face. Incompetent umpire awards Milne a free kick. We win by a goal. Simple really.

I could not have scripted a better ending to a bitter bitter game. That is GOLD.

[maj]

Patrick Smith is an idiot.

[stinger]

As quoted on SEN with KB..
"The Harry O free late was a free kick every day of the week as he ran towards Harry with no eye on the ball, then made contact"

Also "the umpiring late in the game considering the helter skelter of the game was brilliant "

He's entitled to his opinion but it seems very left field to me.

the fatprick was wrong....par for the course....

why can't the afl suckholes on here just admit that they along with the maggots got it wrong......giesch has......

[plugger66]

Plus one.

[stinger]

i see i've still got my stalker....... such a pity he's too thick to realise that i can't read his posts..


....none too bright our afl apologist.....

[dragit]

i see i've still got my stalker....... such a pity he's too thick to realise that i can't read his posts..


....none too bright our afl apologist.....

How do you know he is posting about you, if you can't see his posts?

[plugger66]

Looks like Patrick was wrong.

[stinger]

i see i've still got my stalker....... such a pity he's too thick to realise that i can't read his posts..


....none too bright our afl apologist.....

How do you know he is posting about you, if you can't see his posts?

because he posts under everyone of my posts...has been doing it for years.....

[plugger66]

I still say Patrick was wrong.

[8856brother]

i see i've still got my stalker....... such a pity he's too thick to realise that i can't read his posts..


....none too bright our afl apologist.....

How do you know he is posting about you, if you can't see his posts?

because he posts under everyone of my posts...has been doing it for years.....

Not this time

[gringo]

Actually, agree with Smith on this one. Milney took his eyes of the ball a couple of times running back. Though it was fair enough. Other decisions not sure about but for me we lost the game by kicking poorly, and picking out Collingwood players such as Jolly too often.

I hope anyone who takes their eyes off the ball this week are penalised. Dangerous eye contact is ruining this sport. What if Milne's twitching eyebrows distracted Harry and he tripped an twisted his ankle? Kosi could have made Ban Reid have nightmares just by bulging his eyeballs at an in opportune moment. When will Anderson and co start looking at the real issues. While players only look at the ball there is little chance of infringements happening. We should make everyone just sit in a circle watching a firmly planted footy while holding hands.

[stinger]

Not this time

good....maybe he's learning....

[plugger66]

Will patrick say sorry on Monday?

[Dave McNamara]

How do you know he is posting about you, if you can't see his posts?

because he posts under everyone of my posts...has been doing it for years.....

Sting, on this occasion your mate is actually agreeing with you.

[stinger]

i'll take your word for it...

...he's usually wrong so that would make a nice change....

.but steve ain't my mate, mate....never was never will be....

[plugger66]

I think Patrick will say sorry on Monday.