As a minumum we should make the Geish apologise

[Enrico_Misso]

We should as a matter of URGENCY demand a session with the Geisha Girl and ask him to explain about 30 decisions or non-decision from that game.

Because cleary either

1) We severely misunderstand the rules and must immediately modify our play accordingly.
(Starting with chopping the arms of every opposition forward since that now appears to be legal)

OR

2) We copped a series of the worst and most incompetent and inconsistent decisions seen for many years.
In which case Geishan needs to take action against the offending umpires.
Most of all - he OWES US AN APOLOGY.

And I wan't to see him apologise.

[3rd generation saint]

I want to see him join the queue at Centrelink.

[SainterJ]

Couldn't agree more. I am so angry. Perhaps someone could go through the replay and highlight them all in an open forum.

[Teflon]

he should apologise and quit - the blokes a fwit who has destroyed umpiring imo.

[R. Harvey 3 votes!]

The umpiring this year has been so bad, it is making me seriously lose interest in going to the football anymore for the rest of the year.
I just don't see the point? How are we expected to beat 25 players on the opposition? I am really dis-infranchised now and I have been going
to almost every game for 30 years? It is hard enough to win games as it is, let alone putting up with this crap every other week!

[Verdun66]

I am as rope-able as anyone, but it won't happen. They will pick one incident out in their little showcases on the net 'Ask Geish' or whatever, and say , 'there you are, that wasn't a free' to justify all the wrong decisions.

Just wait.

[saintbrat]

they have on ocasion this year suggested that some decisions may be wrong when they have their review videio with Giesch- But doesn't matter if he does say it-- wont be changed.

[tweedaletomanning]

The umpires are doing exactly what they have been instructed to do!

It is a demetriou directive that the Filth MUST finish top 4 to ensure maximum profits for the AFL.

Once people realise the AFL is no longer a sporting competition and is purely in the entertainment business, the more
These outcomes will make sense.

This competition is now on par with wrestling.

[gringo]

Harry O'brien was chopped in the marking contest and all decisions were correct except a random one that they will show that they missed to the Pies. That's the formula to try to placate fans. The Pies probably complained about last weeks umpires so the won them a game to say sorry at least we will get a good run against the Dees -that's a real danger match.

[Furphy]

We should as a matter of URGENCY demand a session with the Geisha Girl and ask him to explain about 30 decisions or non-decision from that game.

Because cleary either

1) We severely misunderstand the rules and must immediately modify our play accordingly.
(Starting with chopping the arms of every opposition forward since that now appears to be legal)

OR

2) We copped a series of the worst and most incompetent and inconsistent decisions seen for many years.
In which case Geishan needs to take action against the offending umpires.
Most of all - he OWES US AN APOLOGY.

And I wan't to see him apologise.

And then set himself on fire & leap from the Westgate Bridge!

[gringo]

We should as a matter of URGENCY demand a session with the Geisha Girl and ask him to explain about 30 decisions or non-decision from that game.

Because cleary either

1) We severely misunderstand the rules and must immediately modify our play accordingly.
(Starting with chopping the arms of every opposition forward since that now appears to be legal)

OR

2) We copped a series of the worst and most incompetent and inconsistent decisions seen for many years.
In which case Geishan needs to take action against the offending umpires.
Most of all - he OWES US AN APOLOGY.

And I wan't to see him apologise.

And then set himself on fire & leap from the Westgate Bridge!

He can take the rest of that human caterpillar that is the AFL hierarchy with him.

[maverick]

Jeffg@afl.com.au
Go for it.
Ask for explanations as to how the ump made the decision at the last hurdle.
Ask the ump how he missed the hit to Milnes back before the retaliation
Ask how the ump missed the two clear holds on kosi's arms

Do it with respect and you might get a reply.

[Furphy]

Jeffg@afl.com.au
Go for it.
Ask for explanations as to how the ump made the decision at the last hurdle.
Ask the ump how he missed the hit to Milnes back before the retaliation
Ask how the ump missed the two clear holds on kosi's arms

Do it with respect and you might get a reply.

And ask how they missed BJ nearly getting his head torn off in front of goal (and the umpire) & no free kick!

[ozrulestrace]

If the AFL isn't careful, someone in a situation like Sean Dempster or Clint Jones will be making a workcover claim seeking damage with all of the pulling on their arms both within and outside the context of the play to the point serious damage will be done to the player's arm and shoulder.
Not providing a safe work environment etc

[The Redeemer]

We should as a matter of URGENCY demand a session with the Geisha Girl and ask him to explain about 30 decisions or non-decision from that game.

Because cleary either

1) We severely misunderstand the rules and must immediately modify our play accordingly.
(Starting with chopping the arms of every opposition forward since that now appears to be legal)

OR

2) We copped a series of the worst and most incompetent and inconsistent decisions seen for many years.
In which case Geishan needs to take action against the offending umpires.
Most of all - he OWES US AN APOLOGY.

And I wan't to see him apologise.

That fat f***wit will do nothing of the sort.

That fat f***wit is a fat f***wit

[magnifisaint]

Geishen is a stupid fat can't