Goddard???

[ROLS-LEE]

6 possessions after half time.

Elite?

Just does not look like he is working hard enough.

Just put him forward or do something different.

[Old Mate]

Needs to be played loose in defence. Can't win a contest to save his life. Not strong enough in the marking contest and too slow when the ball is loose.

[ShanghaiSaint]

he's missing today

[saintspremiers]

he's missing today

All year you mean?

[ROLS-LEE]

So far the worst game in his AFL career

[Cairnsman]

He shouldn't have been gifted a game this week. Just didn't deserved to be selected.

[saintsRrising]

Ray was dropped for BJ.


As it turns out I am confident Ray would have been much better value.

BJ needs to play a blinder in the last quarter, but looks unlikely too.

[Old Mate]

Not even worth letting go. His value has gone down, we'd be lucky to get a 2nd rounder as compo

[ShanghaiSaint]

he's missing today

All year you mean?

damn straight... i think he's going.

[spert]

He's in preservation mode for the highest bidder.

[Hurricane]

Personally id like to see him go down to Sandy for a week or 2 and get some form and confidence back.

Probably wont happen though

BANG BANG

[Cairnsman]

Personally id like to see him go down to Sandy for a week or 2 and get some form and confidence back.

Probably wont happen though

BANG BANG

Personally I'd like to see him applogise for ripping his team mates off today with his complete lack of effort for most of the game. We were essentially a man down today.

[Jacks Back]

Personally id like to see him go down to Sandy for a week or 2 and get some form and confidence back.

Probably wont happen though

BANG BANG

Personally I'd like to see him applogise for ripping his team mates off today with his complete lack of effort for most of the game. We were essentially a man down today.

Make that 2 with Saad only having 4 possessions

[dcstkfc]

Tellingly no one got around him after his head knock.

He's gone. Thanks for the memories

[Dave McNamara]

He's in preservation mode for the highest bidder.

This!!!

[Old Mate]

His form line demands no more than 250k per year. Maybe we keep him on a reduced contact?

[Cairnsman]

Personally id like to see him go down to Sandy for a week or 2 and get some form and confidence back.

Probably wont happen though

BANG BANG

Personally I'd like to see him applogise for ripping his team mates off today with his complete lack of effort for most of the game. We were essentially a man down today.

Make that 2 with Saad only having 4 possessions

Yeah to be fair to Goddard he certainly wasn't alone in the lack of effort department.

[bobmurray]

His form line demands no more than 250k per year. Maybe we keep him on a reduced contact?

he's playing as well as Cloke is...

[fingers]

On his output this year he can go.

[Old Mate]

His form line demands no more than 250k per year. Maybe we keep him on a reduced contact?

he's playing as well as Cloke is...

Straight swap?

[thejiggingsaint]

Yes, I'm afraid I have to agree with most posters on this thread. Certainly needs a game @ Sandy in my opinion after todays "effort". On the strength of his game today it's time to trade!

[saint1974]

Rumor file this week said his going to Carlton in return we get Hanson? Seems he has a touch of Cloke syndrome, absolutely have loved BJ but this year he has been so disappointing.

[battye]

It's time to play Goddard as a KPP.

CHF.

Riewoldt at FF. Kosi in the ruck, drifiting up forward.

[kalsaint]

6 possessions after half time.

Elite?

Just does not look like he is working hard enough.

Just put him forward or do something different.

My thought exactly. He didnt add too much value today. Needed to switch forward after Siposs went off as forwards were generally beaten.

[Dave McNamara]

Rumor file this week said his going to Carlton in return we get Hanson? Seems he has a touch of Cloke syndrome, absolutely have loved BJ but this year he has been so disappointing.

Should that happen, I'd take the extra salary cap space and a suitable draft pick/exchange of draft picks. Do NOT want Hansen or ANY of their rucks - yes that includes Kruiser and Warnock!

In fact, thinking about it, Murphy aside, I don't think I'd want anybody from Carlton's list. They are all either over paid +/- over hyped +/- mentally soft front runners, or merely GOPs. So definitely, salary cap space and draft pick/s from Carlscum, not players.