Judd - Am I missing something?

[Ice Wolf]

Do you enjoy having your own opinion or just agree with others who say the AFL, the commentators, the media and son on hate us. God I wish I agreed with those people. I am not arguing here. Having a sensible discussion. maybe you get your own way at home so much you cant discuss this without calling it disagreeing.

By the way have no idea what your first comment even means.

Just because we are paranoid doesn't mean we are wrong!

[Rosco]

5 weeks. Do it.

[matrix]

i have an opinions plugger
sometimes i agree with the afl its rules and the people that run it
sometimes i dont

try it, you know, not having an opinion that follows the exact thoughts of everything the afl do

grass
sand
green

[plugger66]

i have an opinions plugger
sometimes i agree with the afl its rules and the people that run it
sometimes i dont

try it, you know, not having an opinion that follows the exact thoughts of everything the afl do

grass
sand
green

Sorry but I do disagree with things the AFL do but people choose to ignore those opinions and focus on when I do agree with the AFL. Its like when people think I only agree with what our coaches do. Totally incorrect but they conveniently forget when I disagree with them.

[CURLY]

Hope Judd gets off to be honest. Probably ths biggest over reaction since Baker on Stevie J.

[plugger66]

Hope Judd gets off to be honest. Probably ths biggest over reaction since Baker on Stevie J.

Even if he dislocted the shoulder?

[SaintPav]

i have an opinions plugger
sometimes i agree with the afl its rules and the people that run it
sometimes i dont

try it, you know, not having an opinion that follows the exact thoughts of everything the afl do

grass
sand
green

Sorry but I do disagree with things the AFL do but people choose to ignore those opinions and focus on when I do agree with the AFL. Its like when people think I only agree with what our coaches do. Totally incorrect but they conveniently forget when I disagree with them.

I can't recall any posts where you have openly disagreed with the AFL or the coaches..Of course I'm not saying that you don't disagree with them, but you you don't post that way.

[CURLY]

Hope Judd gets off to be honest. Probably ths biggest over reaction since Baker on Stevie J.

Even if he dislocted the shoulder?

Yep, unfortunately that's what can happen in a game. No rule against grabbing a blokes arm in fact it makes sense to do so. Foolish to think Judd targeted Adams.

[plugger66]

i have an opinions plugger
sometimes i agree with the afl its rules and the people that run it
sometimes i dont

try it, you know, not having an opinion that follows the exact thoughts of everything the afl do

grass
sand
green

Sorry but I do disagree with things the AFL do but people choose to ignore those opinions and focus on when I do agree with the AFL. Its like when people think I only agree with what our coaches do. Totally incorrect but they conveniently forget when I disagree with them.

I can't recall any posts where you have openly disagreed with the AFL or the coaches..Of course I'm not saying that you don't disagree with them, but you you don't post that way.

I am not going to look but last week I said getting a discount for pleading guilty when it is obvious is totally stupid. As for the coaches i have said many times that the trading of some players was stupid. I dont knock selections because we dont have the information they do.

[SaintPav]

I am not going to look but last week I said getting a discount for pleading guilty when it is obvious is totally stupid. As for the coaches i have said many times that the trading of some players was stupid. I dont knock selections because we dont have the information they do.

ok. that is fair enough.

[BringBackMadDog]

Hope Judd gets off to be honest. Probably ths biggest over reaction since Baker on Stevie J.

Even if he dislocted the shoulder?

Yep, unfortunately that's what can happen in a game. No rule against grabbing a blokes arm in fact it makes sense to do so. Foolish to think Judd targeted Adams.

Surely this is a joke, he grabbed the blokes arm and wrenched and twisted it at unnatural angle when the bloke was pinned to the ground by another Carlton player. I was a cowardice, weak act. The NRL outlawed this years ago because it could seriously cause damage to someone

[stevie]

Just watched all the MRp incidents. The one by Wright of Roos on Robinson was laughable to be even brought up. He simply bumped him.
The Merret one on Roo is despicable and possibly worse than wellinghams gutless effort last week - merret is not even close to getting to the contest!!! And he should have been pinged for trying to smash MIlney just after it. f****** weak as piss thug

[CURLY]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

[Life Long Saint]

Just watched all the MRp incidents. The one by Wright of Roos on Robinson was laughable to be even brought up. He simply bumped him.
The Merret one on Roo is despicable and possibly worse than wellinghams gutless effort last week - merret is not even close to getting to the contest!!! And he should have been pinged for trying to smash MIlney just after it. f****** weak as piss thug

I can't believe the Merrett one wasn't classed as intentional...He is a very lucky boy and should take the week on offer PDQ.

[saintspremiers]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

Fair dinkum open your eyes.

If you can't realise intent to injure someone is a reportable offense you need to review the rule book.

And remember Curly - Judd has history. Not just once prior either.

He's a dog that needs serious retraining.

Maybe he's a wild dog. If so, if someone shot him they'd get $50!

[CURLY]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

Fair dinkum open your eyes.

If you can't realise intent to injure someone is a reportable offense you need to review the rule book.

And remember Curly - Judd has history. Not just once prior either.

He's a dog that needs serious retraining.

Maybe he's a wild dog. If so, if someone shot him they'd get $50!

I seriously doubt he did it to injure Adams. He grabbed an arm to stop him getting the ball out Adams went in with dodgy shoulders that's not Judds fault.

[Eastern]

This would be one of the most difficult cases EVER to predict an outcome. More because of the bizzare actions of Judd than anything else. I'll stick with 4 down to 3. Don't ask me why because I don't have a solid reason. It's pure guess-work !!

Does quoting ones self mean that ones sanity should be questioned?

I have since found that Judd cannot receive a discount for an early plea. My new guess is now 4 weeks !!

[Sobraz]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

So if you dont think he should be suspended, what should he be fined for?

[CURLY]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

So if you dont think he should be suspended, what should he be fined for?

To appease the mob. We see someone get hurt and people want punishment. I honestly think its a crock of s***. Accidents happen players get injured blokes it happens move on. Played to much footy to.let rubbish incidents like this worry me.

[St.Carl]

No joke at all. Media at its best they should fine Judd at worse.

Fair dinkum open your eyes.

If you can't realise intent to injure someone is a reportable offense you need to review the rule book.

And remember Curly - Judd has history. Not just once prior either.

He's a dog that needs serious retraining.

Maybe he's a wild dog. If so, if someone shot him they'd get $50!

I seriously doubt he did it to injure Adams. He grabbed an arm to stop him getting the ball out Adams went in with dodgy shoulders that's not Judds fault.

Sorry - I think that it is probably a lot worse than it appeared.

I was discussing the incident with my physio as he was working my shoulder following a recent shoulder reco. He said that it looked like Judd had training in martial arts and was working the arm around to find the resistance so that he could most effectively damage/dislocate the shoulder (I was getting worried as he was saying this as he was moving my arm around testing the resistance!). He also said that having the person lying face down with another person on his back made it even easier to work the shoulder and inflict damage. The pain inflicted is apparent in the way the foot comes up as an instinctive reaction to the trauma.

Put this together and you have a deliberate and calculated intention to cause injury.

Pure evil.

Sportsmanship? Zero

Dirty play 100%

[saintspremiers]

Great post St. Carl.

If Carlton has any balls (assuming Judd hasn't bitten them
Off yet), they must stand down Judd as captain and replace him with a sane person.

[CURLY]

StCarl that would have to be the biggest lot of overhyped bulls*** I've seen. If what you posted was true which it isn't Judd will be scissor kicking blokes heads off in his next game.

[prwilkinson]

6 reduced to 4.

[Ice Wolf]

StCarl that would have to be the biggest lot of overhyped bulls*** I've seen. If what you posted was true which it isn't Judd will be scissor kicking blokes heads off in his next game.

Because Judd only attacks those that cant defend themselves at the time.

[Ice Wolf]

6 reduced to 4.

Can't be reduced sent directly to the Tribunal