Clarke

[Hurricane]

Im just going to say it

They guy is simply not AFL standard.

After 8 FN years the guy isnt going to get it. A more ruthless team would have delisted a spud like him years ago.

Enough is enough

BANG BANG

[gringo]

He's done some good stuff too unlike some others.

[luc1966]

stupid thread grow some balls his played alright tonight i rekon
bang bang

[Sainternist]

We've had far worse players tonight.

[bergsone]

Had a dip,give him that much

[gringo]

been very good in the last

[Jimmy O'Dea]

Terrible call, he has showed great courage and his run is improving each week. Makes a few mistakes by foot but he's not on his own. Good performance tonight just poor conversion. Looking good for second half of the season given few injuries and better ball movement.

[joffaboy]

Have to agree.

has been very good tonight.

Really bad bad bad OP.

[gringo]

He was huge in the last quarter and with Fish our best defender in that time. makes mistakes but goes hard.

[maverick]

The worst in a long time for mine.
He gets votes from me, I thought he was our best defender.

[Hurricane]

Thats what happens when you post in anger halfway through a game.

I still think he is VFL standard at best but he showed me up to be a fool after this post

BANG BANG

[Spud02]

Thats what happens when you post in anger halfway through a game.

I still think he is VFL standard at best but he showed me up to be a fool after this post

BANG BANG

Nice try...you're still very wrong

[battye]

A few clangers (not alone there), but very courageous tonight.

[ausfatcat]

Clarke is at the point in his career, because of perceived past history, he could play a excellent game make one mistake and people will call for his head (note even the best players make 5+ mistakes a night). Solid without being great tonight very comfortable he did his fair share tonight.

Want to blame someone for the 4 point lose blame the forwards for woefull kicking, Clarke was a big part of the late saints revival something I doubt Newenes would have been able to acomplish at this stage of his career.

[BigMart]

Mixed bag of good and hopeless.... But overall OK

[Ross who?]

Very good IMO, except THAT kick out!

[The Fireman]

Im just going to say it

They guy is simply not AFL standard.

After 8 FN years the guy isnt going to get it. A more ruthless team would have delisted a spud like him years ago.

Enough is enough

BANG BANG

one of our best tonight, WTF .....I thought Collingwood had all the dumb supporters.

[Hurricane]

Thats what happens when you post in anger halfway through a game.

I still think he is VFL standard at best but he showed me up to be a fool after this post

BANG BANG

Nice try...you're still very wrong

Blow me.

I was wrong TONIGHT and admitted as such. No need for the smart ass remark.

The guy is not AFL standard and 1 half decent game wont change that

BANG BANG

[iwantmeseats]

Agree. 8 years EIGHT!! This is as good as it gets and it's sub par. Sorry

[iremember66]

will continue to improve and scare the opposition if can stay fit.

OP rubbish - Raph will prevail...

[Spud02]

The guy is not AFL standard and 1 half decent game wont change that

BANG BANG[/quote]

This is the bit you still won't admit to being wrong about

[dirtydog24]

He was good tonight. You blokes need to take the blinkers off and stop buying into the stereotype.

If we had a few more like him tonight, we win. Simple as that.

[savatage]

I've never rated him on past efforts but calling what you see, his good easily outweighed his bad tonight. At times you can question his decision making but never his courage. His drive was fantastic In the last quarter.

[Jimmy O'Dea]

Pretty easy Spud to work out those that have very little feel for the game. His courage has been highlighted by numerous media outlets tonight.

[saint75]

Im just going to say it

They guy is simply not AFL standard.

After 8 FN years the guy isnt going to get it. A more ruthless team would have delisted a spud like him years ago.

Enough is enough

BANG BANG

You are kidding aren't you? Seriously, did you watch the game? Couple of errors (one costing a goal) but apart from that was excellent. There were plenty of errors made by various players on the field today (for both teams) but the pressure on the field tonight was high.

Easy to find a scapegoat in your disappointment, but to make that scapegoat Raph is boring and predictable and shows your lack of knowledge.