Votes vs Adelaide

[battye]

5. Dal Santo
4. Steven
3. Siposs
2. Fisher
1. Milne

[whiskers3614]

Milne????

[BigMart]

Oh FFS

Serious

5-Dal
4-Joey
3-Gilbert
2-Amitage
1-Schnieder

[Old Mate]

5. Dal santo
4. Steven
3. Monty
2. Gilbert
1. Schneider

[Jimmy O'Dea]

Dont think the coach would agree with Steven in the votes. Plenty of the ball and usual great effort but decision making was ? at times tonight which hurt us.

[Toy Saint]

5. Nick Dal
4. Jack Steven
3. Sam Gilbert
2. Armitage
1. Schnieder

[noob]

5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Montagna
3. Steven
2. Schneider
1. Geary (couldn't fault him when he came on)

[dcstkfc]

5 Dal Santo
4 Montagna
3 Schneider
2 Dempster
1 Fisher

[bergsone]

5 NDS
4 Schneider
3 Armitage
2 Gilbert
1 Goddard

[BigMart]

I must have been watching a different game

[Dave McNamara]

5. NDS.
4. Dempster (I'm surprised he's not getting more love).
3. Steven (all the way from Lorne?).
2. Raph.
1. Schnieds'.

Apologies: Sam G, Monty, Armo', Sippa', Sam F (by the last quarter), Sainta K's boy when he was subbed on (loved that attack on Big Ben Rutton..., loved that Rutton didn't love that attack ).

[avid]

5 dal Santo
4 Steven
3 Schneider
2 Armitage
1 Gilbert

Apols to Montagna, Jones, Dempster (for a massive 1st quarter especially), Raph.

[Eastern]

5. N. DalSanto

4. L. Montagna

3. D. Armitage

2. S. Dempster

1. A. Schneider

!!

[Eastern]

I must have been watching a different game

Nah, same game, different opinion. NOTHING WRONG WITH THAT !!

[PJ]

5 Dal Santo
4 Montagna
3 Armitage
2 Gilbert
1 Schneider

Dempster again very good probably just pipped by a good return by Schneids

[borderbarry]

5. Dal

3. Monty

3. Dempster

2. Schneider

1. Steven

1. Clarke

[BigMart]

Not sure

1/ how Leigh montagna could not be in the votes
2/ how Sam Gilbert could not be in
3/ how Jack Steven could???

Opinion is cool, but seriously....

I think Jack just has to turn up to get a vote. I think you need to look at effectiveness of his disposals (one kick dribbled off his left foot which turned over for a goal) and his decisions with the footy...
But of late his defensive side has been wanting. 2 tackles in two games for a midfielder shows lack of defensive work rate.
He is certainly a ball winner, but not a quality ball winner... He runs hard fwd on the spread, but
No composure with the footy

[BigMart]

Sounds like I'm being harsh on him...

He has had a good year and would be a clear 2nd in the B&F.... And he can certainly play

But he has a massive flaw in his game, and like Gilbert and Clarke his changers are costly..... I believe last night he was costly and his mistakes easily outweighed his output, hence why he shouldn't be considered IMO

[SainterK]

Dal
Dempster
Joey
Gilbert
Schneider (loved his cool head)

[gringo]

Dal Santo
Dempster
joey
Raph
Gilbert

[desertsaint]

Dal
Dempster
Joey
Gilbert
Schneider

Thanks sainterk - always easier to find someone with the same votes and copy, paste!

[perfectionist]

...I think Jack just has to turn up to get a vote. I think you need to look at effectiveness of his disposals (one kick dribbled off his left foot which turned over for a goal) and his decisions with the footy...
But of late his defensive side has been wanting. 2 tackles in two games for a midfielder shows lack of defensive work rate.
He is certainly a ball winner, but not a quality ball winner... He runs hard fwd on the spread, but
No composure with the footy

Not being too harsh - it's obvious. The good news is that he is improving, and you can't say that for every player. When I give votes, I look at the effectiveness of a player. For instance, I gave Clint votes last week (about the only one who did) because he kept Gary Ablett to almost nothing. If a player gives up two or three goals through turnovers, then they have gone a long way to costing the team the win. They don't deserve any votes - unless they kick ten goals. Votes should not be given as an encouragement prize. I'm not giving votes in this game as only Sean Demspter was four quarter performer. Given the result, that, ironically, could be good news. Also, you miss so much watching on TV.

[Dave McNamara]

... I'm not giving votes in this game as only Sean Demspter was four quarter performer...

Hi Perfectionist, maybe you could just give Sean the 5 votes then, and not give out your other votes, if you don't feel that anyone else is deserving this week? I don't reckon Sean should be penalised by the form of his team mates... that'd be a bit harsh...

[Dr Spaceman]

5. Dal Santo

4. Montagna

3. Armitage

2. Dempster

1. Steven

[saintcrazy]

Gilbert- best game so far this year, and may it continue, Dal his classy self, Schneides great return, Hayes never lets you down...Steven good but unfortunate pyjamas... can't say any more. So many chances to bury them didn't come off.