Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

In
Wilkes for Fisher
Ledger for Saad

I suppose they are the outs then

[saintspremiers]

In
Wilkes for Fisher
Ledger for Saad

I suppose they are the outs then

Sounds on the money to me.

We need Ledger's hardness to stop a few of Carlton's goals, and stem the bleeding of goals.

IF Ledger isn't picked, he must be in the bad books big time.

We are rooted this week regardless

[Wrote for Luck]

out Milne
in Wilkes

reckon Milney could do with a rest, and Stanley to go into the ruck mostly changing with Kosi
don't think we will pull either Siposs or Saad as Watters has shown he will stick with a junior for a bit

[SaintPav]

I hate these stupid Monday night games and I really hope they don't continue.

[Eastern]

Farren Ray would have to go close this week...................unless

Otherwise, plugger's prediction could be pretty close !!

[Beno88]

In : Cripps, Ledger
Out : Fisher, Polo

[saintspremiers]

In : Cripps, Ledger
Out : Fisher, Polo

unless Polo is injured, he won't be dropped.

Perfect player against the Blues - hard and experienced......sure, he's not that flash and no champion, but he's hard at it.

[stkildathunda]

IN: Wilkes & Ray
OUT: Siposs & Saad

[Teflon]

In : Ledger/Wilkes
Out: Fisher/Polo

While Polo is tough he offers little run which you need to counter Blues running brigade - Ledger offers tough & run and carry
Wilkes gives us some flexibility - worst case he helps out down back while Blake rucks or we swing him fwd at some point to mix attack

Cripps sub?

[Teflon]

IN: Wilkes & Ray
OUT: Siposs & Saad

Not a fan of dropping kids after 1 game when we are supposed to be developing them.... can't see how that helps development.

[stkildathunda]

IN: Wilkes & Ray
OUT: Siposs & Saad

Not a fan of dropping kids after 1 game when we are supposed to be developing them.... can't see how that helps development.

I think we need to go back to 3 talls in forward line and with no McEvoy that means need to squeeze Wilkes in there again. Siposs didnt play as a forward and if your not going to play him there then he needs to come out for real tall forward that can kick goals.

Think Ray can play a role on one the Blues small forwards or maybe Gibbs. Has been in great VFL form so think he's ahead of Ledger. Saad is probably unlucky but not sure theres room up forward for him with 3 talls, Milne & Milera aswell.

[Spinner]

IN:

Ledger


OUT:

Saad

[rexy]

Out Fisher
In Gwilt

[borderbarry]

Out Fisher (inj), Saad (did not do enough)
In. Wilkes (to play forward releasing Kosi and Stanley to ruck and Blake to defence)
Ray. Reward for effort at VFL.

[borderbarry]

Out Fisher (inj), Saad (did not do enough)
In. Wilkes (to play forward releasing Kosi and Stanley to ruck and Blake to defence)
Ray. Reward for effort at VFL.

[SainterK]

It's weird they have Fisher as test, would he be so lucky to have escaped injury?

Would they really drop Saad after one half of footy?

If Scott keeps up with his sneaky selections

No change

Emg Farren Wilkes Ledger

[stkildathunda]

It's weird they have Fisher as test, would he be so lucky to have escaped injury?

Would they really drop Saad after one half of footy?

If Scott keeps up with his sneaky selections

No change

Emg Farren Wilkes Ledger

Reckon it would be odds on that there is no change tonight. Its all about final teams for Scotty

[saintspremiers]

It's weird they have Fisher as test, would he be so lucky to have escaped injury?

Would they really drop Saad after one half of footy?

If Scott keeps up with his sneaky selections

No change

Emg Farren Wilkes Ledger

Reckon it would be odds on that there is no change tonight. Its all about final teams for Scotty

Agree.

Scott has made a good point re the farce in having to name a final 22 two days in advance.

IMO it should always be a squad on 25 named each Thursday night with the final 22 and sub released 90 minutes prior.

Would make much more sense.

BTW is our mythical 22 named on Sunday arvo given it's a Monday game??

[Richter]

IN: Wilkes, Ray, Ledger

OUT: Fisher, Polo, Milne

Stanley to no.1 ruck, Wilkes up forward as third tall (Kosi up forward and second ruck; Blake permanent defence)
Ray for Polo straight swap
Saad for Milne
Ledger to sub

[ThePunter]

Here's what I'd like:

Fisher to come up. (Now listed as "test".)
Gwilt to be included.
Gram to be excluded.

[borderbarry]

Is Armo able to play this week? He looked pretty crook with his back.

[Beno88]

It's weird they have Fisher as test, would he be so lucky to have escaped injury?

Would they really drop Saad after one half of footy?

If Scott keeps up with his sneaky selections

No change

Emg Farren Wilkes Ledger

Didn't Sam Fisher supposedly do a hamstring twice in 2010 (the game before he kicked the winner against WB and Round 22 before the finals), only to play the next week?

Maybe he's a quick healer? He has played 53 consectutive games.

[paddy]

Think Saad will Stay.

I like the idea of sharing the Ruck between 3,

Think wilkes should come in running as a forward when Stanley & Kosi rucks, and runs to the backline when Blake rucks.

Siposs was poor but, he should stay for another chance.

Wouldn't be upset if milney was rested (although he did fire last year in our first game against carlton), however we really need alot of forward defensive pressure to stop Yarran and co...

So to simplify:

In - Wilkes
Out - Fisher

[Teflon]

Surely Fisher is injured??? What BS is this test stuff ?

[Spinner]

Fisher's scan might have come up good.