Your top ten saints

[skeptic]

Nick Riewoldt...




that is all

[Dave McNamara]

...Now if only I could find someone who's old enough to have seen Billy Mohr, Roy Cazaly and Dave McNamara play. You still out there, P66?

Can't speak for P66 or Stinger, but I'm not old enough to have seen my first game... otherwise I'd have myself on this list.

1 Baldock (the only one I didn't see.)
2 Lockett
3 Harvey
4 Riewoldt
5 McIntosh
6 Young, G
7 Hayes
8 Barker
9 Winmar (Could be higher if rated only for skill, but I still rate him as the 2nd best indiginous player I've seen, behind Maurice Rioli - RIP)
10 Lawrence, B

Apologies: Fisher, Superduper, Burnsy, Cowboy, McNamara.


PS: The fact that Spider, with all his talent, isn't on anyone's list says something...

[whiskers3614]

!plugger

2Barker
3Hayes
4Kozi
5Aussie
6BJ
7Dal
8Cowboy
9Muir
10Perovic

My favourites

[Winmar]

I started going in 1989, so of the ones in my time:

1. Plugger
2. Harvs
3. Riewoldt
4. Winmar
5. Loewe
6. Goddard
7. Burke
8. Hayes
9. Gehrig
10. Grant

I saw Barks, but only in his last year; otherwise I'm sure he'd be in there. I'm sure I've omitted plenty of worth contenders too, like Hudghton.

[Toy Saint]

Best since 1964

1. Plugger
2. Ian Stewart
3. Nick Riewoldt
4. Goddard
5. Baldock
6. Robert Harvey
7. George Young
8. Lenny Hayes
9. John McIntosh
10. Dal Santo

11. Winmar
12. Leowe
13. Nathan Burke
14. Carl Ditterich
15. Spider
16. Frawley
17. Barker
18. Milne
19. Sam Fisher
20. Gerhig

[St Lenny]

10 is not enough, unless you are very young. Id also say what about Hamill or Barry Breen?

[Tom_Sainter]

1. Tony Lockett
2. Robert Harvey
3. Nick Riewoldt
4. Lenny Hayes
5. Nicky Winmar
6. Nick Dal Santo
7. Stewart Loewe
8. Nathan Burke
9. Brendan Goddard
10. Danny Frawley

[WinnersOnly]

•Ian Stewart (1965, 66) won 3 x brownlows and played in winning GF team.
• Robert Harvey (1997, 98)
•Ross Smith (1967)
•Tony Lockett (1987)
•Brian Gleeson (1957)
•Neil Roberts (1958)
•Verdun Howell (1959)
•Colin Watson (1925)
Above all Brownlow winners.

- Lenny Hayes
- Stewart Loewe
- Nick Reiwoldt
- Nick WInmar

[dragit]

•Ian Stewart (1965, 66) won 3 x brownlows and played in winning GF team.
• Robert Harvey (1997, 98)
•Ross Smith (1967)
•Tony Lockett (1987)
•Brian Gleeson (1957)
•Neil Roberts (1958)
•Verdun Howell (1959)
•Colin Watson (1925)
Above all Brownlow winners.

- Lenny Hayes
- Stewart Loewe
- Nick Reiwoldt
- Nick WInmar

How did Colin Watson go?
Your list looks a little like our highest brownlow vote-winners…

[WinnersOnly]

They are all our brownlow winners...

[Dave McNamara]

•Ian Stewart (1965, 66) won 3 x brownlows and played in winning GF team.
• Robert Harvey (1997, 98)
•Ross Smith (1967)
•Tony Lockett (1987)
•Brian Gleeson (1957)
•Neil Roberts (1958)
•Verdun Howell (1959)
•Colin Watson (1925)
Above all Brownlow winners.

- Lenny Hayes
- Stewart Loewe
- Nick Reiwoldt
- Nick WInmar

Dave McNamara (1907, 1914 - Champion of the Colony Medal)

[White Winmar]

Dave McNamara, Champion of the Colony, 1907, 1914. Still posting on Saintsational, 2012. Legend!

[rhino]

1. Lockett
2. Harvey
3. Hayes
4. Loewe
5. Hamill
6. Dal Santo
7. Grant
8. Reiwoldt
9. Winmar
10. Heatley

[R. Harvey 3 votes!]

1. Jayson Daniels
2. Michael Frost
3. Glen Nugent
4. Damian Kitchke
5. Cayden Beethem
6. Tony Antrabos
7. David Strooper
8. Kristen Bardsley
9. Mark Arcery
10. Brian Winton

[CJC]

Favourites,

Baker,
G Train,
Lenny,
Hamill,
Max,
Plugger,
Winmar,
Aussie,
Milne,
Peckett

[whiskers3614]

1. Jayson Daniels
2. Michael Frost
3. Glen Nugent
4. Damian Kitchke
5. Cayden Beethem
6. Tony Antrabos
7. David Strooper
8. Kristen Bardsley
9. Mark Arcery
10. Brian Winton

No Cain Ackland, Gordon Fode?

[whiskers3614]

1 Lovett
2 Barrott
3 B.Wilson
4 J.Krakouer
5.Wow Jones
6. Foschini
7. M.Jackson
8.Capuano
9.J.Plapp
10.all the other ex-Carlton superannuants!

[Dave McNamara]

Dave McNamara, Champion of the Colony, 1907, 1914. Still posting on Saintsational, 2012. Legend!

(Clean living... and cryogenics. )

[bergholt]

1 Rodney Gladman
2 Glenn MacMillan
3 Christian Lister
4 Nick Hanson
5 Leigh Capsalis
6 Dean Matthews
7 Chris Hemley
8 Fergus Watts
9 Justin Sweeney
10 Colm Begley
11 Will Johnson

[Bernard Shakey]

1 Plugger
2 Doc
3 Harvey
4 Lenny
5 Stewart
6 McIntosh
7 Winmar
8 Ditterich
9 Roo
10 Barker

[maverick]

Plugger

Harvey
Roo
Lenny
Winmar
Barks
BJ
Burkey
Buckets
Gehrig

[Thomas]

Lockett.......Best ever
Harvey........very close to best ever
Baldock.......Mister magic
Hayes.........Saints current best
Burke..........Guts and determination personified
Frawley.......Saints best full back
Stewart.......best centre in his era
Barker.........could play anywhere most loved saint of all time
Winmar.......Most skilled saint ever pure silk
Fisher.........Defence General

Others........Breen, Murray, Loewe, Barry Lawrence, Howell, Roo, McIntoch (Could have been one of the greatest if not for injury that cut short his career)

[plugger66]

Lockett.......Best ever
Harvey........very close to best ever
Baldock.......Mister magic
Hayes.........Saints current best
Burke..........Guts and determination personified
Frawley.......Saints best full back
Stewart.......best centre in his era
Barker.........could play anywhere most loved saint of all time
Winmar.......Most skilled saint ever pure silk
Fisher.........Defence General

Others........Breen, Murray, Loewe, Lawrence, Howell, McIntoch (Could have been one of the greatest if not for injury that cut short his career)

I know it is only an opinion but surely Rooy could at least get in your others especially as you have Allan Murray and Steve Lawrence in there.

[Thomas]

Ok Roo could sneak in, By Lawrence I mean his Dad Barry, Murray Bob.

[whiskers3614]

Plugger.
light sarcasm goes straight over the top, need to hit them with sledgehammer not tickle with a feather!