At the end of 2012 who will be our best 5?

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Kosi is s*** and was a massive blunder picking him at number 2 in the National Draft. Harsh but true. (Injuries have played a part though).

To quote you from another thread that's a bullsh*t post citywest ... Look at the top ten picks Of that year only Didak is worth considering

[hungry for a premiership]

[quote="Con Gorozidis"]I think after 2012 - Lendog and milney should hang them up and we should trade BJ to GWS for a top 10 pick.

Yeah, let's just cut out the heart and soul of the club for one untried, unproven teenager.

[Con Gorozidis]

I think after 2012 - Lendog and milney should hang them up and we should trade BJ to GWS for a top 10 pick.

Yeah, let's just cut out the heart and soul of the club for one untried, unproven teenager.

No cutting. They will walk off in to the sunset after winning our first flag in 50 years.
High fives aplenty.

[plugger66]

I think after 2012 - Lendog and milney should hang them up and we should trade BJ to GWS for a top 10 pick.

Top 5
NDS
Fisher
Gilbo
Steven
McEvoy

Is it April Fools day. What is your first paragraph about?

nonsense. if goddard wants to go to gws they will just take him for free, keep their pick, and we'll get compo.

Sorry I didnt realise you wanted Lenny and Milney to retire too even though this year hasnt started.

?

for me, BJ must not be traded ever (barring a ridiculously good offer) and lenny & milne to play as long as they want and as long as they are still effective, i reckon at least 2 more seasons each.

Sorry it sounded like the nonsense was directed at my comment.

[gringo]

I think after 2012 - Lendog and milney should hang them up and we should trade BJ to GWS for a top 10 pick.

Top 5
NDS
Fisher
Gilbo
Steven
McEvoy

Is it April Fools day. What is your first paragraph about?

nonsense. if goddard wants to go to gws they will just take him for free, keep their pick, and we'll get compo.

Sorry I didnt realise you wanted Lenny and Milney to retire too even though this year hasnt started.

?

for me, BJ must not be traded ever (barring a ridiculously good offer) and lenny & milne to play as long as they want and as long as they are still effective, i reckon at least 2 more seasons each.

Sorry it sounded like the nonsense was directed at my comment.

you should be used to it by now plugger:)

[whiskers3614]

Mc.Evoy
Steven
Goddard
Armitage
Montagna
If too many of Riewoldt,Fisher,Milne,Hayes are still in our top 5 we are in deep poo going forward(due to their age).

[The Redeemer]

Mc.Evoy
Steven
Goddard
Armitage
Montagna
If too many of Riewoldt,Fisher,Milne,Hayes are still in our top 5 we are in deep poo going forward(due to their age).

Stevens' best remotely close to Lenny's? I will go on record as saying no...not even in 5 years compared to Lenny's best. Same with Armitage.

Big Mac needs to become big and important and actually become a top level ruck (some and about 5 years too early). Bit of a shame he is not a few years older considering the age of our list (better players being older).

[PJ]

Not sure about top 5 but the selection of rookies looks interesting. I'm hoping Ferg and Cam Shenton can have an impact this year - key position defender and mid.

[borderbarry]

Runner up in the Brownlow but not good enough to get in the Clubs top five?

[whiskers3614]

Runner up in the Brownlow but not good enough to get in the Clubs top five?

Wouldn't it be good if established stars had decent seasons but the new boys overtook them anyway.

[older saint]

IF we are to make the top 4 the answer needs to be :
Top 5
Goddard
Roo
McEvoy
Fisher
Dal Santo

5 Improving on the list:
Stanley
Siposs
Ledger
Cripps
Winmar

5 Break in to the team
Stanley
Sipposs
Simpkins
Cripps
Ledger

If it reads :

Fisher
Goddard
Roo
Dal
Milne

Ray
Steven
Armitage
Polo
Gram

Simpkin
Polo
R Clarke
Saad
Stanley

We could be in for a long year

[whiskers3614]

Especially if Polo doesn't have a twin!