Trade rumours - post them here

BonoRocks · Post: # 1159151Post **BonoRocks** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:33pm

stkildathunda wrote:Chris Bond from Fremantle declares his club has no interest in Farren Ray or Brett Peake

So still hope for zac then, please make it happen

MC Gusto · Post: # 1159152Post **MC Gusto** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:33pm

we need two top 10 picks for BJ - not going to happen

Ralphy · Post: # 1159153Post **Ralphy** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:34pm

BonoRocks wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:Chris Bond from Fremantle declares his club has no interest in Farren Ray or Brett Peake
So still hope for zac then, please make it happen

hope so....

IluvHarvey · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:37pm

Ralphy wrote:
BonoRocks wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:Chris Bond from Fremantle declares his club has no interest in Farren Ray or Brett Peake
So still hope for zac then, please make it happen
hope so....

Who plays full back then?

Old Mate · Post: # 1159155Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:39pm

Greg Swan just said that BJ is 100% not coming to Carlton or leaving the Saints. He said the Saints said straight up that he wasn't available or to be discussed.

Dis Believer · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:39pm

stkildathunda wrote:Chris Bond from Fremantle declares his club has no interest in Farren Ray or Brett Peake

The important thing here seems to be in what he doesn't say - and he doesn't say they have no interest in Zac Dawson, yet all three have been publicly listed as potential trade targets for Freo in the past few days.

Does that mean potentially "good bye Zac"? Hope not, under-rated by many here, but get s the job done and is not one we have a ready replacement for, postiion wise.

Dis Believer · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:40pm

Old Mate wrote:Greg Swan just said that BJ is 100% not coming to Carlton or leaving the Saints. He said the Saints said straight up that he wasn't available or to be discussed.

Well the plonkers won't believe our own officials, maybe they'll believe someone else's !!!

VietNam_Saint · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:46pm

I am not sure how much money we'd free up , imagine a fair bit , but i think we should put Kosi up.

samoht · Post: # 1159167Post **samoht** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:52pm

I hope we only trade for players we need .. no more half back flankers please !

We need ..
A line breaking player or 2 .. like a Varcoe type (just as an example)

A fast medium forward or 2 .. like a Dangerfield type (as an example).

They need to be young and talented .. otherwise why bother.

Dis Believer · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:53pm

The name I saw floated somewhere (can't remember where) that I found interesting was Raph.

Had not much of a mention for the most part and apparently Ro$$ and also Vossy are keen on him.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1159169Post **MCG-Unit** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:53pm

MC Gusto wrote:we need two top 10 picks for BJ - not going to happen

Must be 2 in the top 10 - or 1 top 10 + an A Grade player.

IF he were to be traded, which he's not

SaintPav · Post: # 1159170Post **SaintPav** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:54pm

Old Mate wrote:Greg Swan just said that BJ is 100% not coming to Carlton or leaving the Saints. He said the Saints said straight up that he wasn't available or to be discussed.

You're such an old mate.

The Saintsational Man · Mon 10 Oct 2011 3:56pm

True Believer wrote:The name I saw floated somewhere (can't remember where) that I found interesting was Raph.

Had not much of a mention for the most part and apparently Ro$$ and also Vossy are keen on him.

I think the "steak knives" jokes will follow.....

St Ick · Post: # 1159172Post **St Ick** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:01pm

Goddard is worth O'Meara, plus top 3 draft pick & say late first to early second rounder, that would be a good trade. That being said, wont go anywhere... THIS YEAR... I'd like him to stay with the club but wont be happy if we lose him next year.

With the other trade, here are some #'s;
- Tom Lynch @ 21yo, 192cm, 87kgs, 6 games of footy very limited opportunities, pick 13

- Jack Gunston @ 19yo, 193cm, 83kgs, 14 games, some of which he played very well against poor sides, pick 29.

Seems like for like, but I think Gunston is a bit quicker, good lead and good mark. As much as I think Lynch will be a good smart footballer, I think Gunston will be a great player based on what little I have seen of them both. We'd probably have to swap our later picks and drop down a few rungs in the order to make it happen.

Put it this way, Gunston, Siposs and Stanley sounds a lot stronger in years to come than Lynch, Siposs and Stanley.

Old Mate · Post: # 1159175Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:05pm

samoht wrote:I hope we only trade for players we need .. no more half back flankers please !

We need ..
A line breaking player or 2 .. like a Varcoe type (just as an example)

A fast medium forward or 2 .. like a Dangerfield type (as an example).

They need to be young and talented .. otherwise why bother.

I hope we only trade for picks or players born post 1990

stkildathunda · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:06pm

AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.

Old Mate · Post: # 1159177Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:07pm

stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.

Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.

rexy · Post: # 1159178Post **rexy** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:07pm

Adelaide in dire need of defenders, surely this must be their interest in Lynch, personally I would look at Lynch and Walsh as replacements for Dawson and Blake so think we need to keep Lynch?

stkildathunda · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:08pm

Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.

Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.

Old Mate · Post: # 1159181Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:12pm

stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.
Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.

Maric 26 next year and entering his peak as a ruckman. All in all I think it's a fair trade for both parties.

Rosco · Post: # 1159183Post **Rosco** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:13pm

stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.
Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.

yeah, over the odds for 25 yo ruckman who hasn't shown that much

stkildathunda · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:15pm

Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.
Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.
Maric 26 next year and entering his peak as a ruckman. All in all I think it's a fair trade for both parties.

Lynch for Maric i do agree would be a fair trade, but noway would i want us to give them pick 20 for him...

Ralphy · Post: # 1159185Post **Ralphy** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:18pm

Damian Barrett reporting on @TradeWeekRadio that X Ellis is open to leaving Hawks, with Ess, North, StK and Adel all interested.

Old Mate · Post: # 1159186Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:18pm

stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.
Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.
Maric 26 next year and entering his peak as a ruckman. All in all I think it's a fair trade for both parties.
Lynch for Maric i do agree would be a fair trade, but noway would i want us to give them pick 20 for him...

Totally agree. I don't believe we will give up our first couple of picks.

elizabethr · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:24pm

[quote="Ralphy"]Damian Barrett reporting on @TradeWeekRadio that X Ellis is open to leaving Hawks, with Ess, North, StK and Adel all interested.[/quote
Already got enough weak outside underdeveloped players thanks.

]